
L.A. County Sheriff's Dept. via AP
From top left, Luis Artiga, Victor Bello, George Cole; from bottom left, Teresa Jacobo, George Mirabal, and Oscar Hernandez.
A jury reached mixed verdicts in the trial of the so-called "Bell 6," finding former City Council members guilty of several counts of misappropriation of public funds in a scandal that left a small city southeast of downtown Los Angeles nearly bankrupt.
Watch video, read more on NBCLosAngeles.com
In a case that grabbed headlines nationwide, five former Bell City Council members accused of padding their paychecks were found guilty on half of the counts they each faced, while the jury was unable to come to unanimous agreement on other counts.
Former Councilman Luis Artiga was found not guilty on all 12 counts he faced. As the clerk read the verdicts, Artiga rocked back and forth in his chair, crying. A court official handed him a box of tissues.
The reading of the verdicts began shortly after 11:30 a.m. Wednesday at the criminal courts building in downtown LA on the 18th day of jury deliberations. When the proceeding was complete, about an hour later, the judge had instructed the jury to continue its deliberations on the counts for which it reached no conclusion.
"I know you probably thought this was going to be the end," LA Superior Court Judge Kathleen Kennedy said. "But I'm sorry to say we're going to have to proceed a little bit further."
She had asked attendees in the courtroom to not react audibly as the verdicts were being read.
The city's former mayor, vice mayor and four former City Council members were charged in a 20-count felony complaint with misuse of public funds. They looted city coffers, inflating their salaries and paying themselves for sitting on commissions that rarely met, the prosecutor argued.
City Manager Robert Rizzo, the alleged mastermind of a scheme that former Los Angeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley said cost Bell nearly $6 million, is being prosecuted separately, as is his then-assistant.
During the trial, prosecutors said Bell had been upended by a "culture of corruption."
Related: Criminal complaint against "Bell 6"
The jury had the following conclusions Wednesday:
- Ex-mayor Oscar Hernandez: guilty on five counts; not guilty on five counts. No verdict on 10 counts.
- Former Councilwoman Teresa Jacobo: guilty on five counts; not guilty on five counts. No verdict on 10 counts.
- Former Councilman George Mirabal: guilty on five counts; not guilty on five counts. No verdict on 10 counts.
- Former Councilman Victor Bello: guilty on four counts; not guilty on four counts. No verdict on eight counts.
- Former Councilman George Cole: guilty of two counts; not guilty on two counts. No verdict on four counts.
The guilty verdicts were associated with work done for the city's solid waste and recycling authority. The five defendants were acquitted on charges associated with Bell's public housing authority.
The Bell Association to Stop the Abuse released a statement as the verdicts were being read that stated in part: "This verdict is long awaited and further vindicates the community’s efforts to move out of the shadow of Rizzo corrupt regime. The jury’s verdict is a clear step in helping the Bell community to heal."
The organization -- which calls itself BASTA, meaning "enough" in Spanish -- asked the judge to issue stern sentences for the defendants.
Related: Bell activists "relieved" after multiple guilty verdicts
During 18 days of deliberations after a juror was replaced, the seven-woman, five-man jury had repeatedly asked for the reading back of testimony and had sent multiple questions to the judge.
The jury's decision comes after the 2010 revelation of comparatively exorbitant salaries paid to Bell city officials brought national attention to the working-class city.
The six former elected city officials are accused of paying themselves nearly $100,000 salaries that should have been about $8,000 per year.
Their actions, along with the $1.5 million compensation package for Rizzo, nearly bankrupted the high-poverty city with a population of about 40,000. Several Bell residents attended much of the trial, which began Jan. 24. Jury deliberations started Feb. 22.
Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Edward Miller had told the jury that the Bell 6 had "dreamed up" the salary scheme "solely for the purpose of stealing money from the people of Bell."
Defense attorneys had pointed the finger at Rizzo, who faces trial alongside his assistant Angela Spaccia. Lawyers for the Bell 6 had said Rizzo had duped their clients.
'Buried their heads in the sand'
Miller denied that.
"We know they buried their heads in the sand, but kept their hands out," Miller said during closing arguments.
The prosecutor had argued that -- to get around a City Council salary cap -- the city increased the amount paid to the defendants for sitting on four municipal boards that held few meetings and did little work. Miller called the boards "shams" that sometimes met only to approve members' own pay raises.
One authority, ostensibly focused on solid waste and recycling, was never even officially established or hired any staff apart from council members, Miller said evidence showed.
But defense attorneys said the six former council members worked many hours for their pay. They claimed the officials relied on Bell's city attorney and an independent auditor to establish salary figures.
Hernandez, 65, Jacobo, 55, and Mirabal, 63, were each charged with 20 counts of misappropriating public funds for over a 4 1/2-year period ending in 2010.
Bello, 54, was charged with 16 counts of misappropriation between 2006 and 2009, while Artiga, 52, was charged with 12 counts of misappropriation between 2008 and 2010.
Cole, 63, was charged with eight counts of misappropriation over a two-year period ending in 2007.
The trial had a hiccup on Feb. 28 when a juror was dismissed for misconduct several days after the case was handed to the jury. Juror No. 3 had said she felt abused by other jurors and did online research about jury coercion.
LA Superior Court Judge Kathleen Kennedy's dismissal of the tearful juror came after a jury note had said the group was at an impasse. An alternate juror was put on the panel and Kennedy ordered the jury to begin deliberations anew.
Jurors on March 15 had asked to re-hear testimony about Jacobo's conversation with Rizzo in which she said he told her that she would be able to work full-time and would get paid a full-time salary.
"I asked him if that was possible," Jacobo told the jury last month, noting that Rizzo responded affirmatively and that City Attorney Ed Lee nodded his head.
"My feeling was if the city attorney said it was OK to do so, it must be legal," she testified.
The jury also asked for a readback of testimony about Hernandez's ability to read and write in English. The judge warned jurors, in reference to opening statements about Hernandez's education level, that "what the attorneys say is not evidence."


The headline says they reached a verdict, but the do not say what it is in the article. Hopefully they will update this and provide the information that people are looking at the article to find out. Hopefully they convicted all of these slimeballs and they get sentenced to long prison terms.
They will all go away for a long time. Wait until the Sentencing Phase.
Rizzo and his assistant are being tried separately, and they probable will be convicted and given the harshest of sentences.
Good riddance to all of them.
They do give the verdicts, but the penalty phase is still to be heard. Throw the book at them......doubt if they can even read, though.
LOL, all I have to do is take a look at those mug shots and my verdict would be GUILTY! Some people just look like criminals. I hope they get nice long sentences.
I think the author needs to help with reading and writing. Man, the grammar mistakes...
LOL except for Mirabal he kinda looks like a Chihuahua.
It shows that political corruption is rampant at the lowest political levels ... county & state ... We need to throw these scumbags out ... and make the penalty stiffer for those that deceive and steal from the public coffers harsher locking them away for a long time!
This kind of white collar crime is rampant and needs to be dealt with harshly!Just because these scumbags aren't using a gun to steal they are still destroying many lives
Looking at the photos of all these slim balls, what did the folks in this community think to elect this scum!!!???
Kind of makes me wonder what type of people live in this @!$%#-hole.
More corrupt Liberal Democrats. What else is new???
How do you know that? I didn't see it in the artic...Ah, now I see. NBC at it again protecting their own.
Where do I send the vaseline?
Send them to prison and confiscate their personal belongings then sell at auction and give the money back to Bell's coffers.
I certainly hope other "cities" take head of the court's action. (Are you listening Detroit ?)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please publish the "sentences" and the political affiliation of the condemned.
Arthur66: Ever heard of the Iraq or Afghanistan war and a company called "Halliburton". There's some of your political corruption but ya set your sites on the small city of Bell. Moron.
Both sides of the establishment are responsible for enough waste, corruption, and outright theft to make your head spin. Until people start to hold their own party as accountable as the opposition, it will be more of the same BS.
This sound an awful like what's happening in Washington DC.
Why can't the tax payer stop and prosecute those thieves too?
Inflated salaries, there are none more inflated than those of the Senate, House and Executive branch.
