View more videos at: http://nbcbayarea.com.
Twenty-eight years after a strangled Santa Clara County woman's body was found tossed into a supermarket Dumpster, a Fresno man was charged Monday in a case that broke because of the DNA under the woman's fingernails.
Mountain View police spokesman Sean Thompson said that investigators used a match on the state's DNA database to identify Daniel Garcia, now 53, as the alleged killer of Saba Girmai.
After an investigation, Garcia was arrested on Friday, and is now in custody without bail.
"We never forget about unsolved murder cases and continuously seek out new technology and new leads to help us solve them," Mountain View Police Department Chief Scott S.G. Vermeer said in a statement. "Hopefully this will help bring some closure to Ms. Girmai's family."
Read more stories from NBCBayArea.com
Deputy District Attorney Ted Kajani added: "No matter how long ago someone was murdered, we don't forget about them."
The charge stems from Jan. 18, 1985, when a passerby found the body in the Dumpster near Bailey Park Plaza and Safeway shopping center in Mountain View, and reported it to police.
Eventually the body was identified as 21-year old Girmai, who was known to frequent the San Jose area. During the next three decades, the investigation was frequently revisited but no significant leads were developed, police said.
On Jan. 12, 2010, the Santa Clara County District Attorney's Crime Laboratory developed a DNA profile from the victim's fingernails.
Prosecutors say the resulting profile matched a convicted offender: Garcia, who had never previously been linked to Girmai.
In 2011, MVPD and the newly created D.A.'s Cold Case Unit began to re-investigate the case. That led to Garcia's arrest last week.


They finally nailed him.
Yeah, I'm amazed that they even thought to get DNA from under her nails when DNA was just about even heard of.
It's pretty cool that they had the foresight to preserve such things in anticipation that DNA would one day be almost perfect. Good job guys. Now the family can feel a slight bit of comfort. RIP.
On another note, I wonder if he killed anyone else between then and now. If so, I hope he opens up and gets this off his conscience.
I'm only sorry it took 28 years. As the silver lining of a rather dark cloud, I like to imagine his horrified surprise, when the long arm of the law reached out for him, 28 years after his crime.
He probably thought that he was safe.
Just think maybe ten years down the road science may solve any crime, I'm not sure what to expect from that but a least it would stop the Jackal type killing people that think they can cover it up.
@Creek Dog, Don't assume it was ever on his conscience. A lot of times we assume that it has to eat at them because it is not something we could ever fathom doing. Glad what he did in the dark has now came to light. But they said they sent the info away in Jan '10. You mean it still took 3 years after DNA fingered him.
Really? No one is bringing up the fact that she was an illegal immigrant???
Only you.
And this matters how?
lol good one...
thanks for a good laugh.
With technology booming the way it is today, making today's inventions obsolete in a year, I wish they could figure out a way to attach probes to someones temples within a 1/2 hr of being killed or just died that could play back on a laptop exactly what they seen.
I know, Duh! Impossible. You're crazy. Heh heh. Why not?! We can send a probe to Mars with a battery of tools that can be manipulated from Earth. Just a crazy idea.
Look at it his way, how many ideas have been termed "insane", "crazy", "that'll never work", that actually did work. We have college students working on all kinds of crazy things nowadays that seem impossible but that's why they're trying them.
Can't keep doing the same experiments time and time again when the world continues to technically move forward.
It's just like the lottery, can't "win" if you don't "play".
OK now, I opened the door for scrutiny but what the hell, I'm crazy enough to stick my neck out on the line since I speak my mind anyway...
40 or 50 years ago you could get away with murder...
Anything even a little bit younger than that, ends up in a cold case unit. And if there's evidence? You might've gotten away with murder for a little bit, but modern technology will allow the cops to eventually catch up to your sorry butt...
Glad there's one more murderer off the streets... I hope the woman's family is finally getting the justice they thought was far gone.
Thinking you can get away with murder nowadays is a foregone conclusion for many--note to criminals: even without a body, you can get nailed.
If his DNA was in the data bank then he has been arrested in the past, so odds are good that he continued his life of crime and perversion. I'm glad he's off the streets.
