WASHINGTON -- Faced with a persistently weak economy, the number of immigrants flowing into the United States from Mexico has declined for the first time in decades, according to a study released on Monday.
An analysis of census data from the U.S. and Mexican governments details the movement to and from Mexico, a nation accounting for nearly 60 percent of the illegal immigrants in the U.S. It comes amid renewed debate over U.S. immigration policy as the Supreme Court hears arguments this week on Arizona's tough immigration law.
Roughly 6.1 million unauthorized Mexican immigrants were living in the U.S. last year, down from a peak of nearly 7 million in 2007, according to the Pew Hispanic Center study. It was the biggest sustained drop in modern history, believed to be surpassed in scale only by losses in the Mexican-born U.S. population during the Great Depression.
“The standstill appears to result from the weakened U.S. job market, heightened border enforcement, a rise in deportations, the growing dangers associated with illegal border crossings, and changing economic and demographic conditions in Mexico,” the Pew Center said in a statement.
Much of the drop in illegal immigrants is due to the weak U.S. economy, which has shrunk construction and service-sector jobs attractive to Mexican workers following the housing bust. But increased deportations, heightened U.S. patrols and violence along the border also have played a role, as well as demographic changes, such as Mexico's declining birth rate.
In all, the Mexican-born population in the U.S. last year -- legal and illegal -- fell to 12 million, marking an end to an immigration boom dating back to the 1970s, when foreign-born residents from Mexico stood at 760,000. The 2007 peak was 12.6 million.
The Supreme Court is set to hear arguments about Arizona's immigration law this week. The Nation's Ari Berman joins the NOW panel to talk about the case, the state of immigration laws across the country, and what the Supreme Court's decision could do for the country.
Christian Ballesteros, who has been at a shelter for immigrants in Matamoros, Mexico, across the border from Brownsville, Texas, pointed to stiffer U.S. penalties for repeat offenders as well as brutal criminal groups that control the Mexican side of the border as reasons for the immigration decline. Ballesteros, who has been deported four times, was recently caught after hopping the border fence near Nogales, Ariz.
"The Mexican cartels are taking over, are actually being like the border patrols on this side," Ballesteros said. "They threaten them, 'if you don't pay, what we're going to do is we're going to cut your head off.' That's the worst, the worst, the worst part," Ballesteros said.
President Barack Obama promised to deliver comprehensive immigration reform, tightening security on the Mexico border while offering millions of illegal immigrants who learn English, pay a fine the chance to become citizens, but he has so far failed to deliver.
Republican White House hopeful Mitt Romney, meanwhile, supports tough enforcement. He has expressed support for Arizona's state law cracking down on illegal immigrants that is subject to an appeals hearing in the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday to determine whether the state strayed too far into the federal government's powers.
Former President George W. Bush brought the last attempt at an immigration overhaul to a vote in 2007, but it was killed off by Republicans in the U.S. Senate.
Other findings by the Pew Center:
- Illegal Mexican immigrants who have stayed in the U.S. for longer periods of time are now more likely to be sent back by authorities than before. About 27 percent of immigrants sent back had resided in the U.S. for a year or more, up from 6 percent in 2005.
- Despite an increase in Border Patrol agents, apprehensions of illegal immigrants at the U.S.-Mexico border have dropped sharply - from 1 million in 2005 to 286,000 in 2011, a sign that fewer illegal immigrants are trying to enter.
- Around 30 percent of all current U.S. immigrants are Mexican-born. The next largest sending country — China, including Hong Kong and Taiwan — accounts for just 5 percent of the estimated 40 million immigrants currently in the United States (Pew corrected its earlier percentage of immigrants who are Mexican and second largest sending country).
- A typical Mexican woman is projected to have an average of 2.4 children in her lifetime, compared with 7.3 children in 1960.
- By region, Mexican-born immigrants in the U.S. are mostly likely found in the West (51 percent) and South (33 percent). About 58 percent now live in California and Texas, down from 63 percent in 2000 as immigrants spread out over the past decade in search of jobs in other states.
The story includes reporting by Reuters, the Associated Press, and msnbc.com's Sevil Omer.
More content from msnbc.com and NBC News:


So the weak US economy is cited as a factor in this promising trend. It really is true that every cloud has a silver lining.
Aha, but they'll be back when the jobs do.
The bigots will rejoice thinking that persecution is an effective way to make America all 'white'.
The economists will realize that there are only two ways to end unauthorized immigration.
One is to legislate sensible immigration rules that don't attempt to operate in opposition to the free market.
The other is to completely trash the economy, send American jobs overseas, and waste trillions of dollars.
It may look like a silver lining to those who spit on the C9onstitution, the principles that guided the Founding Fathers, the teachings of Jesus, the wisdom of the Hebrew scriptures, and free market economics.
To the rest of us it's just a dark cloud that we brought upon ourselves.
It's not about color, it's about illegal entry to our country and it's about driving down the wages employers are willing to pay.
common-- Have you lived in a foreign country? Do you know of immigration policies of other countries? No country bends over and takes crap like the USA. We have basically become the welfare system for the 13th most wealthy nation in the world. Immigration laws are there for a reason and should be enforced like any other law.
It's funny - the right wing betrays it's own arguements when these kinds of stats come out.
Yup. Exactly. And the right wingers will continue to dehumanize the illegal immigrants while ignoring the truth that it's the employers who illegally hire illegal immigrants who are the cause of this problem.
When are you right wingers going to be as vocal and and outraged at the cause of the problem - the easily had jobs that illegals can get?
The employers who violate America daily by hiring these people you clearly despise?
When are you going to spend as much time hating them as you do the folks who's only crime is to come across the border illegally in order to get work so they can help thier familes out?
There's very little of the unbounded outrage against the companies, yet you launch a total assault on the illegal immigrants themselves.
Lay off the Constitution; the intent was for LEGAL immigrants. The word illegal immigration supporters always ignore, because it does not suit their purposes, is ILLEGAL
It's certainly not about the 'law'. Otherwise you'd be railing about people driving over the speed limit. Or advocating for SENSIBLE immigration rules that operate in America's national self interest, not the dysfunctional garbage based on bigotry that we have now.
And it's certainly not about driving down wages, because EXPANDING the economy INCREASES wages in general.
Then again, deadbeats who cannot compete on their own are always looking for an excuse.
No, YOU lay off the Constitution. I'm all FOR the Constitution, EXACTLY the way it stands now.
It's the xenophobic haters who want to do away with due process and equal protection.
For most of our history, there were NO restrictions on immigration, other than a prohibition on the importation of slaves.
Then there were rules designed to keep out Italians and Eastern Europeans and Jews, but those rules were largely overlooked.
There were no limits on immigration from the Western Hemisphere until 1965.
We didn't have the current set of IDIOTIC rules until 1986, and they are NOT written into the Constitution.
There is no such thing as an 'illegal' human being. That's just the new n-word. (Of COURSE we want to kill them all, they're 'illegal' after all.)
sorry but when immigration starts going the other way whether legal or illegal that is a true sign of the US economy. things are not getting better if anything they are truely getting worse.
I don't know a single Republican voter who does not favor jailing anyone who employs illegals. Or who doesn't realize it's the root of the problem. Take away the job and they stop coming is part of it. The other is take away the free health care and they will stop coming. And no, I don't care what happens to them. I care what happens to my own tax paying, citizens of the this country family. I am not a racist, nor am I heartless. I'm a realist. I do not live a dream world that says somehow this will all take care of itself. We cannot pay for anyone and everyone. If they want to actually immigrate. I'm fine with that. Get on the record, pay taxes and participate.
Leviticus 19:33-34: "When an alien resides with you in your land, you shall not oppress the alien. The alien who resides with you shall be to you as the citizen among you; you shall love the alien as yourself."
"Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt." Exodus 22:21
"Do not oppress an alien; you yourselves know how it feels to be aliens, because you were aliens in Egypt." Exodus 23:9
"When an alien lives with you in your land, do not mistreat him." Leviticus 19:33
"The alien living with you must be treated as one of your native-born. Love him as yourself, for you were aliens in Egypt. I am the LORD your God." Leviticus 19:34
"...help him as you would an alien or a temporary resident, so he can continue to live among you." Leviticus 25:35
"Hear the disputes between your brothers and judge fairly, whether the case is between brother Israelites or between one of them and an alien." Deuteronomy 1:16
"And you are to love those who are aliens, for you yourselves were aliens in Egypt." Deuteronomy 10:19
"Let him live among you wherever he likes and in whatever town he chooses. Do not oppress him." Deuteronomy 23:16
"Cursed is the man who withholds justice from the alien, the fatherless or the widow." Deuteronomy 27:19
"The LORD watches over the alien and sustains the fatherless and the widow, but he frustrates the ways of the wicked." Psalm 146:9
This is what the LORD says: Do what is just and right. Rescue from the hand of his oppressor the one who has been robbed. Do no wrong or violence to the alien, the fatherless or the widow, and do not shed innocent blood in this place. Jeremiah 22:3
"Do not oppress the widow or the fatherless, the alien or the poor." Zechariah 7:10
“Thus says the LORD of hosts: ‘Render true judgment, and show kindness and compassion toward each other. Do not oppress the widow or the orphan, the alien or the poor; do not plot evil against one another in your hearts.’" Zechariah 7:9-10
"The alien living with you must be treated as one of your native-born. Love him as yourself.... I am the LORD your God." Leviticus 19:34
How would they know if immigration is down, maybe they decided to work for cash they can stay off the grid and there's always two dozen of them to a house..They also come here to sell drugs so tell me, whats the method of counting.