Amen to that! The DC Gang is just as bad.
WORSE.
Light blub just went off:
Unbelievable what these dips***s did, and to think they felt they could get away with it. Who oversaw this group of slime? Is everyone in Bell brain dead to let this happen? 12 to 15 years should do it. They will plead that they were innocent - no, they were caught.
And they would have if it wasn't for those meddling kids...
Sign entering California "Welcome to California, home of corrupt government from top to Bottom. Bankrupted cities R our business".
Sign leaving California "Thanks for visiting California and leaving your home and bank account with us"
This is all wrong. After all, the defense lawyers said they worked hard for the money. And we all know that a scum lawyer would never try to twist the facts.
And where is the former police chief, Randy Adams, who was collecting a 3/4 million dollar a year salary all the while double dipping with his city of Glendale pension? Isn't BASTA interested in knowing why he wasn't prosecuted or have they been told to shut up on that subject? Funny how the only law enforcement official involved gets the only pass from the DA.
What? This isn’t how municipal government works? You know bankrupt the masses for F’N outrageous benefits – No! That’s how it’s always worked – there has got to be a mistake? Set those people free, they were just getting their piece of the pie, after all what’s yours is mine isn’t it?
It is unbelievable to many people how this could go this long without anybody noticing it.
People who are not familiar with Bell probably do not know that 95%+ of residents are hispanic, 1st or 2nd generation.. These people are probably the class did not count in Mexico or similar countries to begin with.
When these 6-8 dumbf*cks came to power, they proclaimed "latin power".. So the people thought, they got hispanics running the city and they should be well taken care of!!!
Well, they were taken for a ride... In a way, they deserved it..
Sicktired -
I grew up in South Gate, where we eventually had own corruption with Mayor Alberto presiding. From Compton, to Lynwood, Cudahy, Bell and Bell Gardens, a similar pattern: Latinos, many naturalized, became the majority; an unscrupulous few took advantage, as you say above playing on ethnicity, and the people were largely clueless and trusting until things became outrageous. For many immigrants, they were used to corruption in Mexico, under the former PRI system, so it seemed normal.
Compton and Lynwood were a bit different given their black majorities for a long time; but some of the early black leaders played the same game, and got away with it for a while, several eventually ending up in prison. I daresay similar things have played out in our larger cities, from New Orleans, to WDC, to Detroit and Chicago. Hopefully voters will learn from all this...but I kinda suspect many don't pay attention to the news...or even read much. Those of us who did pay attention escaped long ago.
Helllloooooo Detroit!
Sounds like normal Mexican-style government moved north.
Roger that; exactly....
... dang! look at that Marabal guy! LOL
No kidding. It's pretty apparent what he did with his loot. Licking sugar off the mirror.
Most of them are of Hispanic origin. Nice to see Mexico's corruption has moved here. Thanks liberals.
Man, what an intelligent looking bunch of thug liberals! Add up all their IQs and you're still in single digits.
These guys were the chumps; Rizzo was the kingpin who invented the whole scam and kept the city council compliant, with a phoney structure of compensation. Rizzo made millions, and my guess is he's looking at a long vacation in the joint. Probably the smartest guy in the room was the former police chief, who seems to have escaped indictment through clever use of employment contracts and state labor laws...I believe he's currently collecting a couple hundred thou a year in retirement, in perpetuity (adjusted for inflation, etc), though he was denied the half-million or so he thought he should get. Rizzo's trial might conceivably re-open Chief Randy's case.
Looks like Ole Barry gonna really loose out on some potential cabinet appointments!
Not necessarily..he could always pardon these crooks...
Hope they can recover some of the money. Bell is a poor community.
they should pay back the huge sum of money they paid to themselves and took from the city and its people.
Cellisis,
Could not agree more. However, do you really believe that any of them have any of the large sums of money they got? That kind of mentality is "spend, spend, spend, for tomorrow we can come up with another scam.
You get this type of corruption because no one in the electorate is paying attention.
You get the government you deserve.
Being in government is like winning the lottery. The higher you are the bigger the jackpot unless you get a little to greedy and don't share with others in government.