I'm sorry, but why did this take 28 years to solve? DNA evidence has been used for decades now and it's SOP to remove ANY evidence from under the victim's fingernails.. It sounds to me like someone dropped the ball big time on this.. The only way I can think of that it would have taken so damn long is if the suspect's DNA was just recently put into the national database, but, considering he's already a convicted felon, I find this highly unlikely..
It's sad her family had to wait so long for justice but I'm glad they got it at last...
One less murdering animal roaming the streets, but it raises some interesting questions. This scumbag has been out there for 28 years, and probably not living a saintly life. He has been convicted of other crimes, so how many times has he gotten away with it, and what are the chances that some innocent people are in prison for his dirty work? Most likely, pretty good.
danimyl because it's a illegal immigrant and we are really hurting for money. Why should we waste money that we desperately need to solve the murder of a criminal?
Wow. Your thinking is really warped. Why should we "waste money" looking for your killer one day? You don't matter any more than she did. Not all values are based on monetary worth.
Hi, CD.
Hang tight, it will come... the Israelis will probably invent it.
To the rest of you... it was a cold case, and with all the current cases waiting for DNA to be run on them, cold cases are not a priority. He's already in prison for another crime, and his DNA was likely run to prove his involvement in the current crime; sometimes the people working on cold cases will add evidence they have to see if they can get a match, playing a wild card. Sometimes, as in this case, it pays off.
Newswinner -
Everyone knows how I feel about illegals. However, illegal or not (and we don't know if she was) she was murdered. And on the balance scales of both life and justice, a killer outweighs an illegal alien when it comes to which one I'd personally rather see behind bars, so yes, I would want our resources used to get the SOB off the streets. How about you?
At long last, rest in peace, young lady.
Newswinner101, you are a very disturbed and sad individual. Please stop making a complete a-hole of yourself now. Thank you!
I'm always glad when a Monster is caught.
"The wheels of justice grind slowly but they grind exceedingly fine."
I'm sick of my tax dollars being wasted on illegal immigrants. And you know what? I don't think we should be wasting money finding gangbangers who kill other gangbangers. Hell, stick them all on an island, arm them, and then let them kill each other off. We SHOULD kill all illegal immigrants. I'm tired of em, the guy who did it is a hero.
"new" technology?? I've seen some cool stuff that is already being used...Hi-tech stuff....On CSI.....
How did they still have her DNA? wasn't she buried or maybe they exhumed her? that part I don't get, but I guess the bottom line is that they got the guy.
@JFC
They took the evidence from under her fingernails back at the time they were initially investigating the crime, and wisely, they kept it.
My question is whether the fact that the victim had the accused's DNA under her fingernails is enough to convict him of anything beyond a reasonable doubt. The article points out that the victim had no previously-known connection to the accused, so what does the fact that she had his DNA under her fingernails tell us beyond a reasonable doubt?
That she scraped a piece of his gum off of her shoe? That she reached out to him to save her while someone else strangled her to death? That a strand of his hair had fallen onto her coat and she had pulled it off?
I think it's a close call that this one fact alone was enough to get an arrest warrant. I think they have to develop something more to get a conviction.
If he is found Guilty then he needs to be taken out back and SHOT..... Capital Punishment means nothing unless carried out, and done in a Timely Manner.....
Interesting question.
I'd say that if the DNA was found on some chewing gum then it would only prove that she had somewhat poor hygiene. But if it was derived from some human tissue, then it proves that she was in very close contact with him within minutes, and more likely, seconds of her death. So if she reached out to him to save her, I'd ask why did he not save her, or at least report the crime.
At the minimum, that would make him an accessory after the fact in the murder.
I'd have to see how the evidence is presented at trial, but off hand, if I were on the jury, I think this might be enough for me to vote guilty.
RonB, your comments read like a defense attorney clutching for anything to exonerate a client. The rest of us have enough common sense to figure out that a stranger's DNA under the finger nails of a murder victim is a proverbial smoking gun.
Newsloser, You are a despicable troll. Your stupid attempt to rile up anger by lauding a murderer merely exposes your lack of common sense. On the scale of threats to society, illegal aliens fall well below murdering career criminals. Too bad your extreme view is only held by a few...
One unsolved murder down, thousands to go, still good news.
Better late than never, good work guys.