Keep the Beaners south of the border - it is where the illegals BELONG.
Things change. For most of our history, there was plenty of space and plenty of unskilled jobs for anyone willing to work hard. Immigrants were also a much lower drain on taxpayers ... no such thing as bilingual education and official government documents (including ballots) written in Spanish. But, as I said, things change. We don't need manual, unskilled labor as much. We need capital .. financial and mental. That's where our immigration policy should be focused. Automatic green cards for PhD's from American universities. Same for engineers. Green cards for those who start new businesses in the US that employ a certain number of people.
One encouraging thing is Obama will lose some votes.
This guys "commonsense" is actually the opposite of what his name implies. He points out scripture to try and justify his rants, way to go, good job. Too bad that anybody with actual common sense can see that you have a one sided view on this immigration subject and that your closed mind is already made up. You need to realize the difference between immigration and ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION. It is not racist to suppport LEGAL immigration and oppose illegal immigration. This paragraph from the article should shed some light:
Christian Ballesteros, who has been at a shelter for immigrants in Matamoros, Mexico, across the border from Brownsville, Texas, pointed to stiffer U.S. penalties for repeat offenders as well as brutal criminal groups that control the Mexican side of the border as reasons for the immigration decline. Ballesteros, who has been deported four times, was recently caught after hopping the border fence near Nogales, Ariz.
FOUR TIMES !
in your mind you probably think "poor guy can't be left alone", common sense tells us "this guy has problems, this guy is an example of those who should NOT be allowed to immigrate". this is exactly the problem, ILLEGALS. Don't you think that if this guy could legally immigrate, he probably would ?
but no, he continues to illegally cross the border, why ? I could tell you but you wouldn't listen. all you would hear in your mind would be racism.
stop acting like everyone in America who opposes illegal immigration is a racist, that is immature and just plain stupid. look at any other country in the world, do you think that you could just walk over the Canada border and be a legal citizen ?
I've told this story to many illegal immigration supporters, but most of them just turn an empty head;
about five years ago a coworker friend of mine married a Spanish lady. Both of them have been trying to move to her home country of Spain for some time. My friend had to work with the Spanish immigration system for OVER TWO YEARS before he could move to Spain, and he MARRIED A SPANISH CITIZEN !!!!!
all one needs to do to become an American citizen is marry an American, or go through the legal process. Plain and simple, get an education before you spout out your opinions.
Hey, those employers have families too you know ;-) ...seriously, you sound like a fifth grader... "ooh, ooh, mommie look at him! He's doing it too!" (sniff, sniff)
If the illegal immigration slow down because our economy is also slow, is a good time to pass laws that protect our country from future increase of illegal immigrants, and expedite visas for people that want to come legally for temporary or permanent jobs. The issue of illegal immigration is exploited for political gain , leaving our borders and states without legal protection. If Democrats a so worry with the conditions of illegals immigrants coming to this country this administration should make more effort to reduce the illegal immigrants, allowed it is allow unscrupulous employers abuse those illegals workers treating them like slaves, with no benefits. Conservatives group do not want it , so we must stop the illegal immigration controlling our borders , also stop employers hiring illegals with fees and also jail time if it is necessary , that apply also for people that provide shelter. Any state or Town that is Sanctuary state or town should not receive any federal or state found.
Thank Goodness. We don't have enough jobs, and we are running out of space, tearing down the forests and building way too many houses, condos, etc to try to support the constant immigration. We are no longer a vast, empty developing land. It is time to cut all immigration down to certain more manageable numbers, even legal.
commonsense must be one of those libs that doesnt understand the difference of words when you put 'IL' in front of a word like legal.
Commonsense is parroting nonsenses.
A falsehood.
http://www.kqed.org/w/pacificlink/history/usimmigration/
Isn't it properly "Emigration from Mexico" the correct main-page title for this article?
I'm thinking commonsense is simply pointing out that conservative babbling about "conservative, Christian" values is utterly hypocritical in the face of xenophobic prohibition of immigration. Especially with comments like ORB, "Keep the Beaners south of the border - it is where the illegals BELONG." it's pretty obvious that the conservative standpoint on this is incredibly un-Christian. So you guys don't have the right to bitch about the city not calling it a "Christmas tree" or gays being allowed to marry, or secularists in politics, because we're all sick and tired of you picking and choosing your "Christian values". Either imitate Christ, or quit telling everyone you do. Your choice.
By the way ORB, my wife is Mexican, so you can go straight to hell.
I have lived in Australia and New Zealand. There are no illegal immigrants in those countries. As quickly as they are spotted, they are arrested and put in camps. Less than 1% are granted the right to stay in those countries for any reason.
Is it any coincidence that they have balanced budgets, minute trade deficits and much stronger currencies? They have no foreign debt to speak about and even though they are thoroughly racists, they are very peaceful, law abiding, safe countries.
Good. Pack their sh!t and send 'em all back.
So this report verifies what I have always said. Stop feeding them, stop housing them, stop providing them with healthcare, and stop giving them free education and they will self-deport.
Jobs? Who needs jobs? All they need to do is cross the border and deliver an anchor baby and they will get welfare for doing nothing. No jobs needed! Just because there 'are no jobs' doesn't mean they have stopped coming over.
Exactly. No great loss for this Country. In fact, it'd be a hell of an improvement if the trend continues.
Sgt
Sorry your argument against the right wing really doesn't stand up. Of the 74 co-sponsors to Rep Lamar Smith's mandatory E-Verify (the Legal Workforce Act H.R.2885) bill only 1 of them is a Democrat - Rep. Jason Altmire (D-PA.)
You know your economy is in really sad shape when even would-be illegal aliens no longer see this country as the land of opportunity and would prefer to stay away!
How in the hell do they know this? Ohh the facts and figures we get showered with hahaha. They still have all the construction jobs, even if they are down. Those Americans that used to do construction, now have to, or had to go to school and switch careers. Now skilled labor is saturated and we have a huge school loan debt as a country, with no jobs to take in these newly aquired skilled laborers. What a @!$%#ing web we weave here in America!
I am curious as to how many of you have looked at the face of illegal immigration. I have and let me paint you a picture of what I see everyday.
Illegal husband goes to work 5-6 days a week to a manual labor or somewhat skilled laborer (some are learning and developing trades in electrical, tile, home repair w/o any traditional training or certifications). Illegal Wife stays home takes care of the kids usually babysits 1 or 2 small children for around $20/day per child ($800 month tax free), cooks, clean and manages Dr appointments and shows up to welfare office with all paperwork completed to collect food stamps and medicaid. Welfare paperwork indicates wife is not married and therefore receives full benefits for all children and self if pregnant. Husband (earns $600-800/week) comes home with buddies from work and congregates outside of their apt with about 5 friends throwing trash and cigarette butts wherever they fall. Meanwhile kids are running amok and unsupervised. Saturday and Sunday is the big family shopping day (paid for with Food stamp card) then they continue their shopping only this time they are actually paying out of pocket for clothes and jewelry. They have multiple cars for husband (decked out with rims and stereo systems with fake tags or inspection). 4 people may have the same ID. I see a total disregard for the laws we have in place and a complete and total disrespect for people in authority positions.
Big picture, they are earning $3000-$4000 a month, collecting food-stamp and receiving free medical and usually living with an additional male in the household who contributes to a portion of the rent for a place to sleep, cooking and laundry service provided by the wife.
It has nothing to do with political parties of racism. It has to do with responsibility. If you work hard and are willing to contribute and work to become a legal resident then by all means welcome ( and i do see this, however is is a disproportionate amount), but if you are here looking for a hand out, then get out.
Increased border security and increased deportations of illegals are also part of the story here since Obama took office. The Republicans don't want to give him credit for this, but the truth always wins in the end.
The border was wide open under George W. Bush.
wildcat
In FY2011 Mr Obama deported (removed and returned) less illegal aliens then have been deported since 1971.
During the previous administration Mr Bush deported 5x the number of illegals that Mr Obama has during his administration.
After the second full year of his presidency (FY 2011), Mr Obama has deported 1.5 million illegal aliens. At the same point in his presidency (FY 2003), Mr Bush had deported 3.5 million illegal aliens.
But Mr Obama is the 1st president with illegal alien relatives living in the country evading deportation.
