• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: 'Like a Hollywood movie': Driver survives I-5 bridge collapse into Wash. river
  • Recommended: 'Winter' - maybe even snow - to return for Memorial Day weekend
  • Recommended: Cars, drivers plunge into river after Wash. I-5 bridge collapse
  • Recommended: Deputy survives horrific shooting caught on camera after police stop

NBC News reporters bring you compelling stories from across the nation. For more US news, follow us on Twitter and Facebook.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 2
    days
    ago

    Too much terrorism data? Connecting the dots may be getting harder

    AP / The Lowell Sun & Robin Young

    Boston Marathon bombing suspects, from left, Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev.

    By Mark Clayton, Christian Science Monitor

    Tamerlan Tsarnaev landed on America's terrorist watch list in 2011. Tamerlan's younger brother, Dzhokhar, now charged in the Boston Marathon bombing case, seems not to have made the list.

    Ultimately, Tamerlan's inclusion on the watch list did not lead investigators to detect the April 15 bomb plot that killed three and wounded at least 260 – prompting inevitable questions about why not, and whether "dots" of intelligence and information that could have been connected were not.

    America's terrorist watch list is all about connecting dots – and it is certain to be a focal point for future congressional hearings pegged to the Boston case. A key part of the vast counter-terrorism net cast by the federal government after the 9/11 attacks, the watch list is actually at least nine lists drawn from a single government database. Criteria for determining who gets "nominated" for inclusion in that database – and, then, who actually makes it onto an agency's specific list – are tightly guarded secrets.

    CSMonitor quiz: How much do you know about terrorism?

    What does seem clear, however, is that the spigot opened wide in the past three years, leading to torrential growth in the core terrorism database. Whether those extra mounds of data give investigators a more accurate view of the universe of terrorists, or whether they have the unintended effect of making prospective terrorists harder to find and the dots harder to connect, is a matter of hot debate – and one that the Boston bombing case may well intensify.


    "There's absolutely no question that they're just choking on the volume of information, both classified and unclassified, that's going into the system," says Dakota Rudesill, a visiting professor at Georgetown University Law Center who served, during President Obama's first term, as special assistant in the policy, plans, and requirements directorate of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, which includes the National Counterterrorism Center. "You're taking on this immense challenge with all this data – like finding a particular needle in a haystack of needles."

    US officials bridle at inferences that the system is overwhelmed.

    "Certainly, the volume has grown, and the list has grown for a number of reasons," says a US counterterrorism official who spoke on background because he is not permitted to speak on the record. "The intelligence is better; the value of sharing information is seen as better by the agencies involved. The watch list is created specifically to be one of the big dot-connectors in the counterterrorism effort – it's among the most sophisticated systems the government has – and it's proven itself to be effective."

    Want your top political issues explained? Get CSMonitor's customized DC Decoder updates

    The making of the watch lists

    Like a giant digital vacuum, the Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment (TIDE), a highly classified database maintained by the National Counterterrorism Center in McLean, Va., each day sweeps up thousands of names, aliases, birth dates, and other potential terrorist tidbits – known as "derogatory information" – and tries to match them with hundreds of thousands of names, faces, and identifying biometric data also sent in by the Central Intelligence Agency, the State Department, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and other US agencies.

    "TIDE is the granddaddy repository – not a watch list itself, but it feeds the lists," says Mark Randol, a specialist on domestic intelligence and counterterrorism formerly with the Congressional Research Service (CRS). "The whole deal with a watch list is that you need a place where the objective is to see if you can identify, and stop, people you think are terrorists from just coming into the US and disappearing into the woodwork to plot attacks."

    As of December, TIDE contained the names of 875,000 individuals (not including aliases), the counterterrorism center reports. Each day, TIDE sends a river of new names to the Terrorism Screening Center, run by the FBI. The screening center combines TIDE's names with those on the FBI's own domestic terrorism list to create the Terrorism Screening Database (TSDB) – America's master terrorist watch list.

    Both TIDE and the TSDB have been expanding fast. TIDE grew from 740,000 names in 2011 to 875,000 in 2012 – an 18 percent jump. The TSDB, for its part, jumped 23 percent from 423,000 individuals in May 2010 to 520,000 in October 2012, according to the CRS and the Terrorism Screening Center.

    What happens to the identifying information about a known or suspected terrorist after it is put onto the master terrorism list? The FBI's screening center sends that information to four US agencies with primary responsibility for straining out would-be terrorists, which then add it to their own unclassified watch lists.

    State Department. Its Consular Lookout and Support System (CLASS) screens passport and visa applicants.

    Department of Homeland Security (DHS). It uses the Traveler Enforcement Compliance System (TECS), which flows into the Interagency Border Inspection System and the Automated Targeting System – lists used by the US Customs and Border Protection for border and port security.

    FBI. Its National Crime Information Center list is disseminated as a tool for police departments across the United States. The bureau also has its own Guardian database (different from the TSDB), and Tamerlan Tsarnaev was reportedly on it.

    Transportation Security Administration. The TSA, part of the DHS, keeps three air-passenger screening lists – "no fly," "selectee," and "secure flight." The no-fly list is one of the most exclusive watch lists, winnowed to those tagged as possible terrorists who are to be blocked from getting on a US-bound flight. The selectee list signals that an air traveler requires extra screening but being on that list does not necessarily prevent that person from boarding. Both lists have about 20,000 names, the Terrorism Screening Center reports. The secure flight list allows expedited boarding for passengers whose prescreened personal information is compared with watch list data.

    Actions that lead to a person being nominated to TIDE as a "known or suspected" terrorist include engaging in terrorist activity, preparing or planning an attack, gathering information on targets, raising funds for attacks, and soliciting membership in a terrorist organization. Less-obvious criteria remain cloaked in secrecy, including nominations that come from foreign intelligence agencies. In 2009, the FBI's own inspector general noted some dissatisfaction with the process, saying the bureau "failed to nominate known or suspected terrorists in 15 percent of the cases we reviewed."

    Getting off the list has been problematic, too. The inspector general criticized the FBI for being "untimely in its removal of the subjects" from the watch list in 72 percent of cases reviewed. Travelers who are often delayed at airports are not usually on a watch list; rather, their names and personal information are similar to that of someone who is. In 2012, at least 14,000 records were deleted from TIDE or terrorist watch lists after it was determined that the people no longer met the criteria for inclusion, the counterterrorism center says. US residents make up about 1 percent of TSDB listings.

    But civil liberties experts are not satisfied.

    "We still don't have access to the information we need to allow us to evaluate how well it's working or how many [who should not be on the list] have been able to get off," says Sharon Bradford Franklin, senior counsel at The Constitution Project, a Washington-based civil liberties group.

    How Tsarnaev made the watch list

    In March 2011, the FBI interviewed Tsarnaev after Russian intelligence services warned that he had become radicalized. By June, the FBI concluded a basic "assessment" without adding derogatory data to his file, The Washington Post reported. His name, however, did remain in the FBI's Guardian database – an internal watch list.

    In September, the Russians again sent up a flare about Tsarnaev's radicalization, this time to the CIA. By year's end, his name had been added to TIDE and the TSDB watch list, the Post reported.

    Three days before Tsarnaev left for southern Russia, his name popped up in the TECS system. It is not clear why the rising number of red flags – including his travel to a part of Russia where Islamic radicals are active and his online postings of jihadist videos – did not set off alarm bells. Some analysts say they believe that some important details simply didn't make it into the database.

    "If they get the Russian tip, and they were also aware of [the] fact he was visiting Russia and jihadist websites, then I'm not altogether convinced the FBI would have said they found nothing on him," Mr. Randol says. "The fact they didn't see a problem means to me they were not aware of these details."

    The near miss that changed watch-listing

    AFP - Getty Images file

    Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab set off a bomb in his underwear aboard a Detroit-bound airliner on Christmas Day 2009. A month before his father had warned U.S. authorities. Abdulmutallab's name was added to TIDE -- but didn't make it onto the watch list.