Time to pay for your crime creep. Too bad you got to live so much of your life free.. Your victim didnt get that chance. Hopefully spending your old age in a cell will be horrible. And cold.
I love science and I have no sympathy for criminals, but wonder: what if the victim got into a fight with Garcia on the street or at a club and scratched him because he said or did something inappropriately, with him leaving, and with her later being killed by a different person? How do the police determine that his DNA under her fingernails proves that he murdered her? People don't just scratch people when they are being murdered.
I dont think its totally uncommon for people to get scratched when they are being strangled. They will do anything to try to break free. Its logical she scratch his arm or hand trying to loosen them. Do you think a she is just going to stand there?
Good point, Nikolaus20. This is a good job by law enforcement, but I suppose now they need to get a confession, or more evidence to really show they have their man. I suppose generally speaking, our minds takes the short cut, and links this DNA result with "convicted offender", and logically(?) concludes/assume "guilty". But indeed, although it points in this "convicted offender" direction, I suppose more evidence is needed.
MvanLWD
@katie, I think you missed Nikos point. He is saying that scratching during a murder is not the only reason people scratch. He gave examples that maybe they just got into a fight and she hit him. Then later on she left and was murdered. The question was how do the police know that the DNA is from the murderer and not just someone with whom she had a fight. That is probably what a defense attorney would use to bring up doubt I would think.
Katie is correct. What are the odds that someone would have someone skin, other than the murderers, under their fingernails on the day they were strangled? I would suggest you think back on your own life and figure out how many times you had someones skin under your own nails. My guess is it would be a very insignificant number. A little common sense says the guy is guilty.
This is a bit similar to the OJ case, where OJ had a bleeding cut on the same hand as the killer, who left a small trail of blood on one side. OJ said he cut it on a glass.
Ralph, ideally, we are convicted of crimes because proof of guilt exists beyond a shadow of a doubt. We are not convicted of crimes (hopefully) because "a little common sense" helped a jury to tie up loose ends. If you had an itch on your back and your wife or girlfriend scratched it for you, that person would then have your skin cells and DNA under her fingernails. If she was found murdered an hour later, your DNA - under her fingernails - could possibly have you convicted of a murder that you didn't commit. You like what common sense does for you in this instance?
Yes Nick- Ideally for a conviction you would have evidence beyond a shadow of a doubt, but it is not a perfect world. I think you are spending too much time scratching your a$$ for an argument, instead of using a little common sense. While your "what if" scenario could happen, as I said before, the odds are infinitesimal.
Think about it for a few seconds. Have you had anyone scratch your back in the past year? I haven't. Then to have yourself killed on the one day when someone happened to scratch your back, not by a gun, but by strangulation, where a person's first reaction would be to scratch and claw at the attacker, is quite a stretch.
It is not unusual to hear some people complain about the money spent trying to solve old murders, their reasoning being there are so many innocent people in prisons that deserve this use of such limited time, attention, and resources. Besides, cases that are decades old, most relatives are probably dead, so who really cares about some old forgotten cases anyway?
However,this case, like others that end up getting solved with DNA, were once new cases, and each victim had others who cared, loved them, deserved to be solved, killers who could still be out there,and so much work done already by so many to solve their murders. It is often simply, that science wasn't what it is now. People never dreamed of us being able to do what we can, with so little human tissue. Every human life stolen, deserves the right to be solved, their killer punished.Time really doesn't change those rights, especially if it was your loved one.
Unless one has lost a loved one to murder, it can be difficult to understand the pain, the sleepless nights, waiting for answers, which may never come. The questions of why, and profound sense of how much one, incredible young, life with all the promise of years ahead, was lost. I can actually personally understand this, sadly. So I can also appreciate how much relief the solving of this senseless killing must be for the victim's family.Especially after almost three decades.
This family will finally have closure,because of a dedicated law enforcement department that didn't give up on a murdered victim. No matter how long ago. Kudos to all those who care and worked so hard to make this happen for people they didn't know, but for a victim they came to care about. Even if people never will know why this horrible monster chose to murder,such a lovely young woman seeking peace, from a world of violence.
May this creep experience finally, the full measure of justice he denied his victim for so long.Locked in a tiny cell, rotting away until death.When I believe true justice will finally begin
Good morning Windy; great post. It is good there is no statute of limitation on murder. Glad one more horrible person is off the street.