First question I had as well, Lusitania.
LMAO! I did not know that, if true, but funny anyway! Other than that, he seems a decent person, though.
jenj306- False Fallacy just makes you sound foolish. stop making up things out of preconceptions in your obviously vacant mind. The poor are always the easiest to attack and blame when things aren't going so well. It's happened for as long as man has held regent over others. It just makes you sound arrogant to others in need, yet your no more than an insignificant pimple on the ass of the rich. There are plenty that look down their noses at the likes of you and I. That I can assure you. Your bluster just adds fuel to their fire.
The writer of this article should really check his facts and numbers. There are at least 20 million ILLEGAL immigrants in this country. They are very hard to count, as they hide in the shadows and work for cash. I live in and around them. They could care less about our laws, and steal from our government systems. They have formed their own society within ours, and can easily hide. Other illegal immigrants, as well as the now anchor babies help them to obtain housing and jobs. They take over entire neighborhoods by the block. They drive out other Legal Citizens from the neighborhoods that they colonize. The ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS are worse racists than I have seen at a KKK rally on TV. They feel as though we stole this land from them, and are willing to do anything to get it back. They hate and despise white Americans. They and their old governments work together to organize and defeat our laws and systems. They steal identities, forge documents, and lower standards of living for legal Americans. They drive without insurance, causing hardship to those that they crash into. They can't even be sued as they technically don't exist on paper. Their gangs bring hardcore drugs into our country, and rape and kill with out care as they can easily hide among us as they have no documents.
These people are nothing but criminals, and not minor ones like some on here would like to portray. Should we as LEGAL AMERICAN CITIZENS allow OUR FAMILIES to suffer so these CRIMINALS may feed theirs????
TO THE IDIOT THAT QUOTED BIBLICAL SCRIPTURE, DOES GOD LOOK FAVORABLY TO THOSE THAT COMMIT CRIMES? YOUR QUOTES ONLY MENTION THE "ALIEN", BUT WHAT DO THEY SAY ABOUT A "CRIMINAL ALIEN"? YOU TWIST WORDS TO FIT YOUR REALITY, AND IGNORE WHAT IS TRULY BEING SAID.
I would be proud to help those that come to our country legally. To those that commit crimes to be here, I say you are my enemy, and I shall treat you as one. You hurt our country and families because you are COWARDS that are afraid to fix your own countries. You break our laws and hurt our citizens because it is easier than fixing your own problems.
NH_Shellback some pretty impressive stats you have there, wouldn't mind stating their origin would ya?
jeffery
Sure thing, my source for numbers is the Department of Homeland Security
fiscal years 1892 - 2010
www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/statistics/yearbook/2010/table36.xls
fiscal year 2011
www.ice.gov/news/releases/1110/111018washingtondc.htm
Floyd-False fallacy strikes again, when are you ever going to print something with originating documented support? Nobody will ever pay legitimate attention to your meandering writing's as anything other than rubbish. Hell why not make it 50 million, you know they breed like cockroaches....right?
Commonsense: You do realize that the word alien refers to stranger or foreigner, don't you? It doesn't mean to blindly let them in and at the same time allow them to ignore the laws which the others must follow. I wish atheists would stop quoting the bible if they don't know the context.
The Bible commands God's people to interact with civil authorities in the following ways:
NH Shellback, your 1st link delivers as code and your 2nd link takes me to the ICE page. This isn't an easter egg hunt man. Maybe a statistic page and paragraph supporting your argument would work a little better for all of us.
Gee Jeffery, maybe you should do some reading. I have read many articles that portray the real numbers of illegal immigrants at much higher values than what this writer used. You sound as though you have the ear of everyone on here as to the value of my words. And yes, I could easily compare them to cockroaches, as they are an infestation. When I go to the grocery store, I see many of them pregnent toting 3 to 5 children behind them. When they check out, they are using food stamps, and then taking their groceries and kids out to a 50k vehicle.
You can go ahead and stand up for your criminal friends, and you can go back home with them for all I care.
Deport ILLEGAL FOREIGN NATIONALS in this country. No rewards for immigration lawbreaking! Americans across the political spectrum (including this Democrat) understand that ILLEGAL immigration imposes catastrophic costs (financial and otherwise) upon United States citizens and LEGAL immgrants! Enforce our laws! We permit 1 Million LEGAL immigrants into our country EVERY YEAR! We cannot sustain this blackmarket labor scheme, as it despresses wages and shifts the true costs of doing business onto the backs of the American taxpayers who are forced to subsidize these lawbreaking business profiteers ILLEGAL business schemes by being forced to pay the healthcare and other costs of the ILLEGAL workforce!
Bible quotations are irrelevant in this matter. I'm ALL FOR the right to worship ANY WAY you choose and ANY DEITY(IES) you want, but in this Country, SECULAR law supersedes BIBLICAL law (OR TORAH OR KORAN law or what have you). Therefore, if SECULAR law states that crossing the border without authorization or proper legitimate documentation is ILLEGAL, then it MUST be respected and ENFORCED. That simple.
Try again, "Commonsense."
@Travis-1944:
I don't think that Jesus would avocate breaking the law like illegal aliens do. They enter the country unlawfully, steal a Social Security number, ruin someone else's credit in the process, and work for $3 / hour while a qualified American ends up not getting what should be a $10 / hour job. Then they drop an anchor baby and sign up for welfare benefits, without ever paying a dime in income taxes. That doesn't sound very "Christian" to me, nor does standing up for such criminal and economy-destroying behavior. People who break the law always, ALWAYS, have an excuse for why it is justified to do so. So tell me... how many illegal Mexican immigrants are working for your business at $3 / hour? Or how many of your relatives are fence-hopping border bunnies? You have an agenda, it is clear, and it isn't in the best interest of our national security or our faltering economy.
Shandril, you give them far to much credit, You should be worried about your white neighbor stealing your identity and SSN a lot more than an uneducated border crosser and thats a fact.
Let me ask you folks something if you don't mind. When did poor become synonymous with bad/criminal and Rich and Wealthy with all thats good and just. The reason I ask is I just don't see the same cause and effect as you folks. so maybe you can explain it to those of us that are a whole lot more pissed off at those that caused this decline, Wall Street and Banks to big to fail. When we went from immigrant farm worker to the label of illegal alien. Please explain your rationale. I am way way curios.
I would close with Peace, but I think most of you are just simply more interested in war. I surly hope none of you are my neighbors.
Poor Jeffery,
You really are such a confused little man. Its not the individual that is solely responsible for stealing of identities and the other crimes, but they are criminals just the same. How hard you would cry if a bank stole your identity and screwed up your credit and finances. My white neighbor is much less unlikely to steal my identity than an illegal immigrant. Most illegals don't even know or live by the people that they harm. It appears to them to be a faceless crime, which makes it SEEM like less of a crime.
No one here is saying that being poor is the same as being a criminal. While I agree that these people are poor for the most part, and are only trying to better their lives, I think that anyone would be upset at any person, rich or poor, of any color or nationalality, that commits such crimes. You sure like to twist your facts to meet your perspective don't you.
Yes, we are in a bad situation greatly caused by the too big to fail banks, but there are so many more people to blame for the situation we are in. Illegal immigration was here before we failed, taking jobs from legal Americans, and lowering the standard of wages. We didn't pay enough attention to them before, and now that we are in a fiscal @!$%#hole, it is easier to see what they have been and are doing to this country and its legal citizens.
The illegal immigrant population are criminals, and there is no way that you can say that they aren't. They committed their first crime by crossing into our country ILLEGALLY, and they continue to commit crimes trying to stay here.
To be honest, I feel bad for anyone that is that desparate to hurt another country and its citizens so they can live, but we had to, and continue to fight in this country to make it a better place to live, and they should be just as responsible with their own country.
commonsense....:
Hey! How about this for a reasonable Immigration Policy?
Let's let in (about) 1,000,000 people EVERY YEAR! We'll send them OFFICIAL invitations to reside in OUR Country!
Oh! Crap! We ALREADY do that! Sorry...
For you bleeding hearts out there: There are the better part of 6 BILLION humans that would give their right arm and first born to live in the poverty our POOREST Citizens live in!
Although we do invite (LEGALLY) a number of downtrodden our immigration system was NEVER designed for that. It is to INVITE, for the most part, people who will contribute the the well being of OUR COUNTRY and OUR ECONOMY!
We only need to bring in about a BILLION non productive people and we will be in the same boat with China and India! No resources and no money...
We are helping OUR COUNTRY, how, by having ILLEGALS here? Every job one of them takes is a JOB that one of OUR CITIZENS needs to survive!
@ floyd-1128183
Agreed
Aside from illegals lowering the standard wages on a number of blue-collar jobs ranging from construction to landscaping. Don't forget that most of them work under the table, they also use their kids' SSID numbers to apply for every government benefit they can. This costs states BILLIONS of dollars thanks to the numerous unfunded federal mandates.