    Connecting dots so that clues are not left floating in a sea of data was a top goal after the near-miss Christmas Day bombing attempt in 2009. Nigerian national Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab famously tried to blow up a Detroit-bound airplane using plastic explosives hidden in his underwear.

    On Nov. 18, 2009, Mr. Abdulmutallab's own father reported his son's radicalization to US Embassy officials in Nigeria. A week later, the son's name was added to TIDE, but not to the watch list – in part because the source of the derogatory information was not included, weakening it. Five weeks later, Abdulmutallab tried to blow up the plane.

    Afterward, President Obama ordered a review to determine why Abdulmutallab's name had not appeared on the master watch list. Later in 2010, the nominating criteria changed, with the result that more names and data flowed into TIDE and the TSDB. One measure of the increase: The number of US citizens and lawful permanent residents on the no-fly list more than doubled, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) found in a 2012 study of watch list changes.

    Even before the changes, concern was evident within the intelligence community about the huge amount of data being funneled into TIDE. Back in March 2010, Russell Travers, then deputy director of information sharing and knowledge development at the National Counterterrorism Center, told a Senate panel that the inflow of 10,000 names a day to TIDE had required some adjustments. Among them was the advent of special "pursuit teams" of analysts to explore threads, threats, and loose ends that would help "connect the dots," he said, acknowledging that the step was "an experiment."

    The 2012 GAO report likewise noted concern among "nominating agencies" about their abilities to process so much information – especially after the changes that followed the underwear bombing attempt. It noted that "agencies are ... pursuing staffing, technology, and other solutions to address challenges in processing the volumes of information."

    A notable watch list success

    U.s. Marshals Service / AP file

    Faisal Shahzad, shown in a U.S. Marshal's Service mugshot, got on an airplane for Pakistan after the attempt to set off a car bomb in New York's Times Square. A watch list flagged him, and authorities arrested him on the jet.

    Despite the fire hose of incoming information, the US saw some success in apprehending terrorism suspects. After someone tried to set off a car bomb in New York's Times Square on May 1, 2010, investigators traced the crime to Pakistani-American Faisal Shahzad – and added his name to the no-fly list at 12:30 p.m. on May 3. Later that evening, Mr. Shahzad was indeed attempting to make his getaway to Pakistan. Minutes before his flight was to depart, authorities spotted his name during a final check.

    "What used to happen in days now happens in minutes or seconds," the US counterterrorism official says of recent watch list updating and technology upgrades. "The Times Square bomber actually got on the plane thinking he was getting away. But we have a real-time transactional interface with the Customs and Border Patrol. They screened the passenger manifest, arrested him, and took him off the plane."

    Today, says the US counterterrorism official, the backlog of information has been eliminated and analytical resources are adequate. The number of names on the TSDB fluctuates, but during the past year appears to have "leveled off" at about a half million, he says.

    Unconnected 'dots' in Tsarnaev case?

    Questions remain, however, about the government's handling of Tsarnaev during the year leading up to the Boston bombings. Some wonder why he was not a candidate for extra scrutiny by a pursuit team or by the FBI. Others ask why federal authorities did not inform local police of the warnings about Tsarnaev's possible radicalization, so they could possibly keep an eye out.

    Were there dots that, if connected, would have led to closer FBI scrutiny and prevention of the Boston Marathon bombings? If so, did data overload play a role?

    "No, actually more data makes it more effective," insists the counterterrorism official. "The more derogatory information in there, the better able the system is to screen, and the better the whole system works."

    But data overload is likely to be raised in future hearings on Capitol Hill, some say.

    "I hope the Boston case will lead to a new revision of the watch list, to see whether we are adding just too much information on people so that it leads to a needle-in-the-haystack problem," Randol says.

    "Right now, it isn't clear that there are plans in place to review the effectiveness of the watch list or whether the level of misidentification is growing because the haystacks are getting too big."

    This report, "Terrorist watch lists: Are they working as they should?," first appeared on CSMonitor.com.

    Related stories from CSMonitor.com:

    • Quiz: How much do you know about terrorism?
    • Boston Marathon bombing: Did US really miss chance to prevent it? (+video)
    • Was Boston Marathon bombing a US 'intelligence failure'? (+video)

    More from Open Channel:

    • Terrorist watch lists: Are they working as they should?
    • Ex Cincy IRS official doubts agency's explanation for Tea Party scandal
    • DOJ's secret subpoena of AP phone records broader than initially revealed

    Follow Open Channel from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook

    27 comments

    The Department of Homeland Security and the Transportation Security Administration are a gross over reaction to threats against the American public. Security lists, mass pat downs, travel restrictions and public paranoia have been whipped to a heady froth that have exceeded the very real threats tha …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, watch-list, tsarnaev, terrorism-database
  • 10
    May
    2013
    12:47am, EDT

    Unaware of Tsarnaev warnings, Boston counterterror unit tracked protesters

    In the first congressional hearing on the Boston bombings many questions remain unanswered, such as why the FBI didn't involve Boston's law enforcement when assessing whether or not Tamlerlan Tsarnaev was a terrorist threat. The FBI investigated Tsarnaev two years ago after receiving a tip from Russian authorities. NBC's Pete Williams reports

    By Michael Isikoff, National Investigative Correspondent, NBC News

    In the fall of 2011, a key Boston police counterterror intelligence unit -- funded with millions of dollars in U.S. homeland security grants -- was closely monitoring anti-Wall Street demonstrations, including tracking the Facebook pages and websites of the protesters and writing reports on the potential impact on "commercial and financial sector assets" in downtown areas, according to internal police documents.


    Follow @openchannelblog

    The police monitoring of the activities of Occupy Boston -- an off-shoot of the Occupy Wall Street protests that swept the country in 2011 -- came during a period after the U.S. government received the second of two warnings from the Russian government about the radical Islamic ties of alleged Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev.

    Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis told a congressional panel Thursday that his department was never alerted by any federal agency to the information about Tsarnaev, but added that it was "hard to say" whether it would have made any difference in preventing the bombing. FBI  officials have insisted that the intelligence about Tsarnaev was vague and uncorroborated and that their own assessment at the time produced no "derogatory" information that justified opening a full-scale investigation.

    But the internal Boston police documents, recently obtained by a civil liberties group, could raise fresh questions about the role of Homeland Security-funded "fusion centers" like the Boston Regional Intelligence Center, or BRIC, which conducted the monitoring. The Boston unit  is one of 72 such units set up to collect, analyze and share intelligence about potential terror threats. While  Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano has called the units “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts, congressional critics have questioned their effectiveness and accused them in some cases of writing "useless" reports that infringed on civil liberties.


    “They  were monitoring completely lawful activities,” said Mara Verheyden-Hilliard, executive director of the Partnership for Civil Justice, a civil liberties group that recently obtained the documents on the BRIC’s monitoring of Occupy Boston under the Freedom of Information Act. She said the BRIC monitoring was an example of the “vast expenditure of government money” to collect intelligence on activities unrelated to terrorism, in violation of First Amendment rights.

    A Boston police spokeswoman said the department has changed its reporting procedures since the monitoring of the protests and emphasized that the BRIC is “about a lot more than terrorism.”

    A Homeland Security official declined comment, saying the BRIC, like other fusion centers, was “locally owned and operated.” But the official noted that, just five days before the marathon bombing, the BRIC did produce an assessment for the event that, while concluding there was “no specific” or “credible” threat information, advised that “officials should be aware of a range of potential terrorist threats, from scattered unsophisticated attacks to dispersal of chemical or biological agents.” The assessment also identified the marathon finish line — where the bombing took place — as well as Fenway Park as “an area of increased vulnerability.”

    The internal police documents about the activities of the BRIC show that on Sept. 30, 2011 — just two days after the second Russian warning about Tsarnaev was sent to the CIA — the Boston police unit was focused on an upcoming “Take Back Boston Rally” planned for the city’s Dewey Square.