Morning raleigh dolly, thanks, and yes, I am so grateful there is no limit. This brought tears to my eyes, just thinking about this woman's family finally getting some closure after 28 years. When you have lost a loved one, the emptiness just never goes away. To be able to start to have closure now, must be so amazing for them. I am sure they wondered if it would ever come!
While this monster thought he got away with his crime, though I suspect he looked over his shoulder, and in the back of his mind, it lay eating at any sense of peace. Who knows, he may have even killed others and more may come yet.But for this family at least,they can stop wondering and perhaps looking at strangers on streets, asking themselves, the,"Is it him?" questions so many do in such cases.
There are millions upon millions here in America who are guilty of murder and has gotten away with it.. But that will soon be changed and those that haven't repented for shedding innocent blood will meet the Supreme Judge of all that there is... Those that are found guilty will be forever separated from God and there will be gnashing of their teeth and never ending thirst for all eternity.
Yes Watchman. As criminal technology advances we become better able to identify the guilty, and in some instances release the innocent who had previously been convicted.
To this womans family and friends. I am sorry it took so long for justice for Saba's murder, but her day has finally come.
My sister was murdered more than 30 years ago. I would still like to know that her killer was in custody and would live out his life as a guest of the prison system.
My sister was murdered 11 years ago and the killer was caught and charged with murder but he plea bargained down to involuntary manslaughter. He was sentenced to 8 years of which he served 4. My sister was 16 at the time of her death. Sometimes the justice system fails us even when the perpetrator is caught and those of us left behind can do nothing.
Very clever ... I see what you did there nbc.
what did nbc do general lee..??....there are people who were just recently let go because of dna findings...can you imagine being in prison all your life for something you didnt do...man I would be so ticked off..they would have to pay me what I would have earned during that time...actually they couldnt pay me enuf ....but it is good to find those who have commited murder and thought they got away with it...because really do we know they havent murdered someone else...she would have been 51yrs old...its the family left behind who suffers...
Case broke b/c of DNA under the woman's fingernails. Play on words.
Glad they caught this guy.. He might be tied to other unsolved murders across country and any missing children as well. I wonder where he was residing for so long and did they speak with any of the neighbors he was living next to? Perhaps after speaking to those people, finding out what he did as far as work, and where he went for fun (bars etc.) can reveal even more clues. After a few drinks he may have told them some other things he may have been up to.
He hasn't been convicted. Save your praise til after the trial.
You are so right because I am sure some lawyer will get him off some how like so many before and that is so sad to think that could happen.
While I agree Carol that many get off on some technicality or another, DNA doesn't lie. There are few reasons WHY your DNA would be captured under another persons fingernails.
I am grateful for the detectives still working on these cold cases.
That said, the writing on this website continually amazes me, are there no editors? Why are we capitalizing the word dumpsters? I know, I know, it's trivial to bring it up, but it's distracting and I would expect better of the writers on a major website. Also, why do I TWICE have to opt out of putting my comment on Facebook. Sorry, NBC News, I am going elsewhere.
Because the word was originally part of a brand name. Two brothers devised a truck that could pick up trash and transport a container. The brothers were named Dempster, and the container was the Dempster Dumpster. For the same reason, the word "tape" should be capitalized in "Scotch Tape", as should Band-Aid, Kleenex, and ChapStick.
Why are we capitalizing the word 'twice'?
Very interesting Denver Bill 2. Did you also know that the zipper was not originally called a zipper? Nor did the Zipper Co. invent said zipper (separable fastener). They started to produce it and it just became common to call it a zipper and they lost their trademark due to becoming "too generic". Kleenex fights tooth and nail to ensure that other companies use "facial tissue" so that they too do not become too generic and loose their trademark.
I did not know that. Thank you.
Yes, but in this case they didn't say a "Dempster Dumpster" as in Scotch Tape, this time they just said a dumpster, which should be lower case, as in "I put some tape on it". I wouldn't type "I put some Tape on it". I know this is off the subject, but SanityPlease is correct in this instance. I just had to add my two cents.
These comments have gone sooo off-point, I've forgotten what I was going to "say."
Oh yeah, something about giving up on spelling and grammer errors ..................
I have noticed in every article I read that "Dumpster" is capitalized. It is a formal name or title and is correctly written with a capital letter.... Whenever the name of a company is used, it is correct to capitalize the first letter: (Ford, Chevrolet, GE, Microsoft...)
Justice has been done... I'm sure this brings closure to her family.
I love science!!!
I'm glad you love science. Unfortunately, most Republicans hate science because it contradicts their world view.
Really? You know most Republicans? I don't know any that hate science. BTW, not a political article, take your crap somewhere else.
A big pat on the back to those officers and prosecuters who finally brought justice for that girl. I'm doubt any of them were on the job when the murder occured. The one arrested is still innocent until a trial, but It will be pretty hard to explain why his DNA was under her nails. One more reason to stop biting your nails.
As a forensic scientist I can tell you that these type of cold cases are great to solve and troubling at the same time for the simple fact that they sit in a warehouse or storeroom not being tested because of budget cuts to departments across the country. The technology has been available for years, the money on the otherhand is tough to come by. The lab I work at does work for free for police agencies for missing person cases and we get our funding from grants. We have helped solve over 75 missing person cold cases last year, and more than 150 additional cases.
Cool and thanks!
Great work Chris! Thanks.
Good work Police. Thanks for all that you do.
This is great. Now if they would only start processing the rape kits...
Now she and her family can finally be at rest but now this man has to go to prison for the rest of his life and never ever see the light to day.
I'm glad that they got the guy who did this but my question is why in the world did it take so long to utilize this technology? Forensics DNA Testing has been around for a while now. The writer didn't explain...
Backlog?
rotteneggs...they do. I was raped in 1988. My case was the first cold case in the state of Maryland that was solved due to the DNA datatbank (2001). The man that attacked me had also attacked another woman a couple of weeks after me and got caught in that attack. He would have been released from jail in his first conviction in 2002 but since he was convicted in my case he is still in jail. His first parole hearing is this summer and I will be there to make sure he isn't let out. Now if we could just fix the judicial system so these monsters never get out. In 2004 a 3 judge panel reduced it to 53 years because 2 judges determined he had the right to get out and rape again some day. Then they gave him 15 years credit for the time served in the other attack reducing it to 38 years. To add insult to injury they considered his sentance in my case began in so the 38 years started in 2002 and not 2004 so he got an extra 2 years off his sentance. Nothing like rewarding repeat offenders with reduced sentences.
If they let him out, a 7.62 to the ear should complete his sentence. Double tap to be sure.
I think I know the case you're referring to. Don't worry, that's all I'll say.
Xmas Dog, I am so sorry, your right the rich Lawyers make or break deals; mostly the make deals for the bad guys that would rape again. Too bad the lowest life form rapest get out and rape again, my suggestion is to prepare yourself. Put your keys between your fingers when you walk out some where, and carry a small bottle of hair spray not mace. Mace gets on him and you and it burns and stings, it makes it harder for you to fight. My rapist was my father from the time I was born til I was about eight, my sister who were older protected us as we barracaded ourself in our rooms even on hot summer nights. We told the school, the neighbor, our Police friend nothing was ever done-we never told our mother until much later. My mother was also raped by my father, he was a rich alcoholic pond scumb lowest form sicko. He died in his sleep in our home Country, where none of our family went to visit him.
im glad they got the person as well.i was serving west coast them days and yes it seemed very crazy at times.now,it seems alot like back then here where i live,thats what both bothers me and scares me alittle too.
Coming soon...Thought Crime...like the movie Minority Report!
I guess it's becoming more true over time and enhanced technology that you can run, but you can't hide.
Justice delayed, but not denied. I wonder if this man will be tied to more unsolved murders? I'm happy for the family of the victim, at least they can have some closure. Not knowing why, or who did something like this is much worse than at least being able to point at someone or something. Little solace, but at least something.
Well, well, well. It's just like the saying goes: There's no perfect murder. I am sure he had "forgotten" that he murdered her after 28 years. The blood of the innocent always cry from the grave.
Well Done to the DEtectives that perseviered in the case, and the Forensics that allowed the arrest.
Why would you think anyone is stupid enough to pay any attention to your 'cut and paste' advertising?
the brothers will be waiting for your to make your stay enjoyable white man