PHOENIX – Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio on Thursday unveiled preliminary results of an investigation, conducted by members of his volunteer task force, into the authenticity of President Barack Obama's birth certificate, a controversy that has been widely debunked but that remains alive for the so-called birther movement.
At a news conference, Arpaio, whose office is facing a federal inquiry involving alleged racial profiling, said the probe revealed that there was probable cause to believe Obama's long-form birth certificate released by the White House in April is a computer-generated forgery. He also said the selective service card completed by Obama in 1980 in Hawaii also was most likely a forgery.
"We don't know who the perpetrators are of these documents," Arpaio said, although he said he doesn't think the president forged the documents.
On Thursday, Obama's campaign spokesman Ben LaBolt offered a light-hearted dismissal of Arpaio's probe — he tweeted what he referred to as a "live link" to the sheriff's news conference, but instead provided a link to a snippet of the old conspiracy-theory based TV series, "The X-Files."

Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio talks to reporters about the birth certificate investigation.
The sheriff said a forensic examination of the electronic document that the White House provided last year proves that it was not simply scanned to create a computer file but rather assembled from several pieces, East Valley Tribune.com reported.
Arpaio's probe comes amid a federal grand jury investigation into the sheriff's office on criminal abuse-of-power allegations since at least December 2009, focusing on the sheriff's anti-public corruption squad. Separately, the U.S. Justice Department has accused Arpaio's office of racially profiling Latinos, basing immigration enforcement on racially charged citizen complaints and punishing Hispanic jail inmates for speaking Spanish. Arpaio denies the allegations and said the investigation is politically motivated.
Earlier Thursday, the 79-year-old Republican sheriff defended his need to spearhead the investigation into Obama's birth certificate by saying that nearly 250 people connected to a conservative Arizona Tea Party group requested one last summer.
"I'm not going after Obama," said Arpaio, who has criticized the president's administration for cutting off his federal immigration powers and conducting the civil rights investigation of his office. "I'm just doing my job."
Speculation about Obama's birthplace has swirled among conservatives for years. "Birthers" maintain that Obama is ineligible to hold the country's highest elected office because, they contend, he was born in Kenya, his father's homeland. Some contend Obama's birth certificate must be a fake.
Hawaii officials have repeatedly confirmed that Obama was born there, meaning he's a native-born American, and Obama released a copy of his long-form birth certificate in April. Courts also have rebuffed lawsuits over the issue. Of late, the president's re-election campaign has poked fun at it, selling coffee cups with a picture of the president's birth record.
Some critics suggest Arpaio's aim is to divert attention from his own legal troubles while raising his political profile as he seeks a sixth term this year. The sheriff vehemently denies such strategies are in play.
Critics also have sought Arpaio's resignation over allegations that more than 400 sex-crimes cases over a three-year period ending in 2007 were either inadequately investigated or weren't investigated at all by the Sheriff's Office after the crimes were reported. The Sheriff's Office said the backlog was cleared up after the problem was brought to Arpaio's attention.
Arpaio has said he took deliberate steps to avoid the appearance that his investigation is politically motivated. Instead of using taxpayer money, the sheriff farmed it out to lawyers and retired police officers who are volunteers in a posse that examines cold cases for him. Other posses assist deputies in duties that include providing free police protection at malls during the holiday season or transporting people to jail.
The sheriff remains popular among Republicans. GOP presidential candidates have courted his endorsement throughout the primary season. At last week's Republican presidential debate in Arizona, Arpaio won loud cheers. During a question about Arizona's border woes, former Sen. Rick Santorum said the government ought to give local police agencies the chance to enforce immigration law as Arpaio has.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
More content from msnbc.com and NBC News


It's a little too late now , for this birth certificate issue to go on any longer ....
But for any president who sue's a state for enforcing U.S. immigration laws , when it is surely out of control ....
Certainly doesn't have the best interest of that state or the country in mind ....
Arizona isn't just "enforcing U.S. immigration laws." SB 1070 went further than US national laws to the point where it conflicted with Federal law. If you look up the judges decision she explains exactly why. The key word is "preemption."
Ben , it's never to late to expose LIBERAL lies !
It's a little too late now , for this birth certificate issue to go on any longer ....
You are correct. The "birthing "issue has been already played many times by many people, including that a*****e Donald Trump.
What this racist, dumb sheriff needs to do, is concentrating in all the problems in Arizona. He should go an help the DEA in the enforcing of the law with all the drug lords in AZ, instead of finding things to entertain himself, so others can take a bullet for him.
Ben , it's never to late to expose LIBERAL lies
Another "brilliant" statement, considering how "truthful" Romney and Santorum are...
Get a grip!
Johnny N. Neither is it ever too late to expose right-wing bigoted Republican lies!!!!!!!!! Found those WMD'S YET in Iraq???????
Man, ignorance is bliss...cant fix stupid, that's for sure
Ok Johnny I think it might be time to take your meds and take the tin foil hat off. If your not on meds get some. Obama was born in the US so move on like most republitards have. The birther issue makes them look like idiots not that it takes much to do that.
Why is Obama's social security number out of an Eastern State if he was born in Hawaii?
*Facepalm*
Will the insanity ever cease? Losing faith in humanity, one conservative at a time...
This is the Sheriff Joe version of "Look! Squirrels!"
Oh gods, Arpaio's making an ass of himself again. Please guys, understand that not everyone in Arizona is a complete @!$%#ing moron. I know that's hard to believe given all the headlines...
No, Toasty, Joe's making an ass out of all of you angry, supercilious, self righteous libs. You all sound like little kids who've just been told politics is only for grown ups. He is second only to Limbaugh in the ability to enrage lefties who can dish out the attack crap, but can't take even a little bit.
Sherriff Joe:
A think he wus conseeved by aleeans frum outa space thet landed in that ther Haweee rownd about the time he sez he wuz born. There are witnesses hu saw tha aleen ship land and we all no ther is a guverment cover up goin on. An we all no that them space aleens are Muzlims.
I know all of the good folks in AZ arent nuts like Arpaio, Toasty (I'm in Chandler at least 3 days a month) but I have to admit, that I am always a little EXTRA cautious when I drive in Maricopa County. I dont want to be pulled over by one of Sheriff Joe's troops & arrested for DWG. I look TERRIBLE in pink!
So Sheriff Joe is going to walk in to court and testify under oath that according to the evidence at hand that Obama's Birth Certificate "may" be a fogery........oh I am sure the taxpayers in Ariz. who are paying his salary are so happy to have had him investigate such an important issue to the people in Ariz and come up with such a solid statment, Donald "dump" Trump came up with the same answer.....but at least he paid for his garbage.
Stupidity does not upset me Spider.....it is an inherited trait can't do much about it, one thing I have noticed though is that stupid people seem to attract people with the same inherited trait, so you could say stupid loves company....thus the lower end of the gene pool is created, how's the water down that end of the pool?
Roger Ramjet, Zip code for Hawaii where Obama lived 96814 in 1977. Zip code for Connecticut 06814 in 1977. Now which is more possible? 1. A clerical error by one of those lazy stupid government workers sponging off the taxpayers.2. A massive conspiracy perpetrated in 1977 by a illegal alien 15 year old boy who knew that in 30 years he would be seeking the one job in America that you have to be a natural born citizen to hold. 3. Maybe because Obama writes with his left hand the honest hard working intelligent government worker just misread his nine for a zero. 4. A simple typewriting mistake by the government worker 9 and 0 are on keys that are right next to each other. Now go back and resume your search for bigfoot and UFOS.
Really Spider, the corruption charges and investigations have nothing to do with it...?
Presumably the point is to prevent Obama from being able to sit a second term; however, I find it impossible to believe Hawaii would allow such a fraud to be perpetuated in their name. If there were any doubt of the validity of one of their birth certificates, Hawaii would be very quick to affirm or deny. Not to mention the country were he was supposedly born also being in on the conspiracy since they would have to suppress the truth of their own records.
This is the problem with conspiracy theories -- they usually defy logic.
Nicely said Really 8) Both the Republicans and Democrats are being difficult but it also depends on the State you live 8) Cali is completely going to hell and we can thank Democrats for that 8) The dem legislature is raping us tax payers to no end.
All I see is a big Circle Jerk in Congress. (We need border security)
I feel deep resentment towards this President every time he does something or nothing I can't stand him or even look at him.. 4 years and I am more broke and losing my house to Wells Fargo because they are evil douche bags who have no Soul.
40 year adjustable mortgage with a balloon rider of 159k at the end is just plain @!$%# modification.
Take your HAMP program and choke on it 8p
I cannot attest to the validity of the sheriff's claims, but my college student son found something interesting with the PDF of the birth certificate that the White House uploaded to the Internet ( gov/sites/default/files/rss_viewer /birth-certificate.pdf) (please remove spaces) using Inkscape, which is an open source vector graphics editor, like Adobe Illustrator.
PDFs can hold image data or text data. In President Obama's case, as this was supposed to be a scanned birth certificate, it should have been a single layer of image data. However, when opened up in Inkscape, the multiple layers are obvious. A youtube that shows a young man visually explaining this can be found at: https ://www.youtube.com/ watch?v= 7s9StxsFllY (please remove spaces)
I consider myself an open-minded person. When I watch my son download the certificate from the White House site, and peel back layers that removes information that "proves" Obama's story, then I become a little less likely to believe him in other things.
Prof - you need to show that Hawaii does not use photo shop or any other graphic program to assemble the Birth certificate.
the real issue is the issued number was one on the birth certificate that it's issue date put it out of sequence by several days for when it should have been issued.
Yes, the social security number is from a state that Obama never lived in, but his dad did. However, Obama's job in Hawaii was several years before should have required him to supply a social security job. Since records on employment may not be saved for a variety of reasons, you may never get to the bottom of that one.
Just vote the guy out in November - this other stuff is just too far over too many people's heads.
And not a single progressive that is attacking the Sheriff has refuted or even attempted to refute the evidence provided that shows Obama's LFBC to be a forgery. Not that I don't find faults in the Sheriff's presentation. For example the LFBC shows Obama's father as being from Kenya, Africa. The country was not called officially named "Kenya" until 1963. So why does Obama's 1961 LFBC use that as the name of Obama's fathers country of origin? It also lists the hospital as Kapiolani Maternity and Gynecological Hospital. The facility did not use this name until 1978. This is straight off of http://www.kapiolani.org/women-and-children/about-us/default.aspx check it out for yourself.
My biggest complaint regarding the Sheriffs investigation is IT WAS NOT NECESSARY. Obama readily admits that his father was NOT a U.S. citizen. In order to be a "Natural Born" citizen BOTH parents must be citizens. It really is that simple. The 14th amendment says nothing about being a "Natural Born" citizen. Nor does it say anything about changing the "Natural Born citizen" requirement to hold the office of President.
Shall we now discuss Obama's selective service registration and the glaring problem with that document? The post office stamp on the document uses a two digit format (80) for the year. The post office ALWAYS uses the four digit format for the year on it's date stamps. Apparently the creator of this document was unable to locate a 1980 year stamp so they cut a 2008 stamp in half and inserted the 08 part upside down in the stamper to get 80. Check out this link. http://www.azcentral.com/12news/news/articles/2012/03/01/20120301video-obama-birth-certificate-arpaio.html
OH SWEET JESUS!
Ignorance, hate and intolerance truly know no bounds.
Obama/Biden 2012
I don't care if he is from Mars....he got the US and Aust out of Iraq and now is working to get us out of Afghanistan.....maybe you needed someone from another dimension to get it done....now hopefully he can get to work on the other things that people actually voted him in for ..... like not giving tax dollars to global oil conglomerates, turning attention to renewable energy sources, better opportunities for further education.....stuff you boneheaded Repubs just don't get....He won the election in a landslide because he presented his and his parties position and that is what the majority of the people voted for....get it, that is how democracy works. Now you guys put John "Crash" McCain and Stupid Sarah up and they articulated (hate to use that word in reference to anything Sarah but it just came up) theirs and their parties policies.....and people smelled the same old rat and didn't vote for them. Get over it....might as well because Rick and the Flim Flam man ain't gonna do it, and the Birth Certificate issue has already been settled....so you can keep diggin' around in the trash bins or you can get on with it....your choice.
And you idiot you do not have to have 2 Natural US parents to be a Natural Citizen all you have to do is be born in the US or of at least 1 US parent....a fact that seems to be lost on you folks and of course you know that Crash McCain was not born in the US but that doesn't seem to matter and Sarah...not even sure she was born on this planet. My daughters are Natural US Citizens and they have one parent that is a US Citizen and were not even born in the US ..... there is this thing called Registration of Overseas Birth....watch out my daughters could be President one day.
You got it Yank. I don't care if his Dad was a purple-people-eater and he was born on Alpha Centauri. He's doing a good job. He's the man to save us from ourselves (well, at least save the ditto-heads from themselves and the hate-mongers).
Keep up the good work Mr. President.
Obama/Biden 2012
Not really. The date for our Iraqi departure was fixed by Bush before Obama took office and the projected departure from Afghanistan in 2014 is still only tentative.
Funniest comment of the day.
Somebody buy dmac a new roll of tin foil.
Arpaio's contributions from out of state must be dwindling. He needed to get back in the headlines so nutcases and bigots from all around America would start sending him money again. He gets a few million a year that way.
EMDF9A: Stay out of Chandler, Chandler is apart of Maricopa County.... Opps I guess you did not know that....
For all you conspiracy people:
The Honolulu newspapers carried President Obama's birth announcement a few days after he was born. Are you really suggesting that they (whoever they is) planned to elect him president when he was only day old????
I keep on reading from some people that in order for a person to be a US President, he must be natural born US Citizen and both parents have to be Natural Born US Citizens. Educate me with references; where on the US constitution is this required? If you do not have the reference, do not reply. If you reply without the reference, it only prooves how stupid you are....
ElAgente777: Here is a little information for you.
Section 1 of Article Two of the United States Constitution sets forth the eligibility requirements for serving as president of the United States:
No person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty-five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States.
Naturalized Citizen:
One who, having been born in another country or otherwise reared as a foreigner, has been granted U.S. citizenship and the rights and privileges of that status. The process by which such a person attains citizenship is called naturalization.
(or “the conferring of nationality of a state upon a person after birth, by any means whatsoever.”) 8 U.S.C. §§23 and 1421 et seq. The person seeking naturalization must satisfy the burden of establishing good moral character and must be a resident of the United States for five years. 8 U.S.C. §1427.
In 2008, when the Democrats raised the question of whether GOP presidential candidate Senator John McCain was a natural born citizen, the U.S. Senate looked into the matter and decided McCain is one.
On April 30, 2008, the Senate passed a resolution — that Obama himself had signed — to that effect, “Recognizing that John Sidney McCain, III, is a natural born citizen.” SR 511 states the following:
“Whereas the Constitution of the United States requires that, to be eligible for the Office of the President, a person must be a `natural born Citizen’ of the United States;
“Whereas the term `natural born Citizen’, as that term appears in Article II, Section 1, is not defined in the Constitution of the United States;
Whereas there is no evidence of the intention of the Framers or any Congress to limit the constitutional rights of children born to Americans serving in the military nor to prevent those children from serving as their country’s President;…
Whereas John Sidney McCain, III, was born to American citizens on an American military base in the Panama Canal Zone in 1936: Now, therefore, be it
Resolved, That John Sidney McCain, III, is a `natural born Citizen’ under Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution of the United States.”
In other words, the U.S. Senate defines “natural born citizen” as an individual who was born:
By that definition, Obama is not a Natural Born Citizen — even if he produces definitive documentary proof he was born in Hawaii — because his father, Barack Hussein Obama, Sr., was a native Kenyan and a British colonial subject who gave his Kenyan citizenship to his son. In fact, by pro-Obama FactCheck.org’s own admission, Obama was a Kenyan citizen until his Kenyan citizenship expired on August 4, 1984 after he had reached adulthood.
You also need to understand the Federal law:
US Citizen Parent(s) Citizenship Concerns
For a child born abroad to a U.S. citizen out of wedlock (or more specifics on the above situations), click here.
You should report the birth of a child abroad (outside the United States) to establish US citizenship. The birth of a child abroad (or overseas) to a U.S. citizen parent(s) should be reported as soon as possible to the nearest U.S. embassy or consulateto establish an official record of the child's claim to U.S. citizenship at birth. The official record is a Consular Report of Birth of a Citizen of the United States of America, or Form FS-240. This document, known as the Consular Report of Birth Abroad, is a basic United States citizenship document. An original FS-240 is furnished to the parents at the time the registration is approved. A Consular Report of Birth can be prepared only at a U.S. embassy or consulate. It cannot be prepared if the child has been brought back into the United States (although a different document may be requested - see the next two paragraphs), or, if the child is 18 years of age or older at the time the application is made. For more information, see Documentation of U.S. Citizens Born Abroad Who Acquire Citizenship at Birth.
If the child returns to the U.S. without a Form FS-240 being filed, an application may be made for a Certificate of Citizenship. Obtaining this certificate involves presentation of basically the same documentation required to obtain a Consular Report of Birth. Under law, the Consular Report of Birth and the Certificate of Citizenship are equally acceptable as proof of citizenship. File USCIS Form N-600 (Application for Certificate of Citizenship) with your nearest USCIS office.
If Obamas mother was outside of the US or just came back and was not in the US for X amount of DAYS and failed to file appropriate forms on Obamas BIRTH. Then he is IN FACT not eligible to be President. Even if he him self filed and was given US Citizenship later in life. That still would make him ineligible to be PRESIDENT.
Left **** the facts and LAW we make them as we go.
These Republicans just don't know how to focus on real issues. Obama is our president. Get over it.
Hopefully that'll be over with this year :).
If his office is finding it to be not real then if I was a prisoner in one of hs jails I would want a new trial as he is proving his police skills are wrong
Arpaio needs to resign, now.
Grab some popcorn, this just gets more entertaining every day.
I forsee your panties being bunched for another four years...
The economy must be purring along pretty well, since the right suddenly wants the election decided on birth control and a birth certificate. Which is ironic in itself.
"No, no -- look over here! Over here, dammit!!"
Cruisebait; if you like BIG GOVERMENT telling you exactly what you can or can't do, then vote for this j#@#! If you like SOCIALISM/ COMMUNISM, then vote for him! If you hate Christians, and love muslims, then vote for him! If you happen to be an illegal, then vote for him! If your a loafer or welfare alumni, then vote for him! You definitly belong in one of these groups. that's the facts jack.
You have no idea where this is headed, with the press conference he had tonight. He has given a reasonable doubt, which will turn into a criminal investigation. You will be screaming repub conspiracy, when you find out what the implications of a criminal investigation does to a sitting president. So I find it hilarious that you are mocking him..
It's funny but when Mitt's daddy George ran for president, I don't recall the fact he was born in Mexico being even mentioned as an issue. But now we have a Christian, capitalist, native Hawaiian who is half black in the White House and the GOP extremists insist he is a Muslim, socialist, foreigner who is secretly planning on confiscating everyone's guns. Seriously. Rod Serling would love this! LOL.
President Obama has been a phenomenal dismal president, undoubtedly
has no clue in what needs to be done to solve the woes
of the economy. Government is not the solution, government is the problem, this is
so true with this administration. Cannot wait to November to vote this non-American out.
As Rush said liberals have mental disorders and your acceptance of what he has
accomplished proves the point of your mental status. It is hard to believe
the principles and values the liberals have adopted, which in my opinion are not God like principles. It said in the Bible things which are good will be made evil and evil will be made good, wow, has the liberals made this prophecy come true.
Also, what about over 5 trillion in new debt, over 8% unemployment which actually
per the Gallup Poll is more like 9% than 8.3 % and 19% for people who are under-employed.
As for Iraq, I thought the Democrats had said the war was lost?
I'm just getting started, but I know it is in vain, as you don't have a clue as to where this President is trying to take this country, that is why he is un-American.
TexasLaw and John1, as long as the Republican party keeps listening to those on the extreme right, like you both, this President's job is safe. What could have been a slam dunk victory for the GOP has been destroyed by stupidity, insanity, racial intolerance, absurd social attacks, disrespect for the rights of workers. Just when I think the GOP has gone as far right as possible and shown such tremendous lack of civility, they manage to upstage themselves. Jeez, what losers.
The Left think tanks has been desperately trying to figure out a new Obama campaign slogan since the last one (Hope and Change) FAILED miserably. Sheeesh, it has been weeks since they started this endeavor.
A quick review of Mr. Obama's agenda and the following NEW campaign slogan comes immediately to mind:
veteran44, you and all the rest of the right-wing nutjobs must be the biggest idiots in the country. None of you have the first clue what 'socialism' is. You throw that word around as if it were some sort of insult, all the while you willfully ignore the greatest financial disaster perpetrated (by the GOP) on this nation, since the 19th century.
Even though you are probably too close-minded to understand it, here is the definition of socialism:
1. An economic theory or system in which the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned by the community collectively. It is characterized by production for use rather than profit, and by equality of individual wealth rather than an unequal distribution of wealth with a small percentage of individuals controlling almost all of the money supply.
2. Any of various social or political theories or movements in which the common welfare is to be achieved through the establishment of a economic system where the economic security and benefit of fellow citizens is placed ahead of the accumulation of individual wealth.
Sounds to me like you don't like people who aren't wealthy. That means most of the population of the United States. How can you claim to love America, when you clearly hate most Americans?
Thomas Jefferson was, by this definition, a socialist. So was George Washington. And James Madison, Samuel Adams, and Benjamin Franklin. Along with most of the other founding fathers. Have you ever even read the Constitution and Declaration of Independence? I doubt it. And apparently, you couldn't even understand it if you did, else you wouldn't spout such vitriol.
Here are a few more facts for you… I doubt you have the ability to even acknowledge them as factual.
These are facts relating to one president only. Name him.
1. He violated more international treaties than any other president in U.S. history.
2. He is the first president in U.S. history to have the United Nations remove the U.S. from the Human Rights Commission during his administration, and also withdrew the U.S. from the World Court of Law.
3. This president’s administration set an all-time record for most home foreclosures in any 12-month period. More families have lost their homes than during the first three years of this President’s administration than during those of any other THREE U.S. Presidents combined.
4. This president inherited the largest budget surplus in U.S. history. Before the end of his first term, the deficit stood at its largest in U. S. history. And continued to grow even after he left office, mostly because of his administration's giveaways to banks, the wealthy, and big businesses.
5. The all-time record for the biggest drop in the history of the U.S. stock market occurred during this President’s administration.
6. This president set the record for most campaign fund-raising trips by a U.S. President. No other president has ever received more corporate campaign donations. This president is also the all-time U.S. and world record-holder for money received from political action committees and corporate donations.
7. Two of his biggest campaign contributors were both indicted for the largest corporate fraud crimes ever committed in the United States.
8. This president continually refused to allow inspectors access to U.S. "prisoner of war" detainees and thereby has become the first President to refuse to abide by the Geneva Convention.
9. This was the first President in history to refuse United Nations election inspectors.
10. This president set the record for least number of press conferences of any President since the advent of television.
11. This president set the all-time record for most days on vacation in any one-year period.
12. This president set the all-time record for most people worldwide to simultaneously protest against him in public venues (over 15 million people worldwide), shattering the record for protests against any other person in the history of mankind, including the leaders of Germany and the Soviet Union during World War II, and Mao Tse-Tung of China.
13. Was the first President in U.S. history to cut health care benefits for war veterans and supported a cut in benefits for active duty troops and their families - all during wartime.
14. This president holds the record for the largest single job loss during his administration, while creating the biggest tax breaks for the wealthiest 10% of Americans in history.
15. This was the first U. S. president in history to take the country into a war based solely on false information, while lying to the American people during a State of the Union address. As a side note, no one stood up and called him a liar, because those persons who dared to criticize this president were labeled traitors, unpatriotic, and anti-American by this president's chief of staff.
16. More personal bankruptcies were filed under this president's administration, than any other two presidents combined. Even after the rules for filing bankruptcy were altered under this president's administration, to make filing bankruptcy more difficult, and more favorable to banks and lenders.
Who is he?
.
.
.
.
.
George W. Bush.
The current president, Bush's successor, has accomplished the second-largest economic turnaround in U.S. history, second only to FDR in the mid-20th century, in the face of the most vigorous Republican obstructionism since the Johnson Administration. (Andrew, that is)
For the first time in nearly ten years, the Stock market closed above 13000. Bush caused the largest single drop in history.
That’s the Republican party.
All of the above statements are provable facts. The truth is, you and your ilk just can't stand it.
John I-1511587
Depressions and recessions aren't made overnight. If you want to pin the deficit and economic downturn on Obama, you're only going to find agreement with the most misinformed. The recession had nothing to do with Obama and frankly started before he was even in office. It confounds me when people seriously think that if a president just "did things right" horrible economic conditions would just wash away after a year or two, if not immediately. The economic meltdown was on a global scale- Europe is still feeling it just as much as we are.
I cannot attest to the validity of the sheriff's claims, but my college student son found something interesting with the PDF of the birth certificate that the White House uploaded to the Internet ( gov/sites/default/files/rss_viewer /birth-certificate.pdf) (please remove spaces) using Inkscape, which is an open source vector graphics editor, like Adobe Illustrator.
PDFs can hold image data or text data. In President Obama's case, as this was supposed to be a scanned birth certificate, it should have been a single layer of image data. However, when opened up in Inkscape, the multiple layers are obvious. A youtube that shows a young man visually explaining this can be found at: https ://www.youtube.com/ watch?v= 7s9StxsFllY (please remove spaces)
I consider myself an open-minded person. When I watch my son download the certificate from the White House site, and peel back layers that removes information that "proves" Obama's story, then I become less likely to believe him in other things.
prof, look up OCR. You can download any .pdf file and it shows layers. Scan a simple word document, create a .pdf file, open it up in the correct program and you will see layers. The Youtube video you reference is made up by Jerome Corsi, associated with extremist RW rag World Net Daily, both who is personally profiting from the pockets of people too lazy to do their own research regarding this issue. Stop being foolish. The State of Hawaii has verified the birth certificate as authentic. There is no record of Obamas mother ever having been in Africa. There is no vast conspiracy. Obama is American born and the lawful President of the U.S.
lol I thought it was just a given that it was fake. Just like 1960 presidential election results in Cook County, IL.
Believe me, being foreign born is the least objectionable thing about Obama. No worries. He's on his way out. He can go back to community organizing in the aforementioned county. Although I'm sure that would no longer be good enough for him. Nah, he'll go the way of that other fatherless, dysfunctional Democrat presidential predecessor: million dollar speaking tour. Not bad for a mediocre lawyer and arrogant dullard.
Looks like YOU LOSE!!! LMAO, as it is right now you have 3 likes to 51 likes on the other post...plus your post is simply right wing rhetoric and has no basis in fact. Go spread your lies somewhere else, somewhere where lies are accepted as fact...like FoxNews or The Weekly Standard.
I'm voting for Obama...I'm a combat vet, I make good money, I pay taxes, I don't hate people based on religion, I am not a communist or socialist, I am not an illegal(btw, calling people "illegal" is rude and insensitive and they don't like it), I have never been on welfare and never will be...so your assessments of the average Obama voter just got tossed right out the window, didn't they?
Maybe you should put some thought into your rants. You want facts? Try RESEARCHING instead of passing on rumors, the latter makes you a fool.
--------------------------------------
veteran44
Cruisebait; if you like BIG GOVERMENT telling you exactly what you can or can't do, then vote for this j#@#! If you like SOCIALISM/ COMMUNISM, then vote for him! If you hate Christians, and love muslims, then vote for him! If you happen to be an illegal, then vote for him! If your a loafer or welfare alumni, then vote for him! You definitly belong in one of these groups. that's the facts jack.
I guess the reality of Obama wining the 2012 Election is just to much for these people, but really does anyone expect anything less, they are trying every trick in the play book from tampering with who can vote to these children games, I guess they think the State of Hawaii created these forged documents, talk about sore losers these people take the cake, but I'm not surprised because they are the biggest Whiners I've ever seen, I can tell when I meet a Republican they will always find something too whine about.
Duh!
What we really need is just one political party so everyone could stop hating each other.
Arpaio, your job as a sheriff is a cruel right-wing joke, foisted onto the public that you don't serve or protect. Perhaps if you traded in your jack boots for the real boots of a peace officer, you would be liked and respected a lot more by many American minorities.
I don't doubt it. The main thing this pandering administration has done is capitulate to the whims of gays. It's been shady if nothing else. They've done a lot of shuffling, and when all is said and done, I believe there will be way more than 52 cards in this deck. Quick...Obama's in trouble, more smoke... Poof! Osama bin laden is mysteriously found and killed... George bush couldn't do it in four years, but that Obama -- I tell you,he's something else.
The only people who believe that the removal of "don't ask, don't tell" was an achievement are the gays in the supply closet and those not in the military. Case in point, most americans don't even know the full title of the policy. Was it "don't ask don't tell" or "don't ask, don't tell, don't harass, don't pursue"?That's shady in my opinion.
Oh no, Obama's ratings are down....Quick, more gay legislation. If he'd had the birth certificate, why did it take so long to materialize? If Osama bin laden was killed why weren't photos of the body released? Like the talaban isn't planning to kill Americans for the sake of their own agenda. I don't Arpaio for doing his job, I just think dirt is coming to the surface.
What a loon.
I would not be surprised if he has a double super secret file proving that brown people hiding in the desert made the Arapio birth certificate.
veteran44::: You have proved to me that you are a male. You didn't mention anything about the republicans wanting to get into the bedrooms of citizens of the US, you didn't mention anything about the republicans wanting to get into the uterus of every woman of child-bearing age in the US, you didn't mention about the republicans wanting to outlaw birth control pills (which by the way are used in other maladies that confront females)-- bet you welcome the advent of cialis tho. Birth control pills have been around longer and noone has biched about them until now, thank you republithugs.
I just wonder about Sheriff Joe's birth certificate. Is it legal or is it a forgery? Is HE legal or illegal?
He's just mad he got benched.
Cruisbait - great compilation. However our tea party friends have allergies with facts. So it might not work w them. Just sayin..
Itiswhatitis....I thought I had established a couple weeks ago that the only nearly creditable study/survey known to this planet puts the estimated % of Gays in a given population to be at best guess (percentages and averages being such dodgy numbers in this context) 3.5%, then consider that in general only 50% of eligible voters vote, and a certain % that are not eligible, and those "Pink Dollar Gays" that vote Republican and you got maybe .08% of the population.....that is hardly going to throw a National Election (maybe the PTA) and certainly not worth pandering to....it aint gonna be that close.
Veteran 44: for the LAST TIME: Socialism is an ECONOMIC system, Communism is a POLITICAL system, a very CONSERVATIVE political system. The fact that you don't know the difference tells us a lot about you and the validity of your argument.
God these people are pathetic. All they do is bitch and whine bitch and whine..
You really want to do some investigating, it should've been on John McCain. I may be stupid or slow or I didn't listen in school, but the last time I checked, the Panama Canal Zone wasn't a state.
-_-
No, they just don't WANT to.
It's much easier to blame brown people for all the nations ills than it is to actually solve problems.
Noah
I suggest you get historically informed.
Since the Great Depression, No recession or depression has recovered so slow.
http://quitenormal.wordpress.com/2011/07/06/obama-recession-slowest-recovery-since-great-depression/
A Depression doesn't have to recover so slow. Did you know that there was a depression from 1920-1923? The bottom fell out of the economy in 1920-1921 and was fully recovered by 1923.
I have a hard time saying we are out of a recession/depression because of the pattern of the great depression and the fact that in our day in age, we have a constant flow of 401K money into the market every day. The money has to go somewhere, and could easily be showing the market artifically high.
We need to get through a couple of more quarters without a major incident to shore up that "recovery" label.
So, does that mean Sheriff Joe thinks that Pres. Obama wasn't born? I do believe there is sufficient evidence to the contrary.
Or is the Sheriff suggesting that the President is an alien? I'm thinking that the Secret Service would have found any zipper in his neck by now.
Well folks, that only leaves one other choice, the good Sheriff is a birther (which is a polite way of saying racist).
Those of us that live in the real world are looking forward to the President's reelection. With luck, we will also witness the simultaneous explosion of Rush Limbaugh's head, along with the rest of the birthers.
Have a nice day! TGIF
Technology has reached a point where we have to question everything we see and hear and are less equipped than ever to do so. Most people have never heard of project Pandora which shows people may not even be able to trust their "own thoughts."
To say that someone is stupid for questioning a digital document's authenticity in 2012 is absurd. To truly deny that a conspiracy could actually take place would allow it to happen. Maybe instead of worrying about wether Obama was born in the US or was a covert operative, we should question wether one man should represent more than 300 million Americans. The notion of the presidency has become obsolete, therefore no president will ever satisfy.
TNRebel- Few have more respect for real Vets than I but in my opinion Crash McCain is a poser (and his right to be a Natural Citizen is not disputed...his claims past that I doubt).
McCain crashed no less than five planes during his less than distinguished career, he never saw a day of real combat and just dropped bombs from a mile up, it is generally acknowledged that he was shot down more as a result of his caviler flying skills than the good aim of the NVA, his lone ranger Hans Solo attitude endangered other members of his squad and because he was the son of an Admiral he received preferential treatment while a POW as he was a good propaganda tool, the NVA claimed at the time and still do that his injuries resulted from the crash and that they gave him all the medical attention that was available. He also aided and abetted the enemy by making public propaganda statements....John McCain is as phony as a three dollar bill....and the easiest way to tell is that he continues to advocate military action at the least possible provocation or conflict (no real Vet would advocate the horrors of war except as a last result)...he is a mouthpiece for the Military Industrial Complex.
This is crazy, can we focus on real issues.... I mean what idiot wants to still focused on the President being a foreigner? Really, so now the FBI, CIA, SS and many other branches of the government are too stupid to do an actual back ground check? I can not believe that people are still focused on Obama being a citizen of the United States. Get it through your thick skull, he is a citizen, he is President and will be President again, especially if you continue to focus on lies!!! it is insanity people....
I think Conservatives here in Arizona vote for these whack-jobs like Kyle, McCain, Brewer, and Joe, just to razz-berry the rest of the Country. They are so extreme Right-wing that they have become cartoonish.
Check out the people in former countries once ruled by the USSR - and which factions want to preserve and restore many of the Socialists ways? Skin-heads and Neo-Nazi racists from the far right want to go back to Socialism...saying Obama is a Socialist is the usual brainwashing that works so well on Conservatives.
Look at the angry faces on our fine Arizona representatives - totally reactionary - no logic.
Eevie--many believe that these definitions are the other way around. Communism is an economic system in opposition to capitalism. Socialism is a political system which exists on a scale near Democracy and away from Absolute Monarchy on the right and Anarchy on the left.
We know this because socialist countries (like those in Europe) are also capitalist. Some communist countries have been democratic.
This can be a bit confusing, since socialist systems do take certain aspects of the production of wealth and cause them to be owned and paid for collectively--in the US, our police, fire fighters, schools, and so forth are owned collectively and paid for collectively. A system that would expand this activity might still be socialist, but would begin to look more and more like a communist system (also, communism looks a lot like extreme socialism).
Thus, the terms "socialist" and "communist" are easily confused with one another--and US conservatives very much like to make "socialist" the opposite of "capitalist" because then they can tag any effort towards socialism (such as socialized health care) as a slide into a non-capitalist state.
However, the fact remains that many European nations are socialist and that they are still capitalist and have made no movement towards changing this. Socialism is not the huge bug-a-boo that people want to make it. Communism has already collapsed--and no one appears to be entertaining the notion of bringing it back (even China has largely abandoned communism).
Still--it doesn't matter. If you want to say that socialism is an economic system--that's fine. The point is that no one is trying to do away with capitalism. They just want a few things taken out of the for-profit sector and turned into a not-for-profit, community owned sector--these services are services that everyone needs and that, if paid for collectively, are less expensive (not necessarily better run, but less expensive).
Medication and medical care in those parts of the world that have "socialized" it are far, far less expensive than they are in the US. For the most part, they are equally good. There are some exceptions--cutting edge practices that are extremely profitable (such as brand new medications in the US that are still under patent) tend to be more available in the US than elsewhere, and the most expensive private hospitals in the US are stellar. It is true that really wealthy people have it better in the US than in a lot of other places. But, socialized medicine is not altogether bad--and, not being wealthy--I am sorry that we don't at least have single-payer care.
Single-payer care, for example, is just like everyone in a state going in together (just as businesses do) to negotiate a better rate. Because the risk is spread among so many, the overall cost is lower. That's an example of socialism (even if it involves mostly the insurance industry rather than medicine, itself).
There are benefits to capitalism, there are some benefits to communism--full participatory democracy has its benefits, representative democracy has its benefits, etc. Under Mussolini, the trains ran on time. Everything (economic or political) has its ups and downs.
Please quit quibbling when people use a term in a way that you think is wrong--many of the "definitions" that one picks up come from political parties. It is kind of like Republicans trying to convince us that the US is a "republic" and not a "democracy." We actually have representative democracy--which Jeffersonian Democrats told us was mostly a democracy and which the Federalists told us was mostly a republic. But, really, we have a mixed government that is in part a republic, in part a democracy, and which has some socialist elements also.
Because someone else defines a term differently doesn't make them wrong--definitions are created by people who want to make a specific point. However, if you want to call "socialism" an economic system that is in opposition to "capitalism"--you do have to explain why European Socialist nations still have capitalism, okay?
Don't blame Sherriff Joe for all this. He is merely annoncing the findings of a VOLUNTEER panel of attorneys and off-duty police officers. They have a right as private citizens to examine the birth certificate under the Freedom of Information Act. If these highly trained and educated people have discovered anomalies in a public document that call into question its authenticity, and when said document is the only proof of whether the man holding the highest elected office in the country is, in fact, legally qualified to hold that office in the first place, then they would have been remiss to not bring those findings to Sherriff Joe.
He is must doing right by the people of his county. He himself is an elected official. He keeps getting re-elected by 70%-80% of the votes. It seems pretty obvious that the job he is doing (punishing criminals instead of coddling them, arresting people who commit crimes regardless of their race or immigration status and actually enforcing immigration law instead of ignoring it) must resonate with the wishes of the vast majority of his county's population, most of whom are conservative Latinos and LEGAL Mexican immigrants (Census data...look it up yourself), or else he would not keep getting re-elected.
NeighborOfTheBeast, nice try. The issues his VOLUNTEER panel brought up were put to rest long ago - check snopes.com. And yes, we can blame sheriff Joe - this is nothing but a an attempt to pander to the birther splinter of the right wing lunatic fringe. This is the 2nd of what promises to be a series of cheap PR stunts intended to draw attention away from all the bad publicity he's gotten over the last couple of years.
Socialism is the opposite of capitalism. Under capitalism, the private citizen is preeminent. The government has clearly defined limits and cannot infringe on the rights of its citizens, from whom its power is derived. Under socialism, the government is preeminent. The government spends the money of its citizens on programs it deems as necessary, most of them social programs. The individual's desires are preempted for the government's definition of what is necessary. Capitalism encourages growth and rewards ambition. A person's wealth is tied directly to how hard he works and the relative worth of thegoods or the service he produces. He responds to the needs of his customers, or he will lose money. Socialism discourages ambition and punishes growth. Businesses and private citizens alike are heavily taxed and regulated. Private property and private businesses are allowed, as are multiple political parties, but the majority of the wealth is surrendered to the government, who provides everything a person needs, but little of what a person may want. By taking the sting out of everyday life and giving people everything instead of making them work for it, the government reduces the incentive to strive to improve one's self. Without the very real possibility of homelessness, starvation and unemployment, the government encourages the maintenance of the status quo. It is that mind-numbing sameness to everything that the human brain instinctively rejects. Communism simply takes socialism one step further to the left. It is the ultimate expression of fascism, where socialism is basically "fascism light". There is only one political party. The State owns the businesses, the land, the housing, the jobs, the cars, the buildings, the stores, everything. If you want anything more than what you need to survive, you must seek the favor of the Party. Its counterpart on the extreme right would be monarchism, where everything is owned by the Crown instead of the State.
@Gumps:
The fact that there are people willing to donate their private time to investigate the anomalies found on Obama's birth certificate proves that your statement about this being laid to rest is not true. Obviously, there is still some dispute in the matter. The Warren Commission did not lay to rest investigations of the JFK assassination. We are still talking about it nearly 50 years later. I suspect that the controversy over Obama's birth certificate will continue for some time, as well. As to pandering, one could say the same thing about Eric Holder bringing charges against Sherriff Joe to distract the public from the abject failure of nearly every single one of Obama's policies, and that this is just pandering to the Latino voter base in order to shore up flagging support from a sector of the populace that the Democrats have taken for granted for far too long. Obama is The Great and Powerful Oz here, not the good Sherriff.
As for cheap PR stunts, what do you call suing the State of Arizona over passing a law that mirrors the federal one? Abusing Presidential power and ignoring a federal court ruling by installing a moratorium on oil drilling in the Gulf and off the East coast? What would you call ObamaCare itself, if not a PR stunt?
Beast, the so-called anomalies that you refer to were addressed and debunked. Just because people like you refuse to acknowlege this fact doesn't change the situation. And yes, 50 years later, nothing new has come out of the JFK assassination investigation; still the conspiracy theorists persist. Doesn't change things at all.
But cling to your conspiracy theories and nut ball ideas - Joe Arpaio is hoping that there are enough of your ilk to surpass those who are fed up of his huckster tricks. In November, he will be voted out of office.
Obama IN
Arpaio OUT
The right pursues idiocy with dogged determination. I have to give them a A for effort.
I have to give them a A for effort.
Or an F for asinine
asinine would still be an "A"
now what would be a good "F" word for this idiot in Phoenix........
suggestions anyone?
Must be hard to talk when you're teabagging...let alone think; no wonder this birther crap!
@centrist republican: Fool comes to mind, but I know too many really good fools to insult 'em in such a way. Guess i'll go with fart.
Here we go again. Republicans are losing the argument. The economy is recovering. They are running idiots for their nomination. Let's rekindle the birther movement!
Over 5 Trillion more debt, and you say the economy is getting better, keep
hiding your head in the sand,. President Obama said if we passed his stimulus plan 767 Billion dollars worth, unemployment would not go above 8%, I believe he missed that by 3 years, but what is sad is the debt he is leaving our children. He needs to go.
John1, the President underestimated the damage done by his predecessor. The recession was much deeper than anyone imagined, and the stimulus package wasn't big enough, but it did improve things. The GAO confirms that. Despite everything that the traitorous GOP in Congress has done, the country is improving.
john. well, he ain't going. your prospective candidates are seeing to that.
that must gall you.
@ centrist and mac: So many more "F" words come to mind, but I am striving to remain polite.
Sorry no A for effort, I can't do that especially when our local teabaggers say it took the CIA 3 years to make the forgery. If that is the case, we are in a world of hurt if it took the CIA 3 years to produce a forged document.
A. That's a lie. President Obama never said it.
B. The unemployment rate was already OVER 8% by February 2009, President Obama's first month in office, and it was on trajectory to go as high as 15%.
C. The stimulus, while it contained pieces that I disapprove of, saved or created millions of jobs in the US. If anything, was too anemic a response to bring about a swift end to the deepest recession since the Great Depression.
D. Republican politicians, aimed at distracting attention away from the recession they accidentally created to the budget deficit they deliberately created, thwarted best efforts to implement good policy in favor of policies that prolonged the recession, repeating many of the same mistakes that prolonged the Great Depression.
Thanks to Republican political hacks, we are subsidizing every rich family in America to the une of $130,000 per year, and have been doing so for over a decade. That's not fiscal conservatism.
Now that we've given every rich family in America an average of over a million and a half dollars EACH, it's time for them to start paying taxes again.
Mitt Romney: He makes dogs want to puke.
commonsense, where in the world did you come up with this balderdash?? subsidizing so called rich families to the tune of $130,000 per year? could you plz direct me to the gov program that provided this windfall. I work hard and make a fairly decent income,however i could really use that $130,000
Instead of everyone spouting political drivel - you guys should instead just note the source of the facts that Arpiao's deputy (Mike Zullo - a retired NJ cop?) cited...
All their facts came from Jerry Corsi - who runs a website claiming that:
1. The USA attacked the WTC on 9/11;
2. John Kerry was never in the military in VietNam;
3. Aliens are advising politicans around the world;
4. Obama is a Kenyan who falsified his birth certificate and draft card.
Note that the investigator admitted that they did not even contact the State of Hawaii to determine whether the birth certificate was valid. And a local AZ news team showed that the 'evidence of fabrication' could very easily have been caused by the scanner used.
But hey - why let facts get in the way of a good vendetta
Yawnnnnn!!!!! No news here. Let's move along.
The birthers just don't give up, do they.
Stupid people don't learn from their mistakes.
If McCain had won in 2008, there would still be a birther movement, but it would be made up of left-wing nut jobs instead of right-wing nut jobs. The losing side can't stand the fact that their man lost and they will pull some ridiculous reason out of thin air that the other guy should not be president. It's all just politics.
Oh c'mon Kevin, anyone with any sense at all knows that is a false premise! In fact, if McCain had been elected prez, we'd all be listening to Palin trying to explain McCain's policy of staying in Afghanistan for 100 years as he predicted before the election and that would be what the left, moderates and anyone with common sense would be questioning, not his birth certificate. The birthers just cannot stand the fact that he is a young, good-looking black man, that not only outdid Bush in protecting the country ie. Bin laden for one, the economy is recovering for another and the fact he can sing too:)
Good point, but McCain was born in Panama
What really blows me away is not just the stupidity of the whole idea that A) President Obama's birth certificate is forged and B) that this somehow proves that he is not a citizen; but also the staggering lack of logic behind the argument. Not to mention, the implied sexism. Even if --IF!-- Obama's birth certificate were a forgery, (which it is NOT, unless the governor of Hawaii is a liar) -- So what? You say he was born in Kenya? What, because his mother decided to forgo a modern American hospital and give birth in Kenya, at the tail end of the Mau Mau Revolt? REALLY? Why would she do that? Because she was what, stupid? Not to mention: Do you have ANY idea of how dangerous it is to give birth in Africa, even today?
But the fact is, even that would not have mattered, because Stanley Ann Dunham Obama was an American citizen. Even had she given birth on Mars, her child would still have been an American citizen. The implication that her citizenship does not matter, because as a woman, her status is not as important as that of the father, is, simply put, outrageously chauvinistic.
Eevie,
You are right. One of my boys was born in Indonesia and gets US citizenship through me. He has a consular birth record from the US Consulate in Surabaya that clearly states that he is a US citizen from birth, i.e. natural born. Even if Obama was born outside the US, he would still be a US citizen through his US citizen mother.
I take it as a hopeful sign. Until now, Arpaio has relied on millions of dollars pouring into his coffers every year from bigots around the country trying to scapegoat immigrants for everything from the recession (persecuction of workers and factory owners may spur recession, but immigration grows the economy) to crime (immigrants have far lower crime rates than US citizens, regardless of ethnicity), to dandruff.
Arpaio arrests people for 'working while having brown skin' because that's easier than going after rapists and gang members.
Now, he's resorting to 'birtherism'.
That's the act of a desparate man. Out of state contributions must be WAY down.
Sean,
I was just pointing out that if McCain had won, there would be a birther movement saying that he is not a citizen because he was born in Panama. Their arguments would make about as much sense as the ones used by the birther movement against Obama. As I said, it's all politics. Extremists on the losing side are always clinging to some ray of false hope that maybe their man won after all.
Oh good grief, drop it already. Idiocy run amok over stupidity shouldn't trump the issues that need to be addressed in this country. This story and sheriff are the poster child of stupid for the day.
And another "stupid of the day" tomorrow generated by the right wing deflecting more important issues.
I wonder if I got enough people in Arizona to petition Arpaio, will he round up some volunteers to look for a glove I lost last weekend? After all, he'd just be doing his job.
Any takers?
when are you dumb republican fu@@@@ going to drop this stupid bullsh##????????????????????????????
My guess is after President Obama serves his second term. President Obama stubbornly remains black, you see.
just waiting for the race card to pop up!
Sure. The race card is the only thing that republicans/conservatives/teabaggers and especially birthers have now.
CreepingJesus
Sure. The race card is the only thing that republicans/conservatives/teabaggers and especially birthers have now
try the TRUTH
creeping jesus, you as#@# are the one's playing the race card! Guess what? I hate his white 50% too. DUMB JERKS!!!
....so much hate. Might I suggest help?
creep. "stubbornly remains black" best line yet. lol!
A 79yo sheriff who says "he's just doing his job" by pursuing something refered to him by 80+ teabaggers is in desperate need of RETIREMENT !!!!
They dwell on this to hide their racism and then claim someone is playing the race card when called on it. But I'd bet Gingrich's moon base that that is their motivation. Of course they still believe the moon landing was a hoax filmed in Hollywood by the U.S. gov.
creepy,
Obama is half black and half white. He will probably subbornly remain that way. Mixed race is so cool! Although it's no guarantee that he will be any better of a president than his predicessors.
I think Arpaio's intelligence is a forged fake.
It's about time for the Sheriff to ride off into the sunset.
His so called evidence has already been debunked. He claimed the document was layered, but others have examined the file and said that isn't so. He claimed a date stamp looked wrong and was an upside down 08 vs an 80. His theory was that a stamp with 80 on it isn't available today, so they flipped an 08 over.
So a few things that he perceives as odd are "proof" of a forgery, yet others disagree. First off, he didn't have access to the original documents but only scanned copies of them. He's not a forensic expert and no expert could make a valid conclusion from a copy. So it proves nothing. This guy is a nut job, plain and simple and is trying to distract from all the trouble he is in with the Feds. But I'm sure Fox will be all over it and claim it's all solid evidence.
Jeez, get over it already!
Ahh man, to me the X-Files is still a recent show!
Seriously?????......let's see school murders, tornadoes, flooding, and snowstorms, hunger, sickness, poverty, and you give us "BIRTH CERIFICATE CRAP...... ARE U SERIOUS???!!!!!....get a real job
Amen!
That jerk sherriff is dirty. My guess is he's got lots of dirty dealings he'd rather not see come to light.
Geez Joe give it a break!!!
Morris the only break arpio deserves is from being sheriff and ruining maricopa county
I am sorry to say as an third generation Arizona resident that the idiocy of the far right seems to know no bounds.
I would say the far left is out of bounds, it is sad that we elected a President that is all talk and the only action he takes is against the citizens of this country. He sues Arizona, what ever happen to sitting down and coming up with a solution, oh I forgot he knows what is best for us stupid people and when we go against him
he acts like a spoiled brat. As Rush said he is a man-child, so very true.
John, do you actually understand the issues or do you just parrot what a guy on a radio says? Your post is so typical of someone that is speaking out of anger and not thinking for him/herself.
Face it, the only people still supporting obama are those trapped in the fantasy of the promise from yesteryear. Anyone else is been awake.
John::: And Rush the Druggie calls PRESIDENT Obama a man-child? What then is Rush Limburger? A druggie with no brain BETWEEN HIS EARS? I'll leave it up to intelligent people to figure out what I mean-- and YOU aren't one of them.
And to ItIsWhat!t!s::: I've probably looked at records of more presidents of this country than you have, and I can assure you that the one with the poorest record was George W Bush (aka SHRUB). He dreamed up a reason for us to go to war in Iraq-- the dream came during a drunken stupor. He got us into TWO wars that he didn't put on the books-- never have I known of an emergency that came up every month or two.
Bet I could compare PRESIDENT Obama's birth certificate with mine and find it contains the same type of information that mine does.
Aridzona wackos abound. This is sillier than anyone could write. Geebus! We're still on this birth certificate thing? Could we please get down to the business of recovering our economy and moving forward? Tin hats for everyone in the Zona.
The profilers at it again!Only he won't take care of his own!
Arpalo is diverting attention from his forged birth document
Arpaio does sound like a Mexican name.
The sheriff doesn't know that he too is an immigrant/son of immigrant unless if his a nativie American.shout up and face the federal on the investigations on about the acitivities in your office.
All conservatives lie--some good, some bad, some ugly.
It takes one to know one. Please tell me one thing the President has said in the last 3 years which isn't a lie. I'm waiting.
Well, let's see....he's said, and proved, he's a US citizen - natural born, no less. He's a Christian... He has upheld the US Constitution as in his oath.
And that's JUST to start with.
So, John, what's your point, because your ability to process intelligence?
Might I add...he told us Bin Laden is dead...that isn't a lie ! There are a lot more truths. It doesn't matter...you can't handle the truth !
JKLD... Can you provide a link to this "proof". Obama readily admits his father was not a U.S. citizen therefore Obama CAN NOT be a Natural Born citizen. To be a Natural Born citizen BOTH parents must be citizens. The 14th amendment says NOTHING about being a Natural Born citizen. Nor does it say anything about changing the requirements to hold the office of president laid out in Sec II of the constitution.
Not a single post on this thread in defense of the usurper Obama refutes or even attempts to refute the evidence of forgery provided by Arpaio's investigators.
"He has upheld the U.S. constitution as in his oath." Really? So the constitution says it is ok for the president to selectively enforce the laws of the U.S.A.? The constitution allows the president to engage our military in hostile action, without the consent of Congress, when there is no immediate threat to the U.S., it's allies or interests? The constitution allows the president to determine when the Senate is or is not in official recess when it comes to making recess appointments? The constitution allows the federal government to regulate and tax NOT engaging in commerce? (unless you received a waiver that is.... which violates the equal protection clause.) And my favorite.... The constitution allows for the president to have a U.S. citizen on U.S. soil be arrested and indefinitely detained, without charges, due process or even habeas corpus? Each of these actions are in direct violation of the constitution. So your claim that Obama "upholds" the constitution is patently false. Prove me wrong
you lying progressive piec...if you can.dmac::: Oh, and the constitution does allow us to be thrown into a war on false pretenses and then have TWO wars that were not funded? Have you looked into that one that was conceived by your savior, Shrub? Oh he had a reason all right-- his buddies needed the money so he came up with the wars so they could profit from them. And it cost us 4,000 of our men so Shrub's buddies could get rich. Where was the immediate threat to the US? And what is so different between PRESIDENT Obama's making recess appointments and your savior doing the same exact thing.
Bet your claim of your having a brain between your ears is patently false.
dmac - You're incorrect about how "natural born citizen" is defined. Neither the Constitution nor the Supremes have defined that term. But here's a little from wikipedia - The Congressional Research Service has stated that the weight of scholarly legal and historical opinion indicates that the term means one who is entitled under the Constitution or laws of the United States to U.S. citizenship "at birth" or "by birth," including any child born "in" the United States, even to alien parents (other than to foreign diplomats serving their country), the children of United States citizens born abroad, and those born abroad of one citizen parent who has met U.S. residency requirements.
Certainly Obama's mom was a citizen, and Hawaii was a state. He's a "natural born citizen."
DMAC225, said: "To be a Natural Born citizen BOTH parents must be citizens."
What exactly are you smoking, DMAC? And how did you come by this (completely false) gem?
To be a natural born citizen of the United States, you must either A) be born on US territory, which includes embassies and military zones. Including the Panama Canal Zone, DMAC!
OR B) ONE or both of your parents must be an American citizen.
Any questions?
Uh, Eevie, I was born in Chihuahua, Mexico and I'm a Natural Born citizen. Last time I checked, Mexico is not a US territory.
Gumps, was at least one of your parents and American Citizen? If so, you're a natural-born citizen. (Point B in my post.)
Not a single post on this thread in defense of the usurper Obama refutes or even attempts to refute the evidence of forgery provided by Arpaio's investigators.
That's because, at least to people with the intelligence level beyond that of a small soap dish, the matter is closed.
dmac225,
You should actually read the 14th Amendment, especially the part that says "All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States and of the states wherein they reside". There is NO requirement that both parents be US citizens for the child to be a natural born citizen. If the child is born in the United Stated, the no requirement that either parent be a US citizen for the child to be a natural born citizen. Unless the parents have diplomatic immunity (See the words "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof"), the child in that case is a US citizen by virtue of being born in the United States.
Jim, of course nobody here has bothered to refute the "evidence" - that was done already. Ever hear of snopes.com? This is a dead issue that Joe Arpaio is bring back to life to pander to people of your ilk.
No matter how often or effectively evidence is refuted, conspiracy theorists will never change their minds. They just continue to believe that the "truth" is out there somewhere and some undefined "they" are trying to keep it from us.
Ya gotta love the crackpot Right. There's no end to their lunacy.
This is news but obamas illegal half bro going to court isn't.Hmmmm a little biased don"t ya think?
reply to:"WORLD OF IT" It was his "uncle", not "half-brother"...
Sheriff "AIR-PIE-YO" is one 79 year old "SENILE PILE of POOP"
Gee, why oh why would a Birther want to try to change the subject...?
R C EDGE
u my little friend r right, his half bro was arrested in Nigeria for possession
Who looses in the smelliest poop contest?
The Judge ;-)
As President Obama's certain reelection gets closer, I expect more and more republicans/conservatives/teabaggers to become unhinged and attack President Obama and his family for the most trivial of matters.
It will be hard to believe that it's possible, but republicans/conservatives/teabaggers will sink far lower and be far more despicable and vile than they have so far.
Like your use of BIGOTED termanology. Do progressives have a version of the KKK yet?
Nah. Republicans/conservatives/teabaggers have an exclusive license for the KKK.
Two guys standing around over 50 feet from the polling area is hardly "voter intimidation." But Florida redneck sheriffs stopping cars of blacks going to vote in 2004 and telling them to turn around and go home if they don't have a taxi license or they all go to jail is in fact some form of voter intimidation. If you doubt this happened there are all kinds of news sources that reported it at the time.
TNRebel-4016842 wrote:
"LOL..You do realize it [the KKK] was founded by Southern Democrats right??"
Yeah. Back when the Democrats were the right wing-nuts, and the Republicans were the Liberals and Progressives. You DO realize, don't you, that Lincoln was a Liberal?
Lincoln was a conservative who believed that states did not have the right to secede from the Union that makes him a strict interpreter of the Constitution and therefore a conservative.
deathjester....it is the conservatives who are trying to tear down our constitution. Lincoln was a member of the Republican party, but as another poster said, that was when it was the Dems who were the nutjobs. The parties have completely flipped since then. Lincoln would be a liberal in today's world. No conservative of today would have ended slavery. I think about 50% would bring it back if they could.
Lincoln was a Whig, a center moderate who believed that the Declaration of Independence, as set forth by the Founders, guaranteed equality to all men. He also believed that laws set forth by a strong central government override States rights, which dovetailed with his rejection of the argument that the residents of a territory should decide, upon ascending to statehood, whether the new state was to be free or slave. Not to mention his frequently overlooked overhaul of the financial/banking and economic sectors. He also signed the first progressive tax act, favored economic protectionism, higher wages for industrial labor, and appointed Samuel Freeman to the Supreme Court. 'Nuff said.
Definition: Liberal = advocating change. Conservative = maintaining status quo.
Eh. That's Samuel Freeman MILLER.
you sound like the majority of voters that support Obama that sit on welfare and live off the system.
Mark, your comment is so typical of your ilk - simpleminded binary logic. Everything can be in only one of two states. Example: "You're either with us or you side with the terrorists". Either you're a conservative or you're liberal; if conservative, you're gainfully employed, otherwise you're collelcting welfare. I suppose that makes it easy for you to try to comprehend things, but reality is far more complicated than that.
Bottom Line is:
Arpaio is pooping on his pants. He knows he is in deep Cr@p with the Investigation conducted byt eh DOJ. Some how he needs to project the attention away from him and back to President Obama on his BC. He will go any length to lie and convince the people that he is right and every one else is wrong. Specially convencing does who do not do their homework/ research and simply run with the rumors.
Arpaio OUT
Obama IN
Haven't we been over this already? Arpaio is deflecting his own legal and political troubles. This from a man who runs a jail with a 'number served' sign.
He's well on his way to a cell of his own at this rate, and no amount of silly distractions will stop that.
This is a lame attempt on the part of Sheriff Joe to appeal to the right wing lunatic fringe, who he hopes will outnumer the rest of the voters who are sick of the money wasted during his tenure:
$100M misspent funds - for things like lavish dinners at expensive restaurants, stays at luxury hotels, valet parking; trips to Disneyland; internet service for his wife's business.
$50M in settlements/claims/lawsuits from families of inmates abused in his jails (Google: "Richard Post", for just one example)
Perhaps another $20M in malicious prosecution claims/lawyers fees, etc. resulting from arrest of Maricopa County Supervisors Stapley, Wilcox and judge Donahoe (who ruled against MCSO in some court cases).
Sheriff Joe is the guy who endorsed Rick Perry, and called Iowans "Buckeyes" while campaigning there. Joe is the sheriff who referred to civil rights as "crap" on TV while responding to the Department Of Justice investigation of MCSO civil rights violations.
Now, Joe is becoming tabloid fodder.
Gumps, this idiot doesn't have to appeal to the right wing lunatic fringe because he's already one of them
Ah, but he needs them to vote in November. We will see then, if Maricopa County is one huge insane asylum..
How about Sherlock Arpaio investigating what happened to Joseph Smith's golden pages and seer stone so he can prove the truth about Mormonism, that should get him re-elected.
Perhaps not in Arizona . . .