    “Approximately 100 people are listed as attending the Take Back Boston Rally on the event’s Facebook page and Occupy Boston organziers are encouraging people to attend it as well,” reads one BRIC report written by a U.S. homeland security official on Sept. 30, 2011. “The BRIC has received information that approximately 700 people will participate in the Take Back Boston march, with approximately 100 people staying to camp out as part of Occupy Boston.”

    A follow-up report, three days days later, tracked the number of protesters, noting that “the size of the camp in Dewey Square has steadily grown over the weekend” and that “according to the group’s website” the demonstrators were planning two marches, including one to a “local media station, very likely to be Fox News Boston on Beacon Hill.”

    Verheyden-Hilliard, whose group obtained the documents, said it was not surprising that the BRIC would be reporting such information since later documents appear to show Homeland Security officials requesting such data. In one “Daily Intelligence Briefing,” dated Oct. 21, 2011, the “Threat Management Division” of Homeland Security’s Federal Protective Service outlines a “template for creating the daily intelligence brief for your region” and then cites a “list of events we want to request” that officials submit “for daily briefing information.” Among the categories, in addition to reporting on domestic terrorist acts and “significant criminal activity” is one called “Peaceful Activist Demonstrations.”

    NBC News

    Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis testifies Thursday before a House committee on the marathon bombings.

    In his testimony Thursday, Commissioner Davis acknowledged to a House committee that his department, which runs the BRIC, was never provided any of the intelligence from the FBI and CIA that Tsarnaev, a resident of Cambridge, had been twice flagged by the Russians as an Islamic radical with ties to “underground” groups in that country.

    “We were not aware of the two brothers,” Davis said in response to questioning by Rep. Mike McCaul of Texas, chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee. “We were not aware of Tamerlan’s activities.”

    Davis acknowledged that police counterterrorism detectives were assigned to an FBI Joint Terrorism Task Force (JTTF) -- a separate unit from the Homeland Security fusion centers that serves as the government's primary investigative arm for probing terror threats. An FBI agent at the Boston JTTF conducted an “assessment” of Tsarnaev in 2011 after the first warning about his ties was sent by Russia’s FSB intelligence service. The assessment found no “derogatory” information about Tsarnaev that justified conducting a formal investigation. Later information about Tsarnaev included a second Russian warning to the CIA on Sept. 28, 2011.

    But while Boston police had access to the JTTF’s classified database, Davis said that his own officers assigned to the task force were never  specifically alerted to any the information about Tsarnaev. “They tell me they received no word about that individual prior to the bombing.”

    FBI spokesman Jason Pack said Thursday that state and local members of the JTTF are “responsible for maintaining awareness of possible threats” in their areas and could have performed “customized key word searches” of the FBI database that would have yielded the information about Tsarnaev.

    NBC News researcher Taylor Sears contributed to this report.

    More from Open Channel:

    • Long before he was charged, Ariel Castro was accuser in sexual assault case
    • Recent immigrant from Canada linked to alleged train terror plot, feds say
    • US traffic deaths rise for first time since 2005 -- motorcycle rate a big contributor

    Follow Open Channel from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook 

    166 comments

    Great...we can't interdict the violent criminals even with tips from foreign governments but protesters get the evil eye... land of the free my arse...

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, boston, featured, bric, counterterrorism, boston-marathon-tragedy
  • 9
    May
    2013
    5:45pm, EDT

    Recent immigrant from Canada linked to alleged train terror plot, feds say

    By Richard Esposito, Jonathan Dienst and Pete Williams, NBC News

    NEW YORK -- Federal prosecutors on Thursday revealed charges that accuse a Tunisian man who had lived in Canada with applying for a visa "to remain in the United States to facilitate an act of terrorism." 


    Follow @openchannelblog

    The charges name Ahmed Abassi, a native of Tunisia who had been living in Canada.  Prosecutors say he came to New York in mid-March. 

    Federal investigators say he met with the men involved in a plot -- first revealed in mid-April -- to attack an Amtrak passenger train from New York to Toronto.  They say the plotters discussed blowing up a bridge at Niagara Falls to cause the train to plunge into the gorge below. 

    Canadian authorities announced in mid-April that the plot had been stopped. They disclosed then that they had arrested two men -- Chaieb Esseghaier of Montreal, a 30-year-old Tunisian graduate student who is reported to have guerrilla warfare training and is described as the ringleader, and Raed Jaser of Toronto, 35, a school bus driver.


     

    Frank Gunn / AP

    Chiheb Esseghaier, one of two suspects arrested last week in Canada in connection with the alleged terror plot to derail a passenger train near the U.S.-Canada border, arrives at Buttonville Airport outside Toronto on April 23.

    Federal prosecutors from the Southern District of New York said Thursday that Abassi was arrested 17 days ago. The fact that word of his arrest was withheld indicates he was likely providing some information about the plot to investigators. 

    He is charged with fraudulently applying for a work visa "in order to remain in the United States to facilitate an act of international terrorism," according to a statement from the Justice Department. 

    Authorities in Canada said in April that an al Qaeda facilitator in Iran had worked with Esseghaier, and also that the train they intended to target was an Amtrak train originating in New York's Penn Station. 

    "Esseghaier was simply a bad guy, and dangerous. This guy was purely evil," said one investigator, and had scientific training and the technical ability to make chemical bombs. 

    Law enforcement officials say Esseghaier met Abassi during a trip to New York. But they say the meeting did not go well.  Abassi, they say, thought he should be the person in charge. As a result of the failure to get along, Abassi did not have a role in the derailment plot. Authorities did not spell out any further the basis for the visa fraud charge beyond saying it was to facilitate an “act of terror.” 

    The FBI has covertly monitored the activities of the two Canadian men, their contact with overseas Al Qaeda facilitators and others, and their possible connection to others who could be linked to the plot. 

    "What Mr. Abassi didn't know was that one of his associates, privy to the details of the plan, was an undercover FBI agent," said George Venizelos, the FBI Assistant Director in Charge of the New York office. 

    The yearlong covert investigation involved electronic and physical surveillance. Authorities emphasize, however, that this was no sting operation.  It was, they say, a significant terror plot, once which failed to get more notice because of the Boston Marathon bombings. 

    CTV News via Reuters

    Raed Jaser is seen arriving at court in the back of a police car in Toronto on April 23.

    Esseghaier and Jaser made their initial court appearances in Canada in April. They are charged with conspiracy to commit murder, conspiracy to interfere with transportation and participating in terrorist group activities. Esseghaier told the court that the Criminal Code of Canada “is not a holy book” and did not apply to him.

    Richard Esposito is senior executive producer of the NBC News investigative unit; Jonathan Dienst is WNBC chief investigative reporter and NBC News contributing correspondent in New York City; Pete Williams is NBC News justice correspondent.

    More from Open Channel:

    • 'Ransomware' tricks victims into paying hefty fines
    • Government doc shows alleged marathon bombers closely followed al Qaeda plans
    • Ties that blind? Family connections can be key in journey down terrorism path

    Follow Open Channel from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook 

    Investigate this!

    Read and vote on readers' story tips and suggested topics for investigation or submit your own. Click here to read more about this tool.


    120 comments

    College education wasted to become a terrorist? Wow, what a shame.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: canada, iran, terrorism, crime, trains, transportation
  • 5
    May
    2013
    4:52pm, EDT

    Tsarnaev uncle arrives in Mass., but family can't find a place to bury bombing suspect

    Tamerlan Tsarnaev's uncle is in Massachusetts to arrange his burial, but four cemeteries have refused to bury him and protesters have set up camp outside the funeral parlor where his body is being held. NBC's Katy Tur reports.

    By Jeff Black, Staff Writer, NBC News

    The family of the Boston Marathon bombing suspect killed in a shootout with police can’t find a place to bury him, even as his body is being prepared for just that purpose.



    Follow @NBCNewsUS

    An uncle of suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev arrived in Worcester, Mass., on Sunday to “prepare the body” of his nephew for burial.