Things like:
But the insidious part is that because their pay is undocumented, these people are able to qualify for the maximum level of benefits (qualifiers typically limited to the permanently disabled)! This means that legitimately working-poor families that need social assistance cannot get anywhere close to the level of benefits that illegal aliens typically get, the programs themselves are stressed by the added numbers of applicants, and the taxpayers have to foot the bill just so that a bunch of businesses and individuals can save a few bucks of their own while forcing the costs onto the taxpayer!
The federal government doesn't care, they don't have to directly pay for it, but by pandering to the groups that sympathize with the illegals they garner their vote!
Considering what we are seeing with this reversing trend of illegal immigration. That's all the evidence we need to be able to show that much of the problem could be dealt with by simply going after individuals and businesses that hire illegal aliens! I'm tired of the government always trying to pass increasingly broad-sweeping and invasive powers that infringe on personal liberties when we know full-well that they will be used on citizens and still ignore illegals!
The laws to convict, fine and even imprison infringing businesses are already on the books! ENFORCE THOSE LAWS! It would dry up the demand for illegal labor and reduce the ability for illegal aliens to stay in the US!
Well Floyd ain't you the uppity pile of male machismo. I wonder if old Floyd is just a withered up old stump of what used to be a man. If you want to insult my manhood or dignity I'll be glad to go toe to toe with ya, You name the rules and we can get that game started at anytime your man enough to puff up again?
I have twisted nothing, I just can't figure out what happened to my Party before it became a discombobulated train wreck more interested in birth control and abortion than with real issues.
My point is this there Billy Bob, the only difference between the little brown man and the black one is the lighter color of their skin. this has nothing to do with Illegal. the Mexican race criminals you complain about are citizens, not migrants. THATS A FACT. The Crips, Los Ambras, MS 13 are all US citizens. Illegals keep a low profile and the last thing they want to do is call attention to themselves. Them's the facts Billy Bob, You can't twist them up differently and if times were better we wouldn't be talking about the little brown man other wise known as your NEW enemy.
Thats the real fact, drugs are illegal too. Yet 10% of the Anglo population in America admits to regular use. When are you going to get it? The enemy lives behind the high walls of their estates and talk of us as if we were cattle. You better wake up Billy...I' mean Floyd!
There is a direct correlation between the administration's lack of effort to stem illegal immigration and their strong efforts to keep voter registration requirements to a minimum. It's all about votes folks and the obsession the liberals have to remain in power, despite a very poor record and the tremendous debt the country now faces!
Everyone should be welcome to come to the United States provided they come legally. If they are already here illegally, then they must be on the road to US Citizenship or they return to their country of origin. This applies to everyone equally and not just our neighbor to the south. Additionally, illegal immigrants are not entitled to any services that I as the American Taxpayer pay for. My ancestors came here and did not (nor wanted) a free handout. Yes, I am a democrat, but we have our own who come first.
The United States of America was founded on immigration. Lady Liberty stands in New York Harbor and proudly displays"Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free. "
www.lightomega.org/worldwatch/StatueofLiberty.html
For everyone who is whining that illegal immigrants are taking our jobs.. Stop whining. There are plenty of jobs that to many Americans feel is 'beneath' them, and are afraid to get their hands dirty.
To all of you righties.. stop blaming Obama yet again. If you can do better, than by all means, run for President.
Seriously? No...Really?! where do you clowns come up with these conspiracies? Do you just catch tidbits of conversations and spin it into the "Godfather" of border jumpers? You guys probably didn't even complete high school yourselves. No sense wasting anymore time on imbeciles , God knows you'll never make it as political pundits. I know what Bill means by the Bubble now...To funny. I'm outta this "going nowhere" hate fest.
Geez Jeffery, talk about spouting stupid quotes without any facts. You seem to be a master at it. You started the "game", I was just trying to talk reason with you but I found myself feeling like I was educating a child. You react so defensively, that you must feel like everyone is picking on poor Jeffy. I have seen your shortsighted comments on here, making like those you disagree with are idiots, yet I have not seen too many that agree with your posts. I wonder why. (sarc) You really don't have a clue what is causing this problem, or why. I appears that you just like to argue the facts, without anything to back up your claims. You just spout insults. Now, go brush your teeth, and get to bed before your mommy finds out your using her computer.
PappaDave-956353
@commonsense.... has no commonsense. His screen name is a misnomer on his part. If you don't agree with his philosophy, you are immediately labeled a "racist" and a "bigot" and that's supposed to shut you up and end the discussion right then and there and he 'wins'. Whatever that's supposed to mean.
The fact is he can call me those things all he wants to, but I'm not gonna change my opinion here and I'll continue to speak out about it as long as the mods here let me.
See, people like @commonsense.... really don't want immigration reform. They just want a whole wide unregulated border that people can freely cross over whenever they feel like it. Drugs? No problem. Just legalize it. People? Hey, come on over. We'll patronize you and kiss your ass as much as we can.
He doesn't care as long as you kiss minority ass and don't say anything. Just like his friends over at La Raza expect him to. So let's hope he'll have brains enough to put on his ignore list 'cause I'm not gonna shut up about it.
Itsabouttime-3704531: Obama can't even deal with his own illegal relatives. So yeah, it is his fault! WE don't need to run for President. We just need to elect someone who can do better.
Here's a little story they did on our President's Relatives:
Our President's aunt, Zeituni Onyango, first came to our attention during the Senator's remarkable theft of the Presidency in 2008; there was no doubt but that she represented a serious threat to his ambitious ascendancy to the Presidency. You may recall she's the aunt who was in the USA illegally, living in Boston and receiving welfare.
This TV news report interviews her and calls her "fiery." Can you imagine being in Russia illegally for years and years, for instance and having the unmitigated gall to tape a TV interview and act "fiery?" But then again that would never happen as Russia would never allow that sort of thing to occur--you'd be deported or on your way to Siberia in nanoseconds if budget allowed. Some people just disappear, never to be heard of again.
If you want to get angry, really angry, watch this video. Americans were rightfully livid after hearing the story of this unapologetically arrogant woman who blamed our system for giving her so much; a place to live in public housing, $51,000 in disability payments and regular welfare payments of almost $700 per month, not to mention the taxpayer-funded hospital stays and treatments.
But we did nothing and went right ahead voting for her nephew who ignored her publicly while his campaign staff issued reports putting lots of distance between Obama, the rising star and his two feckless relatives.
Barack Hussein Obama's aunt embodies everything that is wrong with America and shows us the way to fixing such things.
Please Look above at the "news report" for the youtube connection. Or just look down below.
Unhappy, your posts are relevant (and true), but this is a liberal site and I've found that liberals really do ignore the truth if it doesn't fit their agenda. And their agenda now is to completely ignore the fact that they made a major error in electing a neighborhood organizer to be the President of the United States! We all lose....
This was posted by another user but needs repeating here.
JOE vs. JOSE
You have two families: "Joe Legal" and "Jose Illegal". Both families have two parents, two children, and live in California.
Joe Legal works in construction, has a Social Security Number and makes $25.00
per hour with taxes deducted.
Jose Illegal also works in construction, has NO Social Security Number, and
gets paid $15.00 cash "under the table".
Ready? Now pay attention...
Joe Legal: $25.00 per hour x 40 hours = $1000.00 per week, or $52,000.00 per
year. Now take 30% away for state and federal tax; Joe Legal now has $31,231.00.
Jose Illegal: $15.00 per hour x 40 hours = $600.00 per week, or $31,200.0 0 per
year. Jose Illegal pays no taxes.
Jose Illegal now has $31,200.00.
Joe Legal pays medical and dental insurance with limited coverage for his
family at $600.00 per month, or $7,200.00 per year. Joe Legal now has $24,031.00.
Jose Illegal has full medical and dental coverage through the state and local
clinics at a cost of $0..00 per year. Jose Illegal still has $31,200.00.
Joe Legal makes too much money and is not eligible for food stamps or welfare.
Joe Legal pays $500.00 per month for food, or $6,000.00 per year. Joe Legal now
has $18,031.00.
Jose Illegal has no documented income and is eligible for food stamps and
welfare. Jose Illegal still has $31,200.00.
Joe Legal pays rent of $1,200.00 per month, or $14,400.00 per year. Joe Legal
now has 9,631 .00.
Jose Illegal receives a $500.00 per month federal rent subsidy.
Jose Illegal pays out that $500.00 per month, or $6,000.00 per year. Jose
Illegal still has $31,200.00.
Joe Legal pays $200.00 per month, or $2,400.00 for insurance. Joe Legal now has
$7,231.00.
Jose Illegal says, "We don't need no stinkin'CAR insurance!" and
still has $31,200.00.
Joe Legal has to make his $7,231.00 stretch to pay utilities, gasoline, etc.
Jose Illegal has to make his $31,200.00 stretch to pay utilities, gasoline, and
what he sends out of the country every month..
Joe Legal now works overtime on Saturdays or gets a part time job after work.
Jose Illegal has nights and weekends off to enjoy with his family.
Joe Legal's and Jose Illegal's children both attend the same school. Joe Legal
pays for his children's lunches while Jose Illegal's children get a government
sponsored lunch. Jose Illegal's children have an after school ESL program. Joe
Legal's children go home.
Joe Legal and Jose Illegal both enjoy the same police and fire services, but
Joe paid for them and Jose did not pay.
If you vote for or support any politician that supports illegal aliens... or
don't vote…..
YOU ARE PART OF THE PROBLEM!!
I'd say that about
says it all folks, think about it...
da doc wrote (along with others who basically voiced the same opinion):
I'm truly amazed at the number of people who think a bad US economy is a "good thing," as long as it keeps the illegals from coming in.
It's like owning an apple tree that only has 3 apples on it, compared to the old days when it used to have hundreds. In the old days, people would come and take some of the apples, but at least the person who owned the tree ended up with a lot more than 3.
But whatever. I'm used to the insanity here, by now.
Dr. - im pretty sure the guy that produced your quote, was being facetious, you need to learn irony. He meant that the only way to get this administration to do something positive, is to fail.
trudat - I'm aware of irony. I'm also aware of when one is trying to push one's negative political agenda, as you appear to be.
Do some of you people ever listen to yourselves? Left Wingers, Right Wingers blah blah blah... You repeat the same stuff everytime, it's like telling a funny joke, the first few times it's funny, then it starts to lose anything it ever had and you just start to look like an idiot who can't come up with anything new. A bad record sounds better than some of you.
I'll never understand how people can constantly argue about the most absolute boring subject in the world... Politics. I read 2 sentences and I get a migrane.
Unhappy-158375
and just what illegal relatives does PRESIDENT Obama have? Can you be so kind as to share it with us? We already have a President that is doing 10x better on immigration than his predecessor. However, since you think we need to elect someone who can do better. Why don't you run? Or are you not better?
Here is what many fail to see Dr. Cat. As long as people can come and take from the apple tree with hundreds of apples, they'll never plant their own tree. Why bother when they can take from the one already there? If they're not allowed to take from the tree, odds are they will eventually plant their own tree.
Sadly, coming to the American apple tree has become generational. Generation after generation keeps coming to pick from the tree instead of planting their own tree.
And every time someone allows them to pick from their tree, they condemn the next generation to to the same dependency, instead of them learning to take responsibility for their own.
The average person in Mexico makes $6000 US dollars a year. Currently, just to file the application to enter the country costs $1100 USD and the actual road to being abe to work here legally runs about $5200 dollars after filing fees, fingerprint fees, processing fees, application fees. Would the average American be able to save their entire paycheck for one year? For most of us the answer would be no, because you still have things like rent, groceries, transportation, clothing and incidental expenses. So lets say a person from Mexico saves upthe money, files the appplications, comes to the US legally. They file all the paperwork to come here legally, then they have to wait for USCIS to get around to their paperwork. And they wait. And they wait. Their temporary papers expire while they are still waiting, and you can only get a few extensions before they deny you and say you're undocumented and they place you in deportation, And when they place you in deportation, your home, your car, your bank account are seized as civil asset forfeiture and any children you may have had while you were waiting for USCIS to get to your paperwork are taken from you and you're dumped back over the border minus everything you worked for and out the $5k you paid to do things legally.
Actually, it's not that easy. Citizenship on the basis of marrying an American citizen went out some time ago now if you marry a US citizen they can apply to sponsor you but it it just gives you higher priority in the processing, it doesn't guarantee you citizenship, and it doesn't mean you don't still have to pay all the fees, pass the background check, and jumpthroigh the legal hoops. See the below from an associated press interview with Rachel Wilson, an immigration attorney in Tucson AZ (I can't get the link to stick):
"Out there, there is this perception that there is a process you can easily go through to become legal, but let's say you're Mexican as an example, since most of the immigrants in Tucson are from Mexico. You decide you want to move to the U.S. for economic opportunity, but if you don't have any family members here ... that will sponsor a visa for you, there is no way for them to come legally to the U.S. If a person wants a work visa in the U.S., and eventually to become a citizen, it's easier if they have a relative in the country who has legal status and can file a petition on their behalf. In those instances there are lines of people waiting -- a wait that can go from a period of a few years to sometimes almost a decade."
Mexico happens to be the most backlogged of all the countries. For example, next month the State Department will look at petitions of brothers and sisters of adult citizens that were filed in January 1994. "Let's say you're Mexican and you have a brother or sister in the United States who petitions for you. Here we are in 2010, and they are processing petitions that were filed in 1994. So that's a wait of 16 years," Wilson says.
If you needed a social security card to wok and it took 16 years to get you'd be working undocumented too, because you have to have money to live while you're waiting for ICE to get to your paperwork. That's the difference bewteen undocumenteds and illegals. Illegals are the ones who are undocumented AND have actually committed a crime; undocumenteds are here legally but ICE just hasn't gotten around to their paperwork yet, or they have lost or misplaced it in the 16 year wait time. To then penalize these people by incarceration and deportation when they are here legally would be unconstitutional--it's not fair to penalize someone for someone else's, or in this case, a government agency's, mistake.
I'm all for deporting the truly illegal--the ones who hopped the border, shot a cop, and deal drugs. But for those who are simply undocumented--came here legally and their paperwork expired but they are still waiting...there should be extennsions granted for thiose individuals and they shouldn't be deported until USCIS has looked at their applications and made the decision to deny right of residency.
I was declared by ICE to be illegal, and I neither came here illegally nor have I ever committed a crime. I was an undocumented infant 9baby abandoned with no paperwork at an international orphanage) who was brought to the US and legally adopted by a Vietnam vet and his wife, who subsequently passed away in a car accident before ever telling me I was adopted. 18 years after my adoption USCIS does a routine record search, finds they've loast/misplaced/misfiled my adoption paper, and comes to me for a copy. I, having never even known I was adopted, said 'what papers?' when they said 'Papers please.' And they declared me illegal and dumped me in deportation. Since I have no original birth certificate that says what ciuntry I was born in, they couldn't deport me so they said I'd stay in deportation until I gave them a copy of a paper I never even knew I had. It took me three years of writing letters to every courthouse in three states just trying to find that document.
And then there's my coworker's mother, who was adopted from Germany as an orphan in 1945. Immigration at the time never told her paents that citizenship wasn't automatic with the adoption. In december of last year, 60+ years after her adoption, ICE calls her up, tells her she's no longer a citizen because the proper paperwork was never filed, seize her home, car, bank account and deport her to Germany two weeks later. She was never given the opportunity to file paperwork to correct the mistake and her 90 year old parents went to Immigration to explain that they were never told. But no amnesty was granted even for Immigration's mistake and she was deported to Germany 2 days before Christmas last year without having seen a judge, lawyer or trial.
“We call things racism just to get attention. We reduce complicated problems to racism, not because it is racism, but because it works.” - Alfredo Gutierrez
Finally a headline i can believe, "Immigration" at a standstill, that i can believe, but if they are trying to say ILLEGAL immigration is at a stand still, thats a damn LIE!
This report was released ONLY because the Supreme Court is hearing the Arizona Law. Obama has to be behind this news release, so he can claim there is no problem during his Campaign.
They want you to believe ANYTHING they print. Immigration, both illegal and legal are at an all time high in this country. So funny ANY of you would believe this. All you have to do is go to any WALMART and see that clearly, no mexicans or any other immigrants are left in America. WAKE THE HELL UP PEOPLE. AT a all time high, I don't need anyone to tell me what my own two eyes SHOW me. Remember folks, it is an election year, the facts will be twisted more than in previous years.
Illegal entry to the nation is no different then illegal entry to your home its illegal, that's why it is termed illegal! and since it is illegal it should be handled as illegal (criminal) why do some people have difficulty with that? if a American crosses into another country illegally, they go to prison so why should we allow anyone that enters America illegally to remain, some of these people are here to do you wrong, just like a burglar in your home they don'tbelong. there are legal ways to enter the country they can use that process. as for the states that extradite illegals that should be their right the federal government cant or wont deal with it so let the states deal with it. Obama claims he expels more illegals then his predecessor? looks like he is just taking credit for what some Governors are doing while trying to undermine there efforts. this really is a no brainer.
Need a example Chief of the Indian confederate nations to chief Tecumseh" let the English stay they wont hurt anything", there are only a few of them.
For your reading pleasure
I'm all for reforming how our nation handles immigration, making it easier for tourists to visit, and making it easier for the educated and oppressed who want to become Americans to emigrate here.
What I want to stop are simply two things
This article shows that if we went after the offending parties that hire illegal aliens, we could handily dry up the incentives for illegals to come here and many would self-deport just as they are doing now in the down economy.
American and assimilates himself to us he shall be treated on an exact equality with every one else, for it is an outrage to discriminate against any such man because of creed or birth-place or origin.
But this is predicated upon the man's becoming in very fact an American and nothing but an American. If he tries to keep segregated with men of his own origin and separated from the rest of America, then he isn't doing his part as an American. There can be no divided allegiance here. . . We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language, for we intend to see that the crucible turns our people out as Americans, of American nationality, and not as dwellers in a polyglot boarding-house; and we have room for but one soul loyalty, and that is loyalty to the American people.
Amanda,
As for the $5000 you claim it costs to enter the US legally (not true), apparently plenty of illegal aliens are able to raise thousands to pay to the coyotes who bring them across. If they can afford that, they could afford to apply through legal channels, where the fees for a family-based visa run around $500.
@ Sherrie-299765
I believe it has more to do with the amount of time it takes to get a worker's visa and visas for a family than the cost of acquiring those documents.
When you're dirt-poor and looking for opportunity in a wealthy country, there's probably a lot of incentives to taking the fast-track rather than the legal one.
On top of that, I bet that the smugglers do more advertising and spread a lot of misinformation about how difficult it is to do things legitimately...but that's just me guessing.
jenj306
You are the worst kind of racist of all. In your rant about the daily life of an illegal, you are actually describing Mexican immigrants and your disgust of how they live. You really sound like the biggest racist red-neck around. Why don't you come right out and say that you hate Mexicans? There are other white illegal immigrants. Why don't you say anything about the illegal Irish textile workers in Chicago? Can you not see into their apartments to see how they live? If you are so familiar with the way that the dirty Mexicans who throw trash about and let their kids run amok live, you probably live in a low-income area and are just poor white trash and feel envious about the family that you don't have.
Let's look at your typical day, shall we?
Wake up at the crack of 10:30. Your boyfriend's two-year-old daughter is sitting in front of your old TV in a dirty diaper eating a bowl of cereal that she just barely managed to make herself only because your boyfriend left the milk on the kitchen table while he rushed off to his job at the Circle K.
You step out on the porch to have a quick smoke, letting the smoke drift back in to cover the smell of the diaper you still haven't changed.
Now you're ready to start your day. You put on your marijuana leaf tank top (no bra) and your short, too-tight shorts that say PINK or ABERCROMBIE on the butt and walk down to McDonald's for a couple of sausage mcmuffins. Then it's back to your apartment where you spend all day looking at the Mexican neighbors' kids laughing and playing and being healthy.
No wonder you hate Mexicans.
Pretty soon the problem be Gringos crossing over into Mexico (?)
Seriously doubt it. It stinks down there.
No doubt, went there for a few days a few years ago and they warn the tourists not to go off the beaten track otherwise it's yer own arse. One shop keeper told us Mexico is paradise in the toilet......
That "stink" is in the mind of the beholder.
Now if only the cartels would help keep drugs from crossing over too.....
inmissouri: It will never happen because there are to many middle and high income white guys on drugs which the media tys to hide.
Yeah right hawk. It's only the white man, as usual (sarc).
Yeah, people don't bathe too much down there. Maybe they can get lessons in hygiene from commonsense....
If he has any...
lol...
LOL.........beat me to it.........I was going to say time for us "Mericans" to go to "Mexico" to find work, our stimulous plan worked so well, we stimulated ourselves out of work and money....but we did stimulate Wall Street and the Bank CEO bonus'....oh, and the 1% of course...... :)
See - Obama has dealt with the immigration problem. His total incompetence and inability to restart the economy where he even undermines it does have this one good effect. He is destroying our economy to the point where even the Mexicans don't want any part of it.
Typical repub - Blame Obama for everything bad and then say that good things happened in spite of him.
Blame anyone you want...just get the illegals out of here, one way or another!
Your boy Bush had the destruction of the economy all taken care of - but you already know that.
Typical dem. - Never blame Obama, even if he had the smoking gun in his hand.
How about blaming the real culprits here - the companies that hire them? This is proof that they won't come if there's no jobs. Yet all I hear is your kind screaming about and dehumanizing the illegal immigrants. You won't spend more than a tiny moment barely paying lip service to the real cause of the problem, but you'll scream incessantly about the illegal immigrants....
It's amazing that you all are that two faced. It truly is amazing.
And his boy Holden as they sent the guns to Mexico so they can kill people on both sides of the border.
With 15 million plus illegal immigrates in the US it is way past time to put immigration on hold. I have no issue with those who follow the rules that we have in place to become a citizen of the US, but we need none of those that think our laws do not not apply to them.
How can you stop legal Latinos from hiring illegal Latinos?
Lets see if I've got this right. From the story it was the Republicans that killed the immigrations bill in 2007 but it's Obama's fault. Ok now tell me when the Republicans are ever going to earn up to their blunders.
Bush killed the economy with his tax cuts and wild spending but the bad economy is Obama's fault.
Bush raised the federal deficit to over $11 trillion dollars yet it's Obama's fault that the interest on that deficit has to be paid.
It's the Republicans in congress that have killed every jobs bill since 2009 but it's Obama's fault that the job market sucks.
Congress should leave the partisan politics at the front door and work to get this country back on it's feet but all I see from the Republicans is their agenda to make Obama a one term president. Yeah it's Obama's fault that the TEA party nuts have got the Republican party under their thumb. That's why this Independent is not going to vote for another Republican until they get their head out of their posterior and work for all the American people instead of the elite 1 percent.
Obama could enforce the immigration law but he decides not to. Its not blame, its fact.
Said it before and I'll say it again What part of Illegal Don't You Moronic Liberals Get!!!!!
If You are here illegaly you are a criminal period. You are breaking the law.
Immigration is for law abiding people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That's a lie and you know it. The border enforcement is greater than it's ever been yet we hear the same old talking points from the right wing nuts.
So this is the reason BO is spending our tax dollars fighting Arizona's law protecting the county from illegal immigrants.
lfergie, your mind works in strange ways, move south please, we will let you cross the border with no hassle.
So laughable, I remember thinking in 2008 that there was surprisingly not as much bigotry as I thought there would be with Obama running for POTUS. That fact of the matter is, these, um, dumb red voting jackazzes NEVER thought he would get elected. Now that he is in office, they are spittin' mad! Imagine that! Hahahahahaha. Call a waaaahhhhhbulance!
Immigration has been a major issue since the birth of this country. I am always amazed that people don't know their own history, NOR DO THEY CARE to know. I think that's this is a bigger problem: the current, prevailing opinion of higher education (that's beyond high school). Many, many people brought up in blue collar households are taught to scorn higher education and are very quick to point out "IT AIN'T FOR EVERYBODY, YA KNOW". Do you think our competitors in China and India have that attitude?
The thing about Obama is that he promised a utopia on earth and change, change, change and that is how he got elected.
th2921@aol.com
Not true at all, he cant enforce them, he's too busy suing states that do.
The Obama administration has addressed immigration with the following multistep plan.
1 - Made the politically correct term for "illegal aliens" to be "undocumented immigrants"
2 - Granted Aunt Zeituni Onyango citizenship, after she ignored a judge's order to leave the country
3 - Granted Uncle Onyango Obama a get-out-of-jail free card, which was used to be released from being held by ICE, even though he is in violation of a deportation order from 1992.
4 - Issued a presidential order which granted backdoor amnesty to as many as 300,000 illegal aliens in order to pander to Hispanics and Latinos.
5 - Filed lawsuits against every state attempting to legally address the illegal alien issue
6 - Created and proliferated a lie that they are deporting more illegal aliens that any other administration
If ever there was more evidence to show that going after businesses and individuals that hire illegal aliens to do labor for them would put a MASSIVE dent in the rate of illegal immigration!
We don't need to have paddy wagons haul off scores of people and uproot families in some sort of dehumanizing forced exodus.
Many illegals would, and are, self-deporting when the jobs dry up. If the US would stop allowing people and businesses to skirt the law and cheat the system, it would do better for everyone involved.
lfergie812 - great posts with a tremendous amount of applause from Texas.
Here's a little story on our Presidents' relatives:
Our President's aunt, Zeituni Onyango, first came to our attention during the Senator's remarkable theft of the Presidency in 2008; there was no doubt but that she represented a serious threat to his ambitious ascendancy to the Presidency. You may recall she's the aunt who was in the USA illegally, living in Boston and receiving welfare.
This TV news report interviews her and calls her "fiery." Can you imagine being in Russia illegally for years and years, for instance and having the unmitigated gall to tape a TV interview and act "fiery?" But then again that would never happen as Russia would never allow that sort of thing to occur--you'd be deported or on your way to Siberia in nanoseconds if budget allowed. Some people just disappear, never to be heard of again.
If you want to get angry, really angry, watch this video. Americans were rightfully livid after hearing the story of this unapologetically arrogant woman who blamed our system for giving her so much; a place to live in public housing, $51,000 in disability payments and regular welfare payments of almost $700 per month, not to mention the taxpayer-funded hospital stays and treatments.
But we did nothing and went right ahead voting for her nephew who ignored her publicly while his campaign staff issued reports putting lots of distance between Obama, the rising star and his two feckless relatives.
Barack Hussein Obama's aunt embodies everything that is wrong with America and shows us the way to fixing such things.
So... Obama is being judged by his "HALF" Aunt's actions? You mean everyone in the Obama family must have the highest reputation in the world? They are not able to make any mistakes or do something wrong? Wow, you really have set the bar high for the First Family haven't you.
When are you running for President?
The Federal Government has a plan it just takes a little time to work. first you send all the jobs to Mexico and other countries and all the illegals will eventually follow. the only ones that will remain are the ones on welfare. problem solved the politically correct way, no feelings hurt.
Have you noticed there are more Mexican flags flying in California and Texas then there are in Mexico, and if you visit Southern California you almost have to speak Spanish.
There's a reason for the court case that goes beyond the issue of immigration: precedent. If the Federal government doesn't fight Arizona here, the next time that a state wants to do something that traditionally is a federal responsibility (say, foreign policy), the government's position will be that much weaker. When an issue is before the Supreme Court, the underlying case is often of little or no consequence .. it is the principle.
Si
Bush had the whole thing under control.
maya-4019459: Bush jr could not stay sober enough to get himself under control.
Mr Bush did a much better job than Mr Obama. He deported 5x more illegal aliens during his administration than Mr Obama has.
@ NH_Shellback
Actually quite the opposite
While I disagree with Obama taking every opportunity to NOT DEAL WITH THE IMMIGRATION ISSUE, more illegal aliens have been deported under his administration in 2.5 years than under all 8 years of Bush's.
Those are the facts.
NH_Shellback - Did former President Bush give you this information himself?
People are blind, this nation has no hope.
This news article is not news to me. I see the tendency everyday. People who has been here for years illegally are trying to leave and they are telling their people that the "American Dream" is dead.
It's not the guards at the borders or the criminals nor the stiff penalties that are stopping illegal immigration. It's our dead economy, the hate that's overpowering our society, discrimination and so on that's driving them away.
.
These are the facts per the Dept of Home Security
Fiscal Year numbers adjusted for Administration - I'll take Bush for 10.2 million
Bush Administration
Year - Removal – Return – Total Deported
2001 - 141,770 - 1,012,028 – 1,153,798
2002 - 165,168 - 1,012,116 – 1,177,284
2003 - 211,098 - 945,294 – 1,156,392
2004 - 240,665 - 1,166,576 – 1,407,241
2005 - 246,431 - 1,096,920 – 1,343,351
2006 - 280,974 - 1,043,381 – 1,324,355
2007 - 319,382 - 891,390 – 1,210,772
2008 - 359,795 - 811,263 – 1,171,058
2009 - 98,791 - 146,541- 245,332
Totals – 2,064,074 – 8,125,509 – 10,189,583
Bush Administration Removals - 2,064,074
Bush Administration Returns - 8,125,509
Bush Administration Total Deported - 10,189,583
Obama Administration
Year - Removal – Return – Total Deported
2009 - 296,374 - 439,623 – 735,997
2010 - 387,242 - 476,405 – 863,647
2011 - 396,906 – 0 – 396,906
Totals – 1,080,522 – 916,028 – 1,996,550
Obama Administration Removals - 1,080,522
Obama Administration Returns - 916,028
Obama Administration Totals - 1,996,550
Source: U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Removals are the compulsory and confirmed movement of an inadmissible or deportable alien out of the United States based on an order of removal.
Returns are the confirmed movement of an inadmissible or deportable alien out of the United States not based on an order of removal.
sources
fiscal years 2001 - 2010
www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/statistics/yearbook/2010/table36.xls
fiscal year 2011
www.ice.gov/news/releases/1110/111018washingtondc.htm
Thank you, Shellback.
I had read somewhere that the Obama administration reclassified some deportations to skew the numbers. In any case, the totals tell the story. Even without knowing the numbers, it has been obvious from other presidential actions that Obama is not applying existing law or making efforts to cut down on illegal immigration. I am also very upset about the fact that little or no I.D. is required at polling places around the country. This is turning our elections into a joke.
I reluctantly voted for Obama in '08. I don't believe the economy is his fault, although he has not done especially well in that regard and I am aghast that he has some of the very people who engineered the meltdown working in his administration. But illegal immigration is one potent reason not to vote for him in November. Then again, as in '08, look at the choices: Romney is already cuddling up to the illegal community, which not only knows how to milk the system, it knows how to wield political power.
Shame on all of them.
Well! I stand corrected!
I wonder how Reuters gets their numbers wrong. Or perhaps they are making a wild estimate based on the rate at which the deportations are occurring under the current administration.
Seriously?
At the rate the Obama Administration is deporting illegals it will take 14+ years to surpass the 10.2 Million illegals deported during the 8 years of the Bush Administration.
Yeah, I saw that from your post on the DHS, the 397K of deportations in 2011 greatly slowed compared to 2009-2010
Perhaps Reuters was trending off of just the first 2 years of data which showed a rise from 736K to 834K and assumed it would just keep on accelerating up from there. Which I guess makes sense since the Reuters article was dated 9/20/2011, which means that the 2011 DHS data likely wasn't available yet.
So, all-around in this regard, I am incorrect! Not only is Obama fighting desperately to not enforce the existing laws on the books by suing every state that tries to force his hand, but he has also made significant headway in cutting the number of deportations in 2011 by half of what it was the year prior (presuming that it wasn't arbitrarily lower (in part) because of self-deportation that the DHS measure doesn't include in that list.
The economy explanation is just a smokescreen to try and take away from the success of harsher state immigration laws like those in AZ and AL. The economy in the USA is still pretty bad right now by our standards, but it's still better than it's ever been in Mexico. What's keep the illegal aliens out now is the heightened chance that they'll be found and deported.
That's sooo funny and false.
There's a very large number of states who don't have that kind of draconian demonization law and they're seeing the same results all across the country.
Nice try - but a total fail on trying to falsify the cause of this change in illegal immigration.
I blame Obama. Oh wait...
Said it before and I'll say it again What part of Illegal Don't You Moronic Liberals Get!!!!!
If You are here illegaly you are a criminal period. You are breaking the law.
Immigration is for law abiding people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So laughable, I remember thinking in 2008 that there was surprisingly not as much bigotry as I thought there would be with Obama running for POTUS. That fact of the matter is, these, um, dumb red voting jackazzes NEVER thought he would get elected. Now that he is in office, they are spittin' mad! Imagine that! Hahahahahaha. Call a waaaahhhhhbulance!
Immigration has been a major issue since the birth of this country. I am always amazed that people don't know their own history, NOR DO THEY CARE to know. I think that's this is a bigger problem: the current, prevailing opinion of higher education (that's beyond high school). Many, many people brought up in blue collar households are taught to scorn higher education and are very quick to point out "IT AIN'T FOR EVERYBODY, YA KNOW". Do you think our competitors in China and India have that attitude?
Mick-2181854 - Its a good thing your point of view was not around when the United States was originally founded or this country would have never existed.
YAY!!! And I know the number of Mexicans isn't decreasing.....
If the Feds would spend the time enforcing immigration laws instead of sueing States it would drop even farther. I believe this report just like I believe in the Grinch. Let's ignore the laws enacted by the States that make it uncomfortable for illegals.
Offering illegals anything is moronic. How about you insist they get legalized and pay taxes or leave? Naah, that'd be the fair, logical route.
It's amazing how many of you are so willing to demonize the illegals themselves, but aren't willing to do anything more than minimal lip service against the companies and people that hire the illegals.
This article is proof that if there aren't jobs, they won't come.
If we prevent companies and people from hiring them - we don't have an illegal immigrant problem.
But I guess that concept is just too hard for the average simplistic right wing brain to comprehend.
Said it before and I'll say it again What part of Illegal Don't You Moronic Liberals Get!!!!!
If You are here illegaly you are a criminal period. You are breaking the law.
Immigration is for law abiding people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So laughable, I remember thinking in 2008 that there was surprisingly not as much bigotry as I thought there would be with Obama running for POTUS. That fact of the matter is, these, um, dumb red voting jackazzes NEVER thought he would get elected. Now that he is in office, they are spittin' mad! Imagine that! Hahahahahaha. Call a waaaahhhhhbulance!
Immigration has been a major issue since the birth of this country. I am always amazed that people don't know their own history, NOR DO THEY CARE to know. I think that's this is a bigger problem: the current, prevailing opinion of higher education (that's beyond high school). Many, many people brought up in blue collar households are taught to scorn higher education and are very quick to point out "IT AIN'T FOR EVERYBODY, YA KNOW". Do you think our competitors in China and India have that attitude?
The article was actually about the numbers of illegal immigrants lessening. Stop crying and name calling.
We will continue to have an illegal immigration problem until the administration enforces the existing laws, Congress passes mandatory E-Verify, and the laws are changed to eliminate "anchor babies".
Encourage your representative to support mandatory E-Verify ( the Legal Workforce Act H.R.2885). If Congress would vote on and pass mandatory E-Verify most illegals would self deport themselves when they were denied jobs and a source of income.
formermarinesgt, you are as fake as the day is long. There is no such thing as "former" Marine. A real Marine always states they served in the Marine Corps. Go back to the military channel & try to learn more military lingo. It works better when you don't try to include liberal bull@!$%# too.
Who they tryin' to fool, walk into a Wally World on any given weekend and you'll see a mexican mother with a whole LITTER and I mean LITTER of kids screaming and yelling at the top of their lungs like they were all at a siesta instead of a store.....
Mexico QUADRUPLED its population from 1950 to 2005. They ruined their own country. Let em stew in it.
I guess racism is alive and well in this country. Referring to Mexican people as if they are dogs...and Republicans wonder why many Democrats accuse them of hating the President simply because he is black.
Jack Dulouz
Your simple argument is what odumo is banking on. Oh poor me!
I don't hear anyone screaming about illegal immigrants from Ireland. There are plenty of them in the Northeast.
And I mean ALL people that are illegal but as you can plainly see the majority are Hispanic.....
I'll take an illegal Irish person anyday over an illegal Mexican.
What is wrong with Mexican people?
When are you all gonna stop blaming Bush and get over the fact that there's a new sheriff in town that doesn't know his six shooter from his rifle.....
Yeah you're right, just ask Osama..oh wait...
Um JD, LOL, never mind, go back to your liberal wonder land.
Is that all you have whuck?
Report's numbers are misleading, census bureau listed 10.3 million illegal immigrants living in the US in the last census, down from 11.1 million in 2008. And even those numbers are conservative. California estimates alone were well over four million illegal immigrants.
Calming before the storm. Just wait until all the produce needs to be picked and packed. They'll be back because they no Gringo, White, Black dude are going to pick them. Wake up!
Yeah, we will all starve to death. Just like we did before there were 7 million illegal aliens taking our jobs. You remember right??-- when we were all near death waiting for someone to pick our lettuce? LOL
Said it before and I'll say it again What part of Illegal Don't You Moronic Liberals Get!!!!!
If You are here illegaly you are a criminal period. You are breaking the law.
Immigration is for law abiding people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Paramed-
Then too they were picking the lettuce. Since then Gov't has taken the "Guest Worker" program out and won't let Kids from ages13-18 to pick fruits and vegetables any more. I picked fruit and beans that paid for my school clothes all summer long. It didn't kill me to develop a work ethic and have a position at the bottom of the food chain. Kids today wouldn't last a day picking to help their folks out for school clothes and college fund or car Insurance or whatever. We have become the laziest bunch of people in the world and it's beginning to show with all those "Type" of jobs out there, but people today would rather stay home and collect an unemplyment check. What if the Gov't. didn't have such a program for those people. I believe then those that were sitting around would have to accept a job as menial as picking fruit or vegeatebles to make ends meet. Then, there wouldn't be any of those jobs available for the illegals to have and they wouldn't even come. We've created most of this mess and now we expect them to pick up the slack because we're too busy laying around "Collecting" Unemployment benefits which is part of this deficit we have all been creating. If you don't like them coming, then make something happen where people have to work or pick fruit or veggies all summer to help pay for their Own wages and benefits. Or is that too much to ask and too menial kind of work for us "Americans" won't or not willing to do? You ask all the produce people who picks and sorts their fruit and veggies and then tell me how many white, Black people hold those types of positions in America. Figure that one out if you can> Just saying........
I wonder how fast we could rid ourselves of the deficit if we didn't issue food stamps, free health care, and free education to people who have never, (nor their parents) paid one dollar of taxes in our country.
They can't do that. That would mean those of us who go to work every day to pay for their food stamps, free health care, and free education might actually get back a little more of what we worked so hard for when we retire. Or we might be able to eventually improve the school system with the money saved. Oh my God, it may even make it easier to find employment in some areas if you can only speak English.
Absolutly correct,but the Nobamas can't get it through their thick sculls.
I love how Illegal Alien has become unauthorized immigrant. Like they walked beyond the yellow tape or something. This rush to not offend someone is ruining the country.
I love how the same 15 men locked in a house are obviously illegal aliens, but on the corner of a Lowe's they are not.
I love how 7 million people (and their employers) have to commit a crime in order to be employed and yet our government ignores that little fact and the citizens who are victimized.
I love how federal law requires states to provide education, housing, food and medical assistance for a problem which would not exist if they would do their job- or even let the states do their job.
I love how Mexico is the 13th or 14th (depending on statistics/source) wealthiest nation in the world and they encourage their citizens to use the US like a massive welfare program.
Said it before and I'll say it again What part of Illegal Don't You Moronic Liberals Get!!!!!
If You are here illegaly you are a criminal period. You are breaking the law.
Immigration is for law abiding people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OUR DEMODOGS just don't get it, ileagal is ileagal
So laughable, I remember thinking in 2008 that there was surprisingly not as much bigotry as I thought there would be with Obama running for POTUS. That fact of the matter is, these, um, dumb red voting jackazzes NEVER thought he would get elected. Now that he is in office, they are spittin' mad! Imagine that! Hahahahahaha. Call a waaaahhhhhbulance!
Immigration has been a major issue since the birth of this country. I am always amazed that people don't know their own history, NOR DO THEY CARE to know. I think that's this is a bigger problem: the current, prevailing opinion of higher education (that's beyond high school). Many, many people brought up in blue collar households are taught to scorn higher education and are very quick to point out "IT AIN'T FOR EVERYBODY, YA KNOW". Do you think our competitors in China and India have that attitude?
um yeah, you are dropping some good acid!
When it happens. So far it has not, but Mittens could still get elected...
He no know how illegal is defined ...
Good to hear! The funny thing about Mexico is when people from other Latin countries cross in to Mexico illegally, they are beat and put back on a bus immediately. As crappy as Mexico is..their economy is still better than all of the other Latin countries.
"IMMIGRATION?" Well that IS THE WORD used in the PMSNBC headline, isn't it?
Please PMSNBC... please explain EXACTLY... "what kind of Immigration you're referring to?"
OH... are they possibly referring to ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION or do they mean normal, LEGAL Immigration?
Legal, you know the type of Immigration that people from the other 100++ countries that Immigrants come from to the USA.
Legal, you know the type of Immigration that people from the other 100++ countries who "FILE all the necessary LEGAL documents; play by the rule and wait in line, often for YEARS; pay all the required LEGAL fees and eventually LEGALLY enter the USA?
No, it is obvious by their "disguised headline" that they "really mean ILLEGAL Immigration". If that is what they mean, then why not say it? Why the disguise? Why all the "double-speak"?
WHY any American citizen should give a damn about any country that IS SO SCREWED UP that MILLIONS and MILLIONS of their citizens have been risking their lives to FLEE from for decades and generations is beyond absurd. How or why it should be of any concern to the USA is ridiculous.
In all fairness to EVERYONE involved in this story, the USA has gone far above and far beyond what ANY other country on Earth would even begin to tolerate.
The USA has "met their quota" of ILLEGAL ALIEN CRIMINALS for the entire 21st Century decades ago.
Mexico is still providing documents to their illegals to make it easier for them to STEAL US resouces that were meant for the poor American.
This is good news because since Mexico tracks these numbers, they can reimburse U.S. taxpayers for all the free services the ILLEGALS are getting.
Good luck with that lawsuit!
Just like you can buy ice water in hell.
I don't think any of the rightwing nuts read the article. Illegal immigration has dropped dramatically. There are many reasons and none of them have to do with the silly law in Arizona. First is the present cost a coyote charges for crossing the border - $5,000.00 up front. Second: Lousy work situation in the construction industry in the U.S., Third: More agents on the border. Fourth: Drug cartels run the Mexican side and demand a bribe or that you work for them as mules Fifth. Better economic conditions in Mexico. All of you laugh about Americans headed south but just so that you know. Mexico has discovered an extremely large deposit of oil near Mazatlan. The first discovery on the Pacific Coast. It may turn out to be the largest discovery of oil ever. It could put Mexico on the level of Saudi Arabia. I wonder then if the Repubs in Congress will be so quick to go after those poor Mexicans.
There are tremendous oil deposits in Brazil too. Look how the poor live. And Brazil is an ally to the US where Mexico is not.
BULL %$#T they are coming over as always but the govt wants to minimize it for the election cycle.
BS. BS. BS !!!!
If these illegal aliens aren't coming to the United States to pick horseradish, can you imagine what the price of horseradish be? We need these horseradish pickers!
How about the web site for www.phonyscams.com,Kramer? And how about cutting off all those pimps and scammers, MSNBC?
Makes me want to order some taco's ....
With some El Scorcho hot sauce ....