E-mail updates
Follow on Twitter
Subscribe to RSSA Washington state school district official says he has no reason to believe a high school math teacher knew that injuries to his daughter’s eyes were the result of child abuse allegedly committed by his estranged wife.
As a teacher, Cody Mothershead would be required by Washington state law to report any suspicion of child abuse – even if it was of his own daughter. Mothershead teaches math at White River High School in Buckley, Wash.
Mothershead's estranged wife, Jennifer Lynn Mothershead of Buckley, Wash., is accused of inflicting severe eye damage in their then-14-month-old daughter by giving her eyedrops containing bleach rather than antibiotics, according to court documents. She also is accused of causing a head injury to the girl in May 2011 that required her to be airlifted to a hospital.
But it wasn't until after a medical journal reported on the case that the 29-year-old mother was arrested Friday. She pleaded not guilty to first-degree assault of a child on Monday and was being held in the Pierce County jail in lieu of $150,000 bail.
Many states have laws requiring not only teachers, but physicians, social workers and child care providers to report concerns of child abuse and neglect.
NBC News
A 29-year-old Washington state woman was charged Monday with first-degree child abuse after doctors said she nearly blinded her toddler daughter by replacing the child's antibiotic eyedrops with household bleach.
Mothershead told school officials he had been estranged from his wife since May and had been given limited access to his child during the separation.
“He made us aware of the issue,” said Tom Lockyer, superintendent of the White River School District in Buckley, Wash., a town of 4,500 in western Washington state. "When the girl was taken to the hospital, it was Cody’s first experience with what caused her to be placed in the hospital. Pierce County officials were informed, the case was discussed. Cody was cleared of involvement. The child is now in his custody, and he is working with investigators."
Cody Mothershead told investigators his estranged wife wouldn’t allow him to administer the eye drops and used the child’s medical condition to deny visits with their daughter, whom he saw for a few hours every week to 10 days. The mother had said the child had been prescribed antibiotics for an injury she sustained while playing in a barn.
Mom charged with putting bleach in her toddler's eyes
Court records revealed that Jennifer Mothershead said the child’s eyes had been swollen shut for four weeks and that the girl slept up to 22 hours a day because of the discomfort. Doctors treated her off and on for weeks at Seattle Children's Hospital.
Then, authorities say, the child was airlifted to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle in May 2011 with a head injury.
The mother appeared “unperturbed about the situation and said she had no idea what caused K.M.’s head injury,” the records show. Doctors confiscated the eyedrops and found bleach in the bottle.
The injuries have caused permanent vision loss in the toddler’s right eye, doctors say.
Her injuries were recounted last week in the Journal of the American Association for Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus. In the article, doctors at Seattle Children’s Hospital revealed they treated the child for nearly two months before the head injury occurred and may have missed signs of abuse.
The Washington State Medical Commission is reviewing the case to see if it warrants filing a complaint against the Seattle Children’s Hospital doctors who treated the girl, according to Donn Moyer, spokesman for the Washington State Department of Health.
Lockyer described Cody Mothershead as a dedicated teacher who has been with the White River High School for five years, instructing students in calculus, statistics and advanced placement math. “He is a highly recognized math teacher and probably one of our most engaging teachers."
Watch US News videos on msnbc.com
Education officials in Washington state would not comment on the Mothershead investigation, but said two Washington state laws apply to this case. According to an email from Nathan Olson, spokesman at the Washington Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction in Olympia, Wash., the following laws apply:
The first, Revised Code of Washington 26.44.030 requires a number of groups of people, including “professional school personnel,” to report suspected cases of abuse or neglect “to the proper law enforcement agency.” This must be done, according to state law, within 48 hours.
This law also applies to licensed or certified child care providers and their employees, so if the child were in a day care situation, her care providers would have been required to report suspected abuse/neglect.
Another state law, RCW 28A.400.317, requires all certificated and classified school employees (basically, all school employees) to notify “abuse or misconduct to the appropriate school administrator.” That administrator, then, must investigate and can make a report to law enforcement if he or she reasonably believes that “misconduct or abuse has occurred.”
Msnbc.com health writer and editor JoNel Aleccia contributed to this report.
More content from msnbc.com and NBC News:
Leave a Comment:
"14-month-old daughter giving her eye drops containing bleach rather than antibiotics" This is a very sick, demented individual. My stomach just turned reading this. $150,000 dollar bail doesn't even come close!! They need to tack on a few more 0's.
Bail isn't determined entirely by the seriousness of the crime, aside from it being an indication of what danger to the community the person might pose and to what extent they might be a potential flight risk. In this case, it's highly doubtful that she's going to walk the streets squirting bleach in people's eyes.
Pre-trial incarceration has but two purposes: The ensure that the suspect appears in court and to protect the public from potential harm. It is NOT intended to be used to punish people for crimes of which they are presumed to be innocent. It's also worth noting that she has not, at least yet, bailed-out of jail. So the amount of bail seems to be sufficient to keep her there, at least at the moment.
Now, if she's convicted, the sentence should be as harsh as legally allowable.
The one lingering question: WHY?!
According to doctors, the amount of damage done would have required repeated and prolonged exposure to bleach over an extended period of time. In other words, this wasn't a sudden loss of temper or psychotic episode. This was a deliberate, premedicated, and brutal act. What could motivate a mom to do something so strange and horrific?
Seriously, I'm having a really hard time figuring out what even a possible motive could be.
Yes I am stuck on that as well.
Traumatic events such as divorce shakes even the most stable personalities. If a person is unstable to begin with the seperation can make them implode (self destructive) or explode (destructive toward others). That woman could make the baby suffer and indirectly make the husband suffer. She was in control.
All I can think of is the story of Sybil. Her mother did horrible things to her. The eye injury, the head injury. Who knows what all she was doing to the baby.
There is no excuse for Jennifer Mothershead. Fourteen months is awfully young for a child to be and have your father and mother divorce. And who was the father of the child she just had? Maybe there were some post partum issues thrown into the mix. No, the father didn't know exactly what his ex was doing and okay, he was not obligated to report anything. BUT! When did the marriage become so untenable that he had to get out yet felt comfortable leaving a helpless baby behind? How do people reconcile their spouse having a screw loose but their children will be safe with them?
How was he suppose to know if the hospital didn't? Really this woman is sick. That poor little girl!
So sad.I hope she'll recover. So mom is crazy-20-30 lashes with a whip would cause some reflection on her part
That woman is absolutely sick. Her punishment should be dropping bleach in her eyes until she is blind. Just sick!
There are so many moms in jail that wish they could be with their babies, so I have no doubt she'll get what she deserves! Unfortunately it won't undo the damage that she has caused to her daughter and the emotional damage the girl will have once she learns it was her mother's disdain for her that caused her injuries and permanent blindness. This world is sick and it's getting sicker!!!
Done that to her own baby, did she? In the old Hill Folks wisdom -- "Just some people just need killing."
i am cry...this monstrum women deserve same tretman..cccc
Mom needs to rot in prison, it kinda sounds like munchousens by proxy (Im no psychologist so dont quote me on that) and probably used her childs sickness to get attention and empathy, not to mention the control it gave her over the dads visitation. Just sickening
I wonder if she did anything to the new baby! I hope not. This is one sick momma!!!
I guess Washington law is different than California law for mandated reporting. We are required to report suspected child abuse as it pertains to our professional duties. We are not required to report it when it is unrelated to our jobs. Having said that, I can't imagine someone who wouldn't report it regardless of the circumstances.
Cody Mothershead told investigators his estranged wife wouldn’t allow him to administer the eye drops and used the child’s medical condition to deny visits with their daughter, whom he saw for a few hours every week to 10 days. The mother had said the child had been prescribed antibiotics for an injury she sustained while playing in a barn.
Funny how the douche bag of a mother had the ability to dent the baby's father visitation. Why is it no matter how unfit the female is she will always get custody until she does something terrible.
This woman is obviously a useless Can't Understand Normal Thinking and was allowed to keep abusing her child by a system that always favors the mother. If a male had shown up with a child in that condition the police would have been there in a second.