    Ruslan Tsarni, of Mongomery Village, Md., came to the city about 40 miles west of Boston with three other men, who were not family members,  and met with the director of the Graham Putnam & Mahoney Funeral Parlors.

    The men who joined Tsarni were planning "religious washings" in accordance with Muslim burial rites on 26-year-old Tamerlan Tsarnaev’s body, the funeral director Peter Stefan said.

    Stefan said he and the family have been unable to find a cemetery in Massachusetts willing to take the body. Still, though he’s had "no offers" of a cemetery, he expects the suspect will be buried in the state.

    "We have to bury this guy,” Stefan told reporters in an impromptu news conference Sunday. "Whatever it is, whoever he is, in this country, we bury people. I don't care who it is. That's what I do.”

    A small number of demonstrators had protested at the funeral home over the weekend, holding signs and chanting "USA!" One sign read: "Do not bury him on U.S. soil."

    According to The Associated Press, several people drove by the funeral home Sunday and yelled, including one man who shouted, "Throw him off a boat like Osama bin Laden!"

    Apparently in response to those protests, Stefan remarked, "I can't separate sins from sinners. I can't pick and choose. This is what we do."

    For his part, the uncle said that Cambridge, Mass., was Tsarnaev’s home, not the southern Russian republics of his roots.

    “He lived in America, he grew up here,” Tsarni said. “Any contemplations that his body should be taken to his home country, they cannot believe. His home country was indeed Cambridge, Massachusetts.”

    Stefan said he is planning to ask the city of Cambridge to provide a burial plot, and if Cambridge turns him down, he will seek help from state officials.

    Shortly after Tamerlan and his 19-year-old brother Dzhokhar were identified as suspects in the bombings that killed three and injured more than 200, Tsarni said the brothers may have been motivated by shame and hatred.

    “Being losers, hatred to those who were able to settle themselves,” Tsarni said at the time.

    Dzhokhar, 19, remains in a prison hospital while he awaits legal proceedings on federal terrorism charges. He could face the death penalty.

    NBC News' Alexandra Moe and The Associated Press contributed to this report.

    Related:

    • DNA on Boston bomb does not match suspect's wife, investigators say
    • Boston suspects had plotted July 4 attack, investigators say
    • What motivated bombing suspects? 'Being losers,' uncle says

    1580 comments

    Please, bring him to my place, I have a really, really nice place for him. Good reason enough to get back in the hog business at least for a while.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, featured, manhunt, uncle, boston-marathon-tragedy, ruslan-tsarni, tamerlan-tsarnae
  • 4
    May
    2013
    9:37pm, EDT

    World Trade Center 9/11 museum to charge $20-$25 admission fee

    Mark Lennihan / AP file

    Visitors look over the waterfalls at the National September 11 Memorial and Museum on Feb. 25 in New York.

     

    By Karen Matthews, The Associated Press

    NEW YORK -- Faced with hefty operating costs, the foundation building the 9/11 museum at the World Trade Center has decided to charge an admission fee of $20 to $25 when the site opens next year.

    The exact cost of the mandatory fee has not yet been decided.

    Entry to the memorial plaza with its twin reflecting pools will still be free.

    The decision to charge for the underground museum housing relics of the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks has been greeted with dismay by some relatives of 9/11 victims.


    "People are coming to pay their respects and for different reasons," said Janice Testa of Valley Stream, whose firefighter brother Henry Miller Jr. died at the twin towers. "It shouldn't be a place where you go and see works of art. It should more be like a memorial place like a church that there's no entry fee."

    Testa was visiting the memorial Saturday with relatives from Florida.

    The memorial plaza opened in 2011 on the 10th anniversary of the terror attacks, but disputes over funding have pushed the museum's opening back to spring 2014.

    With the cost of operating the memorial and museum projected to be $60 million a year, the memorial foundation voted at its board meeting last week to charge a mandatory admission fee for the museum.

    "This is something that is going to be important and is going to be worth the expenditure," Joseph Daniels, president of the National September 11 Memorial and Museum, said Saturday.

    Daniels said the museum will be free during certain hours every week and will offer student and senior discounts.

    Foundation officials had considered an optional donation but rejected the idea.

    "We decided that it's more fiscally prudent to have a straight ticket charge," Daniels said.

    Debra Burlingame, a foundation board member whose brother was the pilot of one of the hijacked planes, said the trade center site is expensive to build on and to protect.

    "The World Trade Center site remains a target of interest among terrorists, so the security has to be robust and relentless," Burlingame said in a phone interview. "There's a big price tag on that.

    "Would we like to be able to say this is free? Absolutely," Burlingame added. But she called it "irresponsible to hope that year after year we have donations that will cover an expense like security."

    Some visitors to the memorial were divided about charging admission to the museum.

    Retired school psychologist Valerie Cericola of Lavalette, N.J., said the entry fee sounded fair.

    "You need to keep it open, you need to keep it running," she said. "It's an expense."

    But Jennifer Reyes, a friend of Cericola's daughter who was born on Sept. 11, 2001, said the museum should ask for an optional donation.

    "I think a donation like $10 would be good," Jennifer said.

    AP radio correspondent Julie Walker contributed to this report. 

    Related: Images of the World Trade Center site from PhotoBlog

    © 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

    203 comments

    This is hallowed ground and a fee should NOT be charged to see the museum of 9-11 artifacts. Most museums charge a minimum fee or are free to enter. This is a restrictive charge, a family of four would have to pay 100.00 to 120.00 just to enter the door, ridiculous!

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, sept-11, terrorist, museum, world-trade-center, 9-11
  • 30
    Apr
    2013
    5:44am, EDT

    Adding up the financial costs of the Boston bombings

    Jessica Rinaldi / Reuters

    Flowers lay on the sidewalk at the site of the first explosion at the Boston Marathon finish line after Boylston Street reopened on April 24.

    By Bill Dedman and John Schoen, NBC News

    In a matter of moments, the Boston Marathon bombings inflicted as much as $333 million in damage to the local economy in lost wages, retail sales and infrastructure damage, according to preliminary estimates. But the effects of the April 15 attack, which killed three people and injured 264 others, continue to send shock-waves far beyond Boylston Street.

    Based on published reports and interviews with local business leaders and authorities, here are some figures that hint at the ultimate financial impacts of the bombings, and illustrate the enormous gap between the losses inflicted on the city and victims and the pocket change spent by the alleged killers:

    Cost of artificial legs for the 14 people who lost limbs: $20,000 per amputation; $7,200 for a below-the-knee artificial foot up to $90,000 for microprocessor-controlled full leg; tens of thousands for rehab

    Total cost of care for 70 hospitalized victims: Could exceed $9 million, according to one rough calculation

    Money collected by One Fund Boston established by the city and state to aid marathon victims: $23 million

    Cost to Sugar Heaven, 669 Boylston St.: $65,000*

    Cost to Abe & Louie’s, 793 Boylston: $500,000**

    Cost to Sir Speedy’s Printing, 827 Boylston: $150,000

    Cost to Whiskeys’ Smokehouse, 885 Boylston: $250,000

    Elise Amendola / AP

    A city transportation worker fixes a street sign in Boston's Copley Square on April 25.

    Total losses from 10 hardest-hit businesses: $2.3 million

    Total business losses within the Boston Police Department’s designated “Impact Zone”: $10 million

    Size of Small Business Administration loans available to businesses: Up to $2 million

    Value of tickets for canceled Celtics-Pacers NBA game: $1.3 million

    Value of tickets for canceled Boston Symphony concert: $175,000***

    Value of tickets for three canceled Blue Man Group performances: $105,000***

    Lost receipts for New England Aquarium: $130,000

    Lost parking ticket revenue: $8 million

    Lost fares, one day of Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority: $1.56 million****

    Net cost of canceled Amtrak service: $180,000

    Cost of hijacked SUV: At least $47,270 

    Money stolen from SUV driver: $845

    List price for Ruger 9mm similar to the handgun allegedly carried by the suspects: $374 to $599

    Retail cost of boat where suspect Dzohkhar Tsarnaev hid from police: $50,000

    Amount raised to replace David Henneberry’s boat: $50,522.50

    Cost of manufacturing six bombs from pressure cookers, elbow pipes, nails, firecrackers and glue: Less than $100 per bomb

    Cost of holding a federal prisoner for one year: $25,000

    Cost of holding a federal prisoner in a “supermax” prison for one year: $75,000

    *First blast was outside 671 Boylston St.

    **Second blast was outside 755 Boylston St.

    ***Estimate based on average ticket prices

    ****MBTA was shut down on April 19, during the manhunt for Dzhokhar Tsarnaev

    Mark Schone and Berenice Garcia of NBC News also contributed to this report.

    Related:

    • Could prosecutors cut deal to rule out death penalty? Talks have started

    299 comments

    They forgot the biggest cost. Lawyer fees: $456,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000.00

    Show more
    Explore related topics: bombs, attack, terrorism, featured, boston-marathon-tragedy, tsarnaev
  • 29
    Apr
    2013
    7:17pm, EDT

    Could Boston bombing suspect avoid death penalty? Talks have started

     

    Investigators have taken a DNA sample from the wife of slain suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev to compare with the female DNA discovered on the pressure cooker from one of the Boston bombs. The FBI is also examining whether Tamerlan Tsarnaev met with two men in Dagestan who are considered radical Muslims. NBC's Pete Williams reports.

    By Pete Williams and Tracy Connor, NBC News

    Prosecutors and lawyers for surviving Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev have begun very early discussions about a possible deal, in which he would cooperate in exchange for avoiding the death penalty, legal sources said Monday.

    As details of the nascent negotiations emerged, a lawyer who has helped other high-profile suspects cut deals that kept them out of the execution chamber got permission to join Tsarnaev's defense team.

     

    Attorney Judy Clarke's past clients have included Unabomber Ted Kaczynski and, more recently, Jared Loughner, who was spared facing the death penalty for the Tucson, Ariz., shooting that nearly killed former U.S. Rep. Gabby Giffords in 2011.

     

    Tsarnaev, 19, is charged with using a weapon of mass destruction for the April 15 bombing that killed three and wounded 176 in Boston and could face the death penalty.

    The suspect's older brother and accused accomplice, Tamerlan Tsarnaev, 26, was killed in a firefight with police, and investigators are trying to determine if anyone else was involved.

    Law enforcement officials said they took a DNA sample Monday from Tamerlan's wife, Katherine Russell Tsarnaev, to compare to female DNA found on a piece of pressure cooker used to make one of the bombs.

    The wife has said she had no inkling of her husband's plans, and officials cautioned that the DNA on the cooker could have come from a worker at the store where it was purchased.

    AP Photo/The Lowell Sun & Robin Young

    Boston bombing suspects Tamerlan (left) and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev.

    The FBI is also looking into whether the older brother met with two men considered radical Muslims during a 2012 trip to the Russian republic of Dagestan. Both men — William Plotnikov and Makmud Nidal — were killed last year in Russian operations.

    The spotlight has also been trained on the Tsarnaevs' mother, Zubeidat, who was caught on a Russian wiretap talking to Tamerlan about jihad, U.S. officials said.

    That conversation led the Russians to ask the FBI to look into Tamerlan in 2011. He and his mother were put into a U.S. terrorism database, but no further action was taken.

    While some members of Congress have faulted the Russians for not giving the U.S. more explicit details about the mother, officials in Washington said she spoke so generally about jihad that it's not likely the information would have influenced the outcome of the 2011 probe.


    Follow @NBCNewsUS

    Before he was given a Miranda warning and stopped talking, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev told investigators that he and his brother were motivated by religion but acted alone, without help from any overseas terrorist organization.

    But law enforcement officials believe someone may have carried items out of his dorm room at the University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth a few days after the bombings and they searched local landfills for them. So far nothing has turned up, but investigators are still looking in garbage containers.

    Three federal public defenders were appointed to represent Tsarnaev, and they asked that two death penalty specialists be added to the team. The court approved Clarke but said the request for a second lawyer, David Bruck of the Washington and Lee University School of Law, was premature since Tsarnaev has not been indicted yet.

    Wounded by police during his capture,Tsarnaev was transferred last week from a private Boston hospital to a federal medical prison in central Massachusetts.

    Related:

    • Russians to US: Bombing suspect, mom discussed jihad
    • Congressman: Bombing suspects may have had foreign help

    1121 comments

    The guy must die. Assuming his guilt is shown in court, we cannot allow him to sit and watch TV for the rest of his life. Prosecutors these days... they'll do anything for a quickie.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, death-penalty, featured, boston-marathon-tragedy, dzhokhar-tsarnaev, katherine-russell
  • Updated
    28
    Apr
    2013
    10:21am, EDT

    Boston bombing suspects' mother was in U.S. terror database

    Dmitry Kostyukov / The News York Times via Redux

    Anzor Tsarnaev, left, and Zubeidat Tsarnaev, the parents of the two suspects in the Boston bombing, during a news conference in Makhachkala, Russia, April 25, 2013.

    By Michael Isikoff and Matthew DeLuca, NBC News

    The mother of Boston Marathon bombing suspects Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was placed in a U.S. terror database in the fall of 2011, a counterterrorism official confirmed to NBC News.

    Zubeidat Tsarnaeva was placed on the database by the Central Intelligence Agency at the same time as her older son Tamerlan, who was shot and killed by police in the manhunt following the bombings. That Tsarnaeva was placed on the database does not mean the CIA had any specific information that she might be a threat, the official said.

    A review of government records found that Tamerlan Tsarnaev was entered into three classified counterterrorism databases, according to public statements by government officials and NBC News sources. He was entered into a Guardian file maintained by the FBI, as well as Homeland Security’s TECS database and a master TIDE list maintained by the National Counterterrorism Center.

    The entries for Tamerlan Tsarnaev used some different spellings and dates of birth, a U.S. official brief on the probe said.

    An email alert was sent to a Homeland Security officer in the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force office in Boston when Tamerlan Tsarnaev traveled to Russia in January 2012, sources have told NBC News, but that spurred no further investigation.

    The suspected bombers’ mother has said in interviews that the FBI was watching her son.

    “They were monitoring him and I know that because I used to talk to them,” Tsarnaeva told NBC News’ U.K. partner ITN News. “They used to come to our house, like two, three times. And then my son Tamerlan used to tell me that he used to talk to them, too, because they called me once and they wanted his number.”

    Tsarnaeva said that she began to practice a “pure” form of Islam while living in the United States about four years ago. She moved to the southern Russian republic of Dagestan about a year ago with the suspects’ father.

    On Saturday, a senior law enforcement official told NBC News that investigators are downplaying any connection between a man known as “Misha” and the bombing investigation. Relatives of the suspects earlier this week suggested the man may have helped lead Tamerlan Tsarnaev to radicalism.

    Related:

    • 'Did you hear about the Boston explosion? I did that'
    • Father of alleged Boston Marathon bombers: 'I want facts ... anything could be set up'
    • Missed email, multiple spellings: How Tsarnaev's travel got lost in the system

    This story was originally published on Sat Apr 27, 2013 12:53 PM EDT

    1271 comments

    A review of government records found that Tamerlan Tsarnaev was entered into three classified counterterrorism databases, according to public statements by government officials and NBC News sources. He was entered into a Guardian file maintained by the FBI, as well as Homeland Security’s TECS …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: fbi, cia, terrorism, homeland-security, database, counterterrorism, updated, tsarnaev, tsarnaeva, zubeidat
  • 26
    Apr
    2013
    4:26am, EDT

    Painting for peace: Boston children turn to art to heal

    Scott Oxhorn

    Children and their parents gathered in Dorchester, Mass., last weekend to paint a 100-foot-long banner in memory of Martin Richard, the 8-year-old boy killed in last week's bombings at the Boston Marathon.

    By Matthew DeLuca, Staff Writer, NBC News

    BOSTON -- With song, brushes and buckets of paint, children in Boston are using the arts to try to express feelings about last week's marathon bombings for which even their parents do not have words.


    Follow @NBCNewsUS

    "Painting for Peace” was inspired by 8-year-old Martin Richard, the youngest person killed in the attack near the finish line of the Boston Marathon. Parents and their children turned out last weekend in Dorchester, Mass., the Richard family's home, to paint a 100-foot-long roll of wallpaper with swirls of color and the message held up on an art project by the gap-toothed boy in a picture that went around the world last week: "No more hurting people. Peace."

    "It was just the most obvious message that was on everybody's minds," said Liz Carney, who organized the project with her group Dot Art. "We were seeing that image and that message everywhere. A message about peace had a really important place in our response, in our community."

    The sign now greets drivers passing under the Savin Hill Bridge over Interstate 93 heading into Boston. About 25 to 50 volunteers of all ages showed up to help create the banner, cards and other paintings and drawings over the weekend, Carney said.

    "It was really a very heartfelt expression of peace and solidarity by our neighborhood," Carney said. "I had a lot of parents say how grateful they were to bring their kids to be a part of it, that the children in our community sometimes need a place to express things that are beyond words, and using their hands and having a place to tangibly put their energy is really important."

    Boston-area children have turned to art projects like this one in Dorchester to help heal the wounds left by last week's marathon bombings.

    Martin Richard’s sister Jane, 7, is among the 425 children from across the city who take singing lessons with the Boston City Singers. Not all of the youngest singers know all the details about the deadly blasts, but they know Jane was among the more than 260 people injured in the attack. Jane Richard lost a leg in the explosions; the children's mother, Denise, was seriously injured.

    When a group of 4-to-6-year-old singers went back to Boston City Singers on Wednesday, parents were invited to stay if they wanted, managing director Melissa Graham said. Everything went well even when one little boy had a question about their missing classmate she said.

    "One little boy said, 'Janie got hurt, is she going to be OK?'" Graham said. "And the conductor said, 'Yes, Janie is going to be OK. That was just an accident. Janie got hurt, she is going to be OK.'"

    Boston City Singers charges tuition but does not turn away children on a financial basis, and makes up for costs with fundraising and grants, Graham said. The same way the children forget about whose parents have more money while making a song together, she said, maybe they will forget about the bombings for a little while when the youth choral group performs at "Children Sing for Peace" on Saturday at St. Mark Church in Dorchester.

    The concert, which includes the Cambridge Children's Chorus and other local singing groups, will be about community and not about the bombs allegedly set off by brothers Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev. Other singers will come from the local Neighborhood House Charter School, which Jane and Martin attended and where their mother works.

    "Song is one of those things that unites people," Graham said. "It gives the community a chance to feel like they are doing something."

    The same need for expression was clear to Margery Buckingham when children came into the Dorchester Arts Collaborative on Tuesday. She said the week of arts and crafts she had planned for the 8-to-12-year-olds would not continue as though nothing had happened.

    In a press conference a victim of the Boston Marathon bombing shares the story that left her with an amputated leg.

    "One little girl said how she didn't sleep all night because she was so frightened," said Buckingham, education director at the collaborative, which fosters the arts in Dorchester.

    Heidi Katz, an arts therapist from nearby Roxbury, Mass., came in on Thursday, Buckingham said. She did drawings and spoke with the children, and brought rhythm instruments for them to play. She asked the children where they felt safe.

    "With most of our children it was at home and in church," Buckingham said. "And one little girl said, 'In my heart.'"

    Buckingham called parents to let them known beforehand that the arts therapist would be coming, in case they did not want their children to participate. All the children showed up, and parents sent two more.

    "It's something we have to do again," Buckingham said. "These feelings aren't going to go away."

    Related stories:

    • Source: Bombing suspect showed no fear or remorse during hospital hearing
    • Mother of Boston suspects insists sons not responsible
    • Family connections can be key in journey down terrorism path
    • Full coverage of the Boston Marathon tragedy from NBC News

    13 comments

    The Muslim terrorist cockroach members of the patently evil paramilitary Satanic cult of death, destruction, and hate called "Islam" will continue to rape, pillage, plunder, and slaughter the innocent men, women, children, youth, and elders of our great nation in the names of their fecal deity "Alla …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: art, terrorism, children, boston, bombing, survivors, featured, boston-marathon-tragedy
  • 25
    Apr
    2013
    10:07pm, EDT

    Source: Bombing suspect showed no fear or remorse during hospital hearing

    NBC's Michael Isikoff reports on what a source, inside the hospital room with Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, is telling him about Tsarnaev's interaction with investigators. NBC analyst Roger Cressey also joins to discuss what authorities are now saying about the Tsarnaev brothers' possible plans for an attack on New York City.

    By Michael Isikoff, National Investigative Correspondent, NBC News

    A badly wounded but awake Dzhokhar Tsarnaev showed little signs of fear or remorse during his hospital room court hearing earlier this week and his heart monitor didn’t register a blip when he was told he was facing the death penalty in the Boston Marathon bombing case, according to a source familiar with the events inside the hospital room when he was read his rights.


    Follow @NBCNewsUS

    Tsarnaev’s face was splotched and swollen, his left hand was bandaged, and he was unable to talk during the brief court hearing presided over by U.S. Judge Marianne Bowler on Monday afternoon.

    The surviving bombing suspect mouthed rather than said the word “no” when asked if he could afford a lawyer and nodded in the affirmative when asked if he understood his rights.

    But Tsarnaev appeared to fully follow the proceeding, the source said. The most telling moment, the source said, came early on when, after Tsarnaev was informed of the two charges against him, the judge asked prosecutor William Weinreb to spell out the possible penalties he was facing.


    “Your honor, the maximum penalty is death,” Weinreb said, according to a public transcript of the proceeding.

     

    Tsarnaev showed no reaction — nor did his heart monitor register any change, the source said. “There was no blip at all,” said the source.

    But heart monitors don’t always register emotional responses — and there is no way to tell what impact medications Tsarmaev may have been given had, according to medical experts.

    There have also been conflicting reports about Tsarnaev’s mental state in the days after his capture. “Over the weekend, he’s in and out of lucidity,” Rep. Mike Rogers, chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said on MSNBC’s “Andrea Mitchell” show on Thursday. “He’s got — he’s on medication, he’s talking, but he’s not talking, he’s unconscious, he’s going for medical procedures.”

    But those present at the bedside court hearing were convinced that Tsarnaev was fully cognizant of the circumstances he was facing, the source said. Judge Bowler agreed. “I find the defendant is alert, mentally competent and lucid,” she said, according to the transcript. “He is aware of the nature of the proceedings.”

    Handout / FBI via Reuters

    Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, 19, has been charged in the Boston Marathon bombing.

    The court proceeding erupted as a source of controversy Thursday when Rogers charged that Judge Bowler had interfered with FBI questioning of Tsarnaev – and that the Justice Department failed to object — when she ordered that Tsarnaev be read his rights on Monday, a day after he was charged in a then-sealed complaint at 6:47 p.m. Sunday.

     

    FBI agents were questioning Tsarnaev — and getting his responses in writing — under a “public safety exception” that allows agents to obtain information from criminal suspects for 48 hours without reading them their constitutional rights informing them they have the right to remain silent and a right to a lawyer. The information that agents got — including the disclosure Thursday that Tsarnaev and his brother had talked about driving to Times Square to set off more bombs — came during those sessions over the weekend.

    But Rogers said Thursday that FBI agents “weren’t quite finished with him” when Bowler directed that the court hearing take place that Monday. “To have the court affirmatively push their way in, is — A) I think it's wrong, and B) we should have given the FBI the time that they needed.” Justice Department officials “have a lot of explaining to do.”

    Bowler, asked by NBC News about Rogers’ charges in her federal courtroom in Boston Thursday, replied: “The court does not comment.”

    A  federal law enforcement official disputed Rogers’ account, telling NBC News that FBI agents had already left the hospital room and wrapped up their questioning before the court hearing took place mid-day Monday. In a statement emailed to reporters Thursday, Justice Department spokesman Dean Boyd said that, after the criminal complaint was filed, the rules of criminal procedure required the judge to advice the defendant of his rights. 

    “The prosecutors and FBI agents in Boston were advised of the scheduled initial appearance in advance of its occurrence,” he said. 

    Related stories

    • NYC has 'smart' camera network to thwart terror attacks
    • Boston suspects' mom: 'America took my kids away'
    • Talking terrorism at dinner: When families radicalize

     

    534 comments

    But heart monitors don't always register emotional responses — and there is no way to tell what impact medications Tsarmaev may have been given had, according to medical experts.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, boston, crime, boston-marathon-bombing, dzhokhar-tsarnaev
  • 24
    Apr
    2013
    11:32am, EDT

    MIT and nation mourn Sean Collier, officer with a common touch

    Thousands of mourners attended a memorial service for Sean Collier, the MIT police officer who authorities say was gunned down by the Boston marathon bombing suspects. His stepbrother Rob Rogers told the crowd, "People have asked me, if Sean were here, what would he think? Are you kidding me? He would love this. You've got sirens. Flashing lights. Formations. People saluting. Bagpipes. Taps. The American flag. He would have loved it. He was born to be a police officer, and he lived out his dreams."

    By Bill Dedman and Matthew DeLuca
    NBC News

    Vice President Biden spoke at the memorial for slain MIT police officer Sean Collier and condemned terrorism, saying, "Boston, you sent a powerful message to the world."

    CAMBRIDGE, Mass. – Two young men about the same age apparently crossed paths last Thursday night in the Kendall Square area, on the campus of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. One was an MIT police officer known for his extraordinary ease at building relationships with foreign students. The other was an immigrant from the Caucasus.

    Perhaps if they'd met in a different circumstance, Tamerlan Tsarnaev would have taken a liking to Officer Sean A. Collier. Everybody else seemed to.

    On a campus where 40 percent of graduate students are from other countries, where their experience with police officers may be limited to violent confrontation, students found an exuberant friend in the 27-year-old Collier. In only 15 months on campus, he found a place in its heart. Collier joined the Outing Club to learn winter hiking, and trained with students by running stairs at night, sometimes in his uniform if he was on duty. "When we did a day hike in plaid flannel to yodel off of a mountain, Sean was the most enthusiastic yodeler of all of us," recalled alumnus Maddie Hickman. When he worked security at a school dance, he decided he'd better take dancing lessons, so he wouldn't be embarrassed the next time he showed off his footwork.

    TODAY

    Officer Sean A. Collier, 27, of the MIT Police was killed April 18 in Cambridge.

    Collier was shot dead in his police car on April 18, apparently as the Tsarnaev brothers made a failed attempt to get another weapon. The killing of Collier and a carjacking eventually led to the death that night of Tamerlan Tsarnaev, 26, during a shootout with police in neighboring Watertown. It also eventually led to the capture on Friday afternoon of his 19-year-old brother, Dzhokhar, who is facing federal charges in the April 15 bombings at the finish line of the Boston Marathon.

    The MIT community mourned Collier on Wednesday with a powerful midday memorial service on the baseball and softball facility, Briggs Field, about a five-minute walk across campus from where he died. Fifteen thousand chairs were filled with a sea of blue caps worn by law enforcement officers from around the nation. A huge American flag waved from the tips of two fire department ladders. Collier's casket was placed on a bier.

    The service began with mournful bagpipes and ended with the playing of taps, then a flyover by police helicopters. Vice President Joe Biden spoke, paying tribute not only to Collier and his family, but to the families of all law enforcement officers. James Taylor sang the folk song "The Water is Wide" with the MIT Symphony Orchestra and then his "Shower the People" with MIT a cappella ensembles. A handmade sign displayed prior to the memorial proclaimed "Collier Strong," a play on the "Boston Strong" meme. Students who couldn't get into the memorial gathered around campus to watch the live video feed.

     

    The siblings of MIT Police Officer Sean A. Collier, 27, who was killed April 18, describe their brother on the TODAY Show.

    Related: Family of Officer Collier on TODAY: "Sean was such a good person"

    How could a police officer meet so many students in barely a year on campus? MIT Police Chief John DiFava offered his explanation.

    "He was the same person in uniform then when he wasn't wearing the uniform," DiFava said. "He was able to achieve a level of trust with people of many different backgrounds that was truly remarkable. ... Many of our students come from countries where the police really are not their friends. ... Sean understood this right away. He made it his mission to achieve their trust."

    Young Officer Collier, fresh out of the state police academy, applied his own brand of community policing. He lived in neighboring Somerville, where he had worked as a civilian for the police department and was planning to begin a job as an officer this summer.

    "People have asked me, if Sean were here, what would he think?" said his stepbrother Rob Rogers. "Are you kidding me? He would love this. You’ve got sirens. Flashing lights. Formations. People saluting. Bagpipes. Taps. The American flag. He would have loved it. He was born to be a police officer, and he lived out his dreams."

    Hickman, the former student, posted her memories of Collier along with other students on the Outing Club's website.

    Slideshow: Aftermath and reaction following Boston bombings

    Dominick Reuter / Reuters

    Heightened security, empty streets, and memorials mark the the day after the Boston Marathon bombings.

    Launch slideshow

    "He wanted to get involved in countless other student organizations across campus," Hickman wrote. "He loved the MIT community, and loved getting to know students and becoming a part of the MIT culture. ... He was good at making lasting connections, not just at striking up conversations, and we became close friends. I ran into him regularly on campus, and stopped by often to chat through the window of his police cruiser, or on his patrols. Sean cared a lot about his job, and he cared intensely about people; he worked long hours, but always made time to stop and chat. He was incredibly easy-going and friendly, and we'd talk regularly - about life and the world, or just being silly.

    "Sean used to stop by the student center while on shift, and often came by the MIT Lindy Hop dance in uniform," Hickman said. "At first, some of the dancers were nervous at the 'police presence' in the room, but Sean made friends quickly and stood by the door to hang out and chat. In the spirit of trying new things, he even started taking swing dancing lessons in his time off, so he could participate in future dances 'without being embarrassed,' as he said."

    Chief DiFava said he saw Collier about 9:30 last Thursday night, and pulled alongside his police car. He said Collier said he was "just making sure everyone is behaving." An hour later, DiFava said, he got the phone call.

    As the memorial continued, police snipers held positions on the tops of buildings.

    Biden called the perpetrators of the marathon bombing "twisted, perverted, cowardly, knockoff jihadis." He said he's often asked why terrorists do what they do. "They do it to instill fear," he said. "The irony is, we read about these events, we experience them, but the truth is, on every frontier, terrorism as a weapon is losing. It is not gaining adherents." He called for Americans to hold firm to their values. "The moment we get in a crouch and are defensive, is the moment they win. ... We have not yielded to our fears. We have not compromised our values. We have not weakened our constitutional guarantees. We have not closed our borders. ... We will not hunker down. We will not be intimidated."

    DeLuca reported from the memorial in Cambridge.

    MIT has created a Sean A. Collier Memorial Fund, which will support a Collier Medal to be awarded to people who demonstrate Collier's values. And his family has suggested that memorial gifts be made to the Jimmy Fund of the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston.

    23 comments

    As a mountain lover--I can see Mt. Washington as I write, what most impressed me about what I have read about Sean was his willingness to join the Outing Club and learn winter hiking. That he could hang out as an equal with some of the smartest people on the planet tells us what kind of man he was.  …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, boston, crime, mit, boston-marathon, sean-collier
  • 24
    Apr
    2013
    4:01am, EDT

    After hospital, where will Boston bombing suspect go?

    FBI via Reuters

    Dzhokhar Tsarnaev is at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center now. The feds will have to figure out where he goes next while awaiting trial.

    By Tracy Connor, Staff Writer, NBC News

    Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev has been hospitalized since his arrest, but if his condition continues to improve he will soon experience the hospitality of a high-security lockup while waiting for a trial that could be two years away, experts say.

    "As soon as he is medically cleared, he'll be moved," said Steven Swensen, a former U.S. marshal who now runs a judicial security consulting firm. "This is a high-threat, high-profile situation."

    Tsarnaev's condition improved from serious to fair on Tuesday. But his injuries -- including a gunshot wound to the head and neck that could be self-inflicted -- were so severe he initially communicated with investigators in writing.

    The hospital and FBI have not released details of his treatment at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, where he was under heavy guard, or given any hint of when he might be released.

    Video from a restaurant surveillance camera shows Dzhokhar Tsarnaev walking toward the scene of the second bombing and slipping his backpack off, investigators say. NBC's Pete Williams reports.

    When it happens, the U.S. marshals and federal prosecutors will have to weigh distance from the courthouse against security and medical needs in choosing a new temporary home for the suspect.

    Federal prisoners are sometimes sent to the Plymouth County Jail, which can handle high-risk prisoners but does not have extensive medical facilities. The state's Shattuck Hospital has a jail unit and is only about 20 minutes from the courthouse.

    Further afield, there's the Wyatt Detention Center in Central Falls, R.I., a privately run maximum-security federal detention facility less than an hour's drive Boston, or the federal prison hospital at Fort Devens in Harvard, Mass.

    If it's Wyatt, Tsarnaev would be far from the first high-value prisoner locked up there. Rezwan Ferdus, who pleaded guilty to trying to fly bomb-laden model aircraft into the Capitol and the Pentagon, spent 399 days in solitary confinement at the facility before he was sentenced.

    But the 771-inmate center has just four hospital beds, according to its annual report, and it became the subject of controversy in 2008 when an immigration detainee died of advanced cancer and the feds found he had been neglected.

    Devens is a medical facility but doesn't typically house suspects before sentencing. The Bureau of Prisons said it can handle detainees of any security-risk level, but it's also about an hour from Boston.

    Wherever he ends up, experts said, Tsarnaev will likely be subject to special administrative measures that could sharply curtail his contact with fellow prisoners and the outside world.

    Elise Amendola / AP file

    Devens Federal Medical Center is seen in Devens, Mass., in December 2011.

    Stephen Huggard, a former Boston federal prosecutor who worked on the 9/11 investigation, said Tsarnaev's parents, who are in Russia and have insisted he's being framed, may not even be allowed to visit.

    How long the University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth student spends in a local lockup depends in large part on whether prosecutors decide to seek the death penalty -- a decision that is months away and will ultimately be made by Attorney General Eric Holder.

    If the marathon bombing becomes a capital case, it could be "a couple a years" before a jury decides his fate, Huggard said.

    Tsarnaev, 19, hasn't even been arraigned yet.

    He nodded answers to a few questions at a cut-and-dried initial appearance before a magistrate in his hospital bed after being charged with one count of using a weapon of mass destruction and a second count of malicious use of an explosive.

    The next step is for a grand jury to vote on an indictment. Technically, prosecutors have 30 days to get that done, but legal experts agree the deadline is likely to waived by both sides while they continue to investigate.

    The suspect's next court date, May 30, would then be a status hearing, and he would not be arraigned until the indictment -- which could contain more charges and evidence than the criminal complaint signed this week -- is issued.

    "There is no reason to rush at this point," said Dan Collins, a former federal prosecutor in Minnesota who worked on the Mumbai bombing case.

    Tsarnaev has been assigned three federal public defenders who are likely, given what legal analysts describe as overwhelming evidence, to open discussions about a plea deal that would keep their client off death row at the "supermax" prison in Terre Haute, Ind.


    Follow @NBCNewsUS

    "It wouldn't shock me if this ends in a plea," Huggard said.

    "This is a kid, and as heinous as his acts are, he acted atypically for what we would expect for a terrorist," he said, noting that Tsarnaev was back at school and the gym after the bombing and before the bloody rampage that led to his arrest.

    "Does it mean he didn't fully comprehend what he was doing? That's going to get explored by both sides."

    But Huggard added that if Tsarnaev was telling the truth when he reportedly told investigators he and his older brother Tamerlan were lone actors and not sponsored or deployed by a terrorist cabal, it may make it harder to get the death penalty off the table.

    "Then he has nothing to offer," he said. "Then he's just a guy who decided he wanted to blow up America."

    Related:

    • Bomb suspects' phones, computers show no sign of accomplice
    • Wife of dead bombing suspect in 'absolute shock'
    • FBI quizzes members of mosque suspect attended

     

    561 comments

    To HELL I hope. When he dies 'an Islamic martyr', I hope his seventy-two virgins are Catholic nuns with steel rulers.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: terrorism, bombing, prison, featured, boston-marathon-tragedy, dzhokhar-tsarneav
Older posts

Browse

  • featured,
  • crime,
  • military,
  • weather,
  • california,
  • updated,
  • florida,
  • environment,
  • us-news,
  • shooting,
  • new-york,
  • texas,
  • education,
  • chicago,
  • police,
  • gulf-oil-spill,
  • kari-huus,
  • nbcnewyork,
  • los-angeles,
  • murder,
  • new-jersey,
  • guns,
  • afghanistan,
  • obama,
  • colorado,
  • sandy,
  • trayvon-martin,
  • nbclosangeles,
  • barack-obama,
  • crime-and-courts,
  • politics,
  • gay,
  • veterans,
  • connecticut,
  • fire,
  • arizona,
  • snow,
  • crime-courts,
  • religion
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

Jeff Black, Staff Writer

I'm a senior writer and editor working on the news team.

Tracy Connor, Staff Writer, NBC News

Archives

  • 2013
    • May (375)
    • April (608)
    • March (548)
    • February (510)
    • January (563)
  • 2012
    • December (457)
    • November (460)
    • October (477)
    • September (432)
    • August (525)
    • July (519)
    • June (508)
    • May (566)
    • April (538)
    • March (576)
    • February (471)
    • January (417)
  • 2011
    • December (455)
    • November (190)
    • October (9)
    • September (3)
    • August (51)
    • July (8)
    • June (3)
    • May (12)
    • April (5)
    • March (3)
    • February (1)
    • January (8)
  • 2010
    • December (5)
    • November (1)
    • October (2)
    • September (28)
    • August (40)
    • July (35)
    • June (177)
    • May (50)
    • April (9)
    • March (2)
    • February (2)
    • January (4)
  • 2009
    • December (5)
    • November (5)
    • October (2)
    • September (11)
    • August (4)
    • July (12)
    • June (1)
    • May (1)
    • April (1)
    • March (3)
    • February (3)
    • January (2)
  • 2008
    • December (3)
    • November (2)
    • October (6)
    • September (30)
    • August (26)
    • July (10)
    • June (4)
    • May (8)
    • April (13)
    • March (9)
    • February (7)
    • January (6)
  • 2007
    • December (10)
    • November (6)
    • October (22)
    • September (11)

Most Commented

  • Man with ties to Boston bombing suspect admits role in 2011 murders; shot during FBI questioning (2106)
  • Boy Scouts vote to lift ban on gay youth (4246)
  • US judge rules department of 'toughest sheriff' engages in racial profiling (1442)
  • At least 51 killed, including 20 children, as tornado tears through Oklahoma (1807)
  • Scouts await decision on gay membership (2226)
  • Zimmerman defense releases texts about guns, fighting from Trayvon Martin's phone (1730)
  • Jodi Arias pleads for jury to spare her life, says, 'I want everyone's pain to stop' (854)

Other blogs

  • The Body Odd
  • Cosmic Log
  • Red Tape Chronicles
  • PhotoBlog
  • Open Channel

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • US news